Quote:
Originally Posted by jsbrook
I don't see the problem. I'm happy to see the Market East building get some tenants, and the Arch Street building will do well as apartments.
|
I should clarify that I don't personally view it as a problem. The wealthy suburban brokers in my office think it's the downfall of mankind as they think the current location (1400 block of Arch) is the "nastiest in the city." The simple truth is that this tenant means long long lines of people awaiting court hearings/sentencings. At the 1401 location, they crowd most of the sidewalk, are often miserable (as anyone would be awaiting an appointment in court), can break it into screaming arguments, are smoking various things all across the sidewalk, etc. There are often sheriff's buses (retrofitted schoolbuses for prisoners...oh the irony, don't get me started on the state of criminal justice and education in this country) sitting outside waiting to load up and take people away. Long story short, some people don't like acknowledging that this is a reality for many people in this country, and would rather see such a facility somehow hidden from public view. I take issue with that, but if you live a life of sufficient privilege to worry only about how such an operation makes YOU feel or makes your friends/family feel as you show them around town or walk from cocktails to dinner, then that's a stance you can take.
Practically speaking, it is a 9-5 operation, so there are several hours of the day (all daytime hours) where crowds of people gather out of a facility like this, and they are an unavoidable reminder of many things that make many people uncomfortable: questions of race, class, criminal justice, poverty, "society's woes", unequal distribution of wealth/opportunity etc, etc.
So all that said, a use like this obviously has to go somewhere, and if you think about this as an unfortunate but very necessary service of the government, then it should really go in a maximally accessible location, which means it would've/should've wound up somewhere along the major spines of our transit system. So from a service/equity/service provision standpoint, both its current and future locations are very appropriate. In a future where Market East is chock full of flashing billboards and thousands of shoppers veering between different mixed use complexes, will it feel like an anomaly and a surprising and sudden change in the environment? Yes. Can a densely packed, activity filled corridor absorb such a use without being ruined? Absolutely.