Quote:
Originally Posted by red-paladin
Uh... It's more than that. Give credit where credit is due.
I am not sure if you've been down to the Port Mann area recently but this bridge is -massive-. Yeah I know some people on the forum will just say 'It's not the biggest bridge on the continent, but really, it's going to by far the largest in the country and apparently have the widest deck of a long span brige in the world. As another forumer mentioned, when normal people in approaching airplanes see that monster, they are impressed, and it's not even complete and cleaned up yet.
As for the 'boo hoo it's not a stack interchange' comments, this is not an 'urban interchange' in the middle of a 5+ million people American city. We all agree we wouldn't want a freeway downtown no matter how nice the interchanges are. The new cape horn should be evaluated this way: 1) There is the Trans Canada, the Lougheed, Mary Hill Bypass and United Boulevard all joining together, and the previous interchange didn't serve all directions very well at all and this will almost completely rectify the inital design's problems. Show me a 6+ way interchange with one road right below a massive bridge that is more asthetically pleasing in an American city please. 2) With Lougheed to the north and United Boulevard to the south and east, and the inital footprint of the existing interchange, there is no reason to further stack it much more than the current plan does, as the land is already owned by the government. 3) The new third level curved lanes from the bridge to north on the lougheed, and the elimination of the dreaded and dangerous 'crazy crisscross' segments is a major improvement.
Sorry to complain but I think people underestimate how much of an improvement and how large scale the bridge and interchange improvements are.
|
I love the new Port Mann bridge, I wasn't commenting on that in any way. That certainly is impressive, and welcomed, but I was commenting more or less on how the new Port Mann Bridge is about 15-20 years late, if you compare to other North American locations.
The bridge is MASSIVE, but I was commenting on the whole of the Gateway project. It's generally just playing catch-up with the rest of the areas. Cape Horn is a fantastic interchange, but I was talking more from a drivers perspective that if you don't really have an interest in roads or highway design, I don't know if it would be that "awe-inspiring" driving through.
I would support a nice urban freeway to downtown Vancouver, one that was built with the environment in mind, integrated well with the land use, and was in some ways lowered beneath the ground. Maybe I'm the only one, but for example, you all mention how glad you are that Gastown is there, but I really think a Gastown-like neighbourhood would have evolved somewhere nearby IF a freeway was built through there.
I'm absolutely against a freeway that is raised/elevated, or that is wide, but I certainly would be OK with a nice subgrade freeway that would integrate well with downtown. I just believe something is wrong when at times it's quicker to take TCH 1 over the Ironworkers to the Lions Gate to access downtown compared to First Avenue or Hastings.
And, I should explain, growing up in Ontario, and seeing how things are done here in highway design (high design criteria, large and impressive stack interchanges), it's really easy to compare on my end. In that way, I'm NOT advocating a 12-16 lane freeway like Vancouver, but just something built with the highest level of safety in mind.