Quote:
Originally Posted by Obadno
As I've reiterated countless times, Id rather have a city of these 5 story projects than single family homes with the occasional out of place Mono-use 20-30 story tower.
|
Nobody is arguing for single-family homes and mono-use towers to be built, though. It doesn't always need to be such an extreme either/or when it comes to projects.
Tempe, in spite of its growth and ability to attract urban investment, is still a suburb of Phoenix that has a relatively small amount of land in its downtown to potentially (re)develop. 5-story projects can definitely be beneficial if well-designed. But, the issue many have with this particular project is:
1) its location: this is probably the largest remaining privately-owned parcel that has frontage on either University or Mill, and this one is actually nearly adjacent to the intersection of both. Tempe has planned for heights up to 300' in its downtown, has invested in additional mass transit (streetcar), and has produced a lot of policies encouraging smart urban growth and increased population clustered around walkable services, etc. To accomplish those goals, it makes sense for people to want a project at this location to deliver more than just 100 rental units in 6 stories.
2) its design: yes, a downtown lined with midrise buildings that are well-designed and create/add to an urban experience at the ground level are great; however, this midrise is being built with a large blank wall facing Ash, a street in need of projects that are planned with the streetcar in mind to encourage transit-oriented development along the rest of the lots.
3) its predecessor: the last proposal for this site was just really great, so it makes this even harder to swallow; Mosaic had an attractive design, brought home-owners into downtown Tempe, was taller on the east to complement W6/Centerpoint and tapered at the west to transition to lower buildings on Farmer and beyond.