Quote:
Originally Posted by ethereal_reality
 Pretty cool find sopas.
As most of you know, I pretty much pulled 'noirish' out of thin air when I named the thread five years ago.
(the first images I discovered at USC were dark and foreboding)
The thread immediately expanded beyond the smallish niche of noir, and began exploring the general history of Los Angeles and Los Angeles County.
I'm surprised most of you are raking Flyingwedge over the coals for his understandable concern about non L.A. images,
yet no one took the time to thank him or comment on his immensely interesting post on the Rookwood, Whitmarsh, etc. from a few days ago.
It was one of my favorite recent posts.
I'm curious, what's the consensus here on posting on Orange County (Anaheim, Laguna Beach etc)? -or Ventura County for that matter..
My experience with Los Angeles certainly includes these areas.
Recently I've been tempted to post on Palms Springs because of it's close association with Hollywood stars and the Two Hour Rule.
Is Palm Springs fair game?
__
|
Yes.
I would like to acknowledge publicly FW's scholarly and thoughtful contributions to this thread. Same goes for all of the frequent posters including you and GW, HossC, Albany, CBD and many others - including the poster FW singled out. Most of those posts take considerable thought and effort,
even if it is not always evident in the final product. The fact remains that the vast majority of posts still concern LA - even if a few are not based in LA. Taking exception to a handful of images considering the 1000's that are directly on point
is trite. As Albany succinctly noted, LA is not an island to itself. A lot of what transpired in LA was inspired by events and people outside of SoCal. For that reason alone,
I would err on the side of inclusion rather than exclusion. Since we do not all see things through the same eyes, some of us may find relevance in images that others overlook.
Regarding geographical parameters, I think the thread is fine just the way it is. Let me remind you of a post that provided evidence that until 1889, Orange County was once part of LA County. So, some of those images of Santa Ana and Anaheim are absolutely germane to this thread. Recall the posts about the wooden highway in the desert. My recollection is that some photos did not identify the location although they were most probably the desert east of San Diego. Should those informative and entertaining posts be purged from the thread? What about those images that were erroneously labeled LA but are not? A simple correction should suffice, while leaving the earlier post to set the record straight. Regarding areas north of LA, I would still leave it to the discretion of the poster. Like it or not, many neighboring communities had a commonality of interests with LA. From what I have read, some LA Courts once exercised jurisdiction over Ventura County. Likewise, Mulholland's activities in the Owens Valley and areas southward had a definite impact on LA. What about posts concerning the Eastern Sierra's (e.g., Manzanar), where many LA residents spent time during WW2, or Lone Pine which functioned as a set for countless LA-based film-TV businesses and their LA resident employees? There was a recent post of a California tagged Packard at Boulder Dam, where some of LA's electricity is produced. The photo was evidently related to Earle C. Anthony. Depending upon your point of view, because the iconic image depicts something that occurred
in another State its relevance to this thread is questionable.
As Albany noted, some posts concern pioneers who came from outside of LA. Should we place blinders on about where these pioneers came from and what may have influenced them? Or how about LA's influence on the rest of the world? I recently found a post card of a "famous" Brown Derby in Texas. There is little doubt what Wilshire Blvd. was being emulated. I now am guessing it is probably not the proper subject of a post here. Well forgive me for noting the genie may be out of his bottle.
PS.
God's speed Albany! Some of us have been there or been there with others similarly situated.
Tyler Texas. Reportedly opened 1935 and closed 1953
http://www.tylertexasonline.com/images/postcards/brown-derby-tyler-texas.jpg