I have to applaud WVC, they seem to be doing the "lets create a downtown" in the logical small steps approach.
We have our City Hall here, across the street is a crap hole mall, and about a mile away is the entertainment/hospitality core of the city. How to connect these areas and create some growth?
Let's encourage the mall to remodel, add out buildings and do an overall upgrade (not sure to what extent the city helped if any) We are getting a traxx extension, lets bring it past our entertainment core and end it right on our front door (City Hall). The connections are in place. Now they are building a piece at a time to increase density in the area, a highend, full service hotel, near City Hall, close to transportation. Eight stories tall, is this a skyscraper? No, but is it a major increase in height for WVC? Yes. I fully expect to see a mid-rise (5-8 story) office building in the WVC core in the next 5-10 years. It's organic growth as there is a demand. Sandy should takes some notes.
Sandy already has the mid-rise office in their downtown, but how does their "downtown" connect via transit? Sandy, come up with a solution for connecting your transit options, of which you'll have both Traxx and FrontRunner and entice a hotel chain or business of some sort to come in and built the next tall building in Sandy, maybe 10-15 stories.
In my opinion, MAJOR developments like the formerly proposed Proscenium, or redevelopments can be successful when the organic growth of a city demands it, as in City Creek Center, and that development or redevelopment is just a small part of the overall city core. However in the case of Sandy to create the city through one development seems very out of reach. WVC is doing it in small pieces, and will eventually grow with more buildings and more height.
In regards to proscenium, IMO that project would have had a much better chance for success if it was proposed in downtown SLC. While it was a huge project it would have just been a piece of the greater downtown SLC rather than the entire downtown Sandy.
I haven't posted in days, sorry if that entire thing was just a huge ramble.