Stephen Archibald did a blog on this...
https://halifaxbloggers.ca/noticedinnova...dinary-new-building-on-gottingen-street/
A few excerpts below:
Quote:
So what is there to amuse the poor pedestrians as they trek along the sidewalk past the grim rectangle? Why, that would be the 160-year-old gates that have been preserved, but have not led anywhere for 70 years or so.
|
Quote:
Finally the big reveal. The gates were built as the entrance to the Wellington Barracks, the largest buildings in Nova Scotia in the 1860s. Through a passageway in the soldier’s barracks, you catch a glimpse of the officers’ barracks on the other side of the large Parade Square. All very grand, don’t you think?
|
Quote:
So where does that leave us? The gates, that are now considered a monument to the Royal Canadian Regiment, might suggest a path forward. Maybe tableaux, like the gates, that tell stories about the base, could be inserted into the wall. And if nothing else, remember that before the present concrete wall, the stone wall was far taller and rather wacky. A little of that goes a long way.
|
In my opinion, yeah the new building is bleak, and the new wall even more bleak, but sometimes buildings just have to be functional. Not everything can be built with streetside cafes. This building will have great function to provide training for our military, who have the job of providing protection for our country, so in this case function is a higher priority over form. FWIW, it's no less bleak and imaginative than the ubiquitous glass box that everybody coos over because it's tall and shiny, but they are still just featureless boxes.
Another function over form building that comes to mind is the Irving Shipbuilding/Halifax Shipyard structure. It is basically a series of big white boxes, but what happens inside is necessary and extraordinary. Function over form has to happen sometime...