Quote:
Originally Posted by red-paladin
I'm pro-Pacific Centre, but I can't understand the obsession with indoor malls for downtown.
"Our City is fine but, if only we had a massive mall we'd move up the global city charts!" - Said Edmonton in 1979.
Don't get me wrong, I support the growth of retail, mixed use and yes, a certain amount of enclosed mall space. I think that this project in particular was right on to integrate the basement to Pacific Centre (and Skytrain!). Lots can be done in this area for sure in the future.
However, as International Village, and some smaller projects downtown have shown, even the tepid failure of the original Royal Centre vision. There isn't an insatiable demand for indoor malls downtown.
|
Indoor malls brighten up and enliven the surrounding streets. With a concentration of retail tenants, management can also provide better services like security, garbage removal & cleanliness, etc. Just look at Nordstrom and PC mall, the surrounding sidewalks are usually kept pretty clean, and the homeless do not camp over there. In contrast just across Granville St., the walkways servicing the street retailers are often unkempt, dirty and stinky. During periods of heavy rain and wind-swept days, I always see loads of people congregating in PC mall. Indoor malls are epitomes of urban social hubs and they can be updated to today's standards, and even incorporate outdoor elements, to pacify those sun-worshippers. They can also host exhibitions, small museums and theme parks, etc, as in the case of Aberdeen Centre and West Edmonton Mall. In the downtown environment, good public indoor space is just as important as the outdoor ones, and other than malls, most indoor spaces are restricted to the selected few, which is kind of sad when one needs to hang out indoors after dark, or when the weather isn't optimal. Moreover, more retail shops can hopefully bring down the overall rental rates in the city, thus attracting more local retailers to set up shop downtown.
I like Nordstrom for bringing the variety of high fashion concept boutiques, as well as food and beverage into their large-format indoor mall/department store format. One thing lacking is the food hall that everyone loves. Now that we have a high-end department store (Nordstrom) as well as lower range (Winners), downtown definitely needs more mid-range retailers like Simons, Uniqlo, Toys r Us or even Ikea to not only take up shop here, but occupying a new attractive building, which is obviously lacking. The General Post Office or Bay parkade sites would be perfect for them, while a mixed-use development of the sites, be it residential, hotel, or office use, can add even more vibrancy.