Quote:
Originally Posted by jl4069
Have to say that the progress since August September is very very small.
Have a look at page 211 of this thread to see the progress from September. I gotta go by the site a see how much activity is going on. The latest pictures show almost no one on the roof. Painfully slow. j
|
Using that reasoning, how many people do you count on 220 CPS? Is that moving too slow as well? I think you're assuming that there is a full workforce on these towers every day, which there isn't. There are some sites that have an active workforce on the weekends, but not many.
As far as how slow the progress is here, it's slow, but it's not like we're waiting for the most dynamic tower to get built. If this were the only game in town, I might be more concerned with the pace, due to the excitement. But there is simply way too much going on in New York to get concerned about it. Barnett could put this on ice for a couple of years, and I wouldn't be bothered. This just happens to be the
tallest of the new supertall towers being built in New York. It's hardly the most exciting. It will dominate from sheer size of course.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Prezrezc
As for this spire or no spire argument, I've concluded that for where it is, the addition really isn't needed. Its simplistic contours in juxtaposition between One57 and 220CPS easily catch the eye without drawing too much attention to itself, which IMO adding the spire *would* do.
|
Is that not what the tallest towers are supposed to do? Is not the Empire State such an icon because it was the tallest, the spire topping a vast skyline of other skyscrapers, screaming "look at me"?
This tower will be the tallest in Midtown, with or without the spire. It will stand above the Empire State, One Vanderbilt, 111 W. 57th, 30 Hudson, the Chrysler, 53W53, BofA, all towers that have an apex with variations on the New York spire/crown that the skyline is known for, all standing above row after row of boxes (people don't generally think of buildings like the GE, Met Life, Chase, as skyline defining towers).
The New York skyline is seen from a number of angles, most often not the ones we generally think of. This building will matter more than others because it will be the most visible. As is currently planned, the apex doesn't do this city or it's skyline justice. But it will be what it will be. It will be thrown into the mix same as the others. It just should have been a better representation of a skyline defining tower in New York.