Quote:
Originally Posted by MichaelS
Not the best written article (to be expected when you consider the source I guess). Here is a link to the CPC report on this application:
http://www.calgary.ca/PDA/pd/Documents/calgary_planning_commission/agenda/2015/loc2014-0155.pdf
Seems like there is extremely strong policy reasons to not approve this, as is the case with all private parkades in the Centre City. Also, if you look at Appendix IV of the report, starting on page 29, you can find the parking supply study that was completed by DA Watt in 2013. It actually states that parking supply will meet demand in that part of East Village (see graphic on page 36), so an additional private parkade that violates many other policies is not necessary.
|
Very interesting. Thanks for providing the link. I have to say that based on the City's current policy framework, I can see why it is recommended for refusal. That being said, I hope this is a case where Council over-rides the policy decision.
To me it seems like this entire deal has been structured to satisfy the investors behind the ALT Hotel. Essentially the proposal is for a hotel, plus the parking that would normally be required to be included with the hotel proposal plus a few extra stalls. Instead of the hotel offering to rent out its extra parking stalls (as happens at the downtown Hyatt), a separate entity is being created to "own" and "manage" the parking component of the hotel. Guests at the ALT Hotel would still have priority access to any required stalls but anything beyond that would be under control of the parking company.
The way I see it, if everything about this development remained exactly the same but it was ALT Hotel asking to add a few extra parking stalls to the number required by a hotel development instead of the current proposed arrangement, chances are project would be approved. But because the current proposal brings a non standard ownership arrangement we end up with a recommendation for refusal.
I think the ALT Hotel is one of those projects that is worth making an exception for and that the East Village is the place to test it out (this is the same reason why I support the no-parking condo proposal in the East Village as well). Having a public parkade at the western edge of St Patrick's island and across from the Riverwalk will help the East Village continue to develop as a destination neighbourhood for the entire city. Having both the ALT hotel and Hilton hotels in the East Village will also help the area. As the financing for the ALT Hotel seems contingent on the approval of this ownership structure I say do it!!