Development wave hits Gastown
Several new, higher projects have been proposed for Vancouver’s oldest neighbourhood
By John Mackie, Vancouver Sun
February 7, 2015
One of the proposals for a redevelopment in The Landing [SIC - The Courtyard] at 117-131 Water St. in Vancouver. The plan was rejected by the Gastown Historic Area Planning Commission. The drawing shows the loss of the sawtooth look if everything was built to the allowable 75 feet.
...
One recent proposal would have demolished a seven-storey warehouse at 157 Water St., and replaced it with a building. A two-storey structure next door at 151 Water would have had a five-storey glass addition added on top.
Another proposal was to completely redo The Courtyard, a 1970s development at 117-131 Water. The three old buildings on the site would have been retained, but the 1970s portion would have been replaced with new, taller structures.
A third development would have added five storeys to the two-storey Le Magasin building at 332 Water.
The 151/157 Water and the Courtyard proposals got the thumbs down from the Gastown Historic Area Planning Committee, a civic body that “works to preserve and protect the heritage and character of the historic Gastown area.”
The 332 Water proposal was supported, but isn’t going forward at this time.
...
Without the bonus density, it’s harder to do a project on a smaller building. Hence the new proposals all look to go to the area’s maximum allowable height of 75 feet (22.8 metres), which Fung said gives developments the “critical mass” they need to be financially viable.
The problem is, Gastown developed with a “sawtooth” profile, where there is a mix of small and big buildings.
Architectural historian Harold Kalman said the sawtooth profile is one of the things that makes Gastown distinctive.
“The buildings were different heights, and you had an uneven line of teeth across the top,” he explained.
If you build everything up to 75 feet, Kalman argues, “all of a sudden you’re changing the distinctiveness into sameness. And it’s really a shame, because once you’ve done it, it’s not reversible.”
The initial wave of Gastown redevelopment was residential, but many of the new proposals are for office space, including 151/157 Water.
...