Quote:
Originally Posted by 65MAX
It's most definitely in a VERY prominent location. I mean, how much more visible can you get than MLK and Burnside? And gimmicky and garish?.... absolutely. But the building is actually designed to be very functional and pleasant to be in. Ground floor retail; high, exposed beam ceilings in open, flexible creative space; plenty of bike parking (zero auto parking); skybridges joining the two main volumes on all levels. Also, 20% glazing is actually not too shabby, considering you'll be able to see out at least three sides of the building from the center of the (relatively small for a commercial building) open offices. The Portland Building is a very large floor plate combined with miniscule windows, therefore the lack of natural light is exponentially worse.
I was also worried about the maintenance of the exterior at first. But they're using a high grade stucco finish that would require almost no maintenance and should last for at least 50 years or more. So that lively pattern should be around longer than all of us.
|
OK, I'll take one more shot at this then I will be done. I don't want to become PDXDensity MkII.
I would ask those that like this design to imagine this building painted a solid color. still like it? it would be two connected boxes with too few randomly placed windows (20% is
abysmal BTW). its entire concept (parti) relies on the painted pattern. I'm sorry, but that's just poor design. either lazy or cheap, take your pick, but in the end the designer takes a severe shortcut to relevancy by using an audacious skin to cover the lack of design rigor applied to the entirety of the building. given the location and visibility I personally find that inexcusable.
and don't be fooled by the use of "high grade" stucco. it's still a painted pattern on top of the stucco. it will require maintenance and occasionally need to be repainted. in order to look decent in the long term it will require an owner committed to keeping up the appearance. does this owner have that? will this owner be around in ten years? thirty years? there's absolutely no guarantee that this building won't look like crap in a relatively short time, and there's no hiding at this location.
I would be happy to see something interesting, even severe, at this location. but you simply can't fake good design.