Quote:
Originally Posted by relnahe
Yes they can move the corporate jobs to a sprawling suburban office park and put all the ugly industry in the city. Sounds so great.  Can't wait for any spills in any of the rivers that they'll beg the state and federal gov'ts to clean up on the taxpayers dime. 
|
I don't really buy the whole "energy center" story either.
The raw material processing industry's historical MO has proven over and over that it will stick around only as long as the raw materials are cheaply accessible, will essentially trash the local environment as required to make a profit, and then leave the massive environmental and socioeconomic mess for the public to (not) clean up. The executives retire in the pristine Swiss alps while the ant-like masses (i.e., us) suffer in remaining cancer clusters of often high unemployment, physical incapacitation, and entitlement dependence.
This is a text book case of privatizing profits and socializing externalities.
The white collar people who work in the energy industry are essentially not urban dwelling creative types, but inveterate mainstream exurbanists so will offer little to the betterment of the urban environment during their time around town. One only need to look at the sterile, characterless, windswept downtowns of Texas and Oklahoma oil cities for proof of this. Houston is a lifeless assemblage of corporate glass box clusters amid miles of mind-numbing sprawl. The super wealthy live far away from the urban center and the filthy air of nearby the industrial oil processing zones.
I don't think this class of people or the industry in which they thrive offer any long term upside to our region.
We should be emulating clean, successful places like SF, Boston, Seattle, Vancouver, Melbourne, Sydney. Not Houston, Baton Rouge, Tulsa, Bhopal, Shenyang.
Intellectual capital will characterize the successful metro areas of the future, not ephemeral natural resource wealth.
Having said that, Marcus Hook is not really the city - our city, at least. Not that I would wish ill on the people there, but it is as remote from Philly as the oil refineries of the Arthur Kill are from Manhattan.