Quote:
Originally Posted by Denver
For everyone bitching about the design of the Alexan and Speer proposals, here is my rant. It takes two seconds to realize that the rendering is a conceptual proposal that appears intended to show massing more so than design. Just look at what EnV (aka Joule) looked like at this point in the design process. Now as anyone who has driven down Speer would know, Env looks a lot better in person than it does in the early renderings. This is not to say that the final design new building (what are we calling it?) will satisfy everyone but rather to point out that it is way to early for anyone to start bitching about the design.
As far as the Alexan proposal goes, all I am going to say is that it is a hell of a lot better than what is there now and that the design could have turned out much much much worse that what Kephart is proposing. I really do not understand how people on DI are complaining about the design as much as they are. I personally think it looks pretty great.
On a side note, I love the progression of many of the DI commenters and people on this thread. First we complain that not enough buildings are being built in Denver. Then when buildings are built we complain that all we are getting are boxy stick builds. Then when developers pony up the cash for a larger building we complain about the design, color, and lack of retail. Isn't there a point where we can just be happy that our urban fabric is being rebuilt without needless complaining about the designs of many of the buildings currently being built? If the design truly is horrible (Aloft) then yes, lets bitch and moan. But come on....this is getting old fast.
Rant over. Thank you for your time.
|
Disliking, pig like massing on buildings is understandable. I am not sure why you are complaining at us for having opinions. Its not like we have veto power on these projects ;0 and even in my post I commented on still being glad to see a project go live in the area. My dream is the developer sees this and they have a moment of enlightenment when they realize they are building something people have to live in and look at for a long time and its worth a little on the margins! (I know I am dreaming)
We 'build', go figure, our environments and as we have seen in the past its not hard to mess it up. I am not sure massing like we are seeing is a good thing. Maybe we have entered in the age of manufactured high rises and they just happen to resemble commie blocks, or porky pigs (Again, I am not talking about density, purely massing, and really just above the 5th floor for any 9 story or higher building.)
Its not about the litpstick, its the fact its a pig. Giraffes are so much cooler!! What would you rather be surrounded by: Pigs or Giraffes? Give me some height variance across the block. Prices are high enough to warrant it. If the Alexan AS was a half block development I would have no issues..
I am sorry my opinion irks you. I am all for development, but I think with any evolutionary system (city development for example), debate and discussion is a good thing.. Don't forget that, like our society has.