Quote:
Originally Posted by King Kill 'em
And still some of Ocenawide's stores will face the street. If anything it will have a better pedestrian experience than circa or metropolis because it's garage entrances are less obstructive and its podium is less massive and overbearing.
|
The issue isn't that "some" retail will face the street, but that besides a few stores, the majority of the retail will be in a massive, indoor mall. Imagine, instead, that all the retail not facing the street instead lined Main, or Broadway, or Olive. By placing retail inside malls, you create a glut of retail and remove the demand for more commercial space. Every store that moves in to LA Central is a store that could have been in a street-facing retail space. Malls like that which are planned in LA Central or Metropolis consolidate retail in to small islands around downtown that one can drive in and out of without ever venturing in the rest of the city. Retail shouldn't be isolated to a few dense spots, but instead distributed evenly across a neighborhood. That is how a walkable neighborhood forms.
Moreover, the very idea of creating a "tourist district" is silly. Tourism is a natural process. A city can't force tourism in one area. Tourists visit Times Square because of what that neighborhood represents within culture as a whole, not just because there are big flashing screens. Why should Tourists come visit South Park? To see smaller, flashing screens and some parking lots? How is South Park supposed to draw tourists by being a cheap pastiche of Times Square. A city should build neighborhoods to be lived in. Tourism is a natural byproduct of that. Take SoHo for instance. SoHo became a tourist destination because it was a hip, desirable, and
livable neighborhood first. Tourists wanted a piece of what residents had. Or, more locally, consider downtown Santa Monica and The Pier. I've lived in Santa Monica my entire life. Sure, there were always tourists at The Pier, but the majority of downtown Santa Monica was for locals. There was local retail. Prices were cheap. Crowds not as dense. Tourism increased over time not because the city deemed The Pier to be a tourist attraction, but because The Pier, and downtown Santa Monica, was a fully formed local draw. The same needs to happen to the rest of downtown, let alone South Park.