Quote:
Originally Posted by Keith P.
However, those cold climates you cite are different from ours. There, it gets cold and stays cold for months. Here, it can be -15 one day and +10 the next, with lots of moisture and freeze/thaw cycles through the course of a winter. Those are what play hell with masonry structures. The wet climate here also has a lot to do with the decay of wooden structures. The original comment was overstated somewhat, but is not totally groundless either.
|
I think if you research the weather patterns of most populated areas of Canada you would find that they all experience weather variations/temperature fluctuations. Halifax is not unique in that respect.
Regardless, the original comment could be considered 'not totally groundless' if you are saying in broad terms that "the environment in general causes all structures to degrade over time". Every climate has its challenges, yes, and those challenges extend to all structures, regardless of materials/building techniques.
Saying brick and mortar doesn't hold up well in our climate is ludicrous. Look at basically
all the 100-plus-year-old structures on Barrington that you would like to have torn down, and realize that many of them have had 'zero' maintenance done to them in the past half-century at least. How many buildings of any style will hold up to that kind of neglect?
The arguments against the Khyber, as I see it, come from how the population values (or doesn't) the arts community, and not the esthetic/historical value of the building. If you take comments posted at the end of a news article to be a cross-section of society (which I believe is far from the actual situation), then it appears that many people don't understand the richness that an arts community ads to society and would only notice the negative effects if it ceased to exist. They can't believe that there is value in the city suggesting to basically 'give' them the building in order to be used for cultural purposes. All they see is lost $$$.
Then there's the lunatic fringe who see no value in history or architecture whatsoever and think that we would be better off just leveling everything that doesn't fit their idea of being 'useful'. IMHO, in a business environment these people have a useful role in keeping things from going too crazy, but thank the deity of your choice that they don't make all the decisions for us....