Quote:
Originally Posted by SevenSquared
I'm still not convinced we needed a bigger rink, but rather a newer rink downtown. Time will tell if going huge for an extra $20-30M was justified, or if it was another case of thinking a little too big.
|
I agree that a newer (and preferably downtown) arena was desperately needed. The Coliseum had a number of issues and location was certainly one of them.
In terms of size, here's a comparison of similar size CMAs and similar size arenas:
Population is most recent census CMA/CA listing, with arena and capacity:
London (494K) Budweiser Gardens (9,100)
Halifax (403K) Metro Centre (11,093)
Victoria (368K) Save-On-Foods (7,006/9,000 for concerts)
Windsor (345K) WFCU Centre (6,500)
Saskatoon (295K) SaskTel Centre (15,100)
Regina (237K) Brandt Centre (~6,500)
St. John's (206K) Mile One (7,000)
Barrie (197K) Molson Centre (4,195)
Kingston (161K) K-ROCK Centre (5,614)
Guelph (152K) Sleeman Centre (5,100)
Moncton (144K) Events Centre (~9,000)
Saint John (126K) Harbour Station (6,308)
Peterborough (122K) Memorial Centre (3,729)
So similar to Victoria/London's arenas at a fraction of the population base. If you extend the Events Centre's geographic reach to Southeast NB for concerts and events you're looking at a capture-area population of 200K+, which would make it slightly larger than St. John's building.
I don't mind Moncton going a little big with its building. It's a growing community and one that sees itself on a more prevalent stage in the future. It's ambitious but potentially better than being hemmed in by a smaller building in ~20 years. SaskTel in Saskatoon is a good example of a building slowly expanding to suit its needs for events (originally built sub-10K, IIRC).