My assessment of Touchdown Atlantic (reposted from the Maritime CFL thread)
Thoughts on Touchdown Atlantic
I was at the game today (but of course) and truly enjoyed the experience.
The crowd was enthusiastic (but non partisan) and cheered almost equally for the Eskimos and the Argonauts. I was really surprised by the number of people in the stands sporting Eskimos colours. In any event, the crowd acquitted itself quite well and hopefully impressed Cohon et al. There is a certain
je ne sais quoi about the sound of over 20,000 people cheering at once.
The stadium looked really good and the addition of the end zone bleachers really makes the stadium seem more complete.
With the end zone bleachers, the stadium can seat over 20,000. If the corners were filled in as well and perhaps the east grandstand elevated a bit, I have no doubt the stadium could seat 28-30,000.
I am a little surprised by
q12's assertion that it would take $75M to bring the stadium up to CFL standards but there is no question that there is still major work to be done. In addition to adding more permanent seats, a proper CFL stadium would require indoor concourses and permanent concessions and washrooms. This would be an expensive proposition and would have to be factored into the equation as to whether or not a CFL team should be a goal for the city of Moncton.
Still, I strongly feel that we should take the bull by the horns and go for it. As I have already stated in a previous post, there is probably nothing else that we could do that would be so effective in building a national profile for the city of Moncton as getting a CFL franchise. Halifax already has a national profile and most other people in Canada only think of three things when it comes to the Maritimes - Halifax, Anne of Green Gables and unemployed pogey collecting fishermen. We need to do more to enlighten the country and let them know that there is more to the Maritimes than this!!
It is true that Halifax is three times the size of Moncton and would seem to be the natural choice to locate a regional franchise. It is also true however that Moncton is more central to the bulk of the regional population than Halifax is. I agree that the three hour driving time rule is probably unrealistic in terms of determining the potential market for a team
but I do think that 90 minutes to two hours is realistic.
- population within 2 hrs of Halifax - 680,000
- population within 2 hrs of Moncton - 625,000
This seems to me to be a wash.........
Given this, you have to also look at civic leadership, the availability of a new (or expandable) stadium, corporate interest and popular support. Most of these factors I believe are on Moncton's side of the equation. In addition, Moncton has an established relationship with the CFL and I strongly believe that Touchdown Atlantic will become an annual event. If these events remain continually successfull then the CFL Board of Governors will have to sit up and take notice.
Of course it could be that Commissioner Cohon is merely playing footsie with Moncton in order to get the civic leaders in Halifax to get off their collective keisters and start looking at building a stadium,
but the recent announcement that the Uteck Bowl will be played in Moncton in 2011, 2013 and 2015 may do more that anything else to mobilize Halifax into action. This should be a major embarrassment to Halifax and is potentially a very dangerous move in terms of prodding the sleeping bear into action. I really don't think it was stategically a very good idea for the city of Moncton to steal this event from Halifax - it could backfire.
In any event, the next 5-7 years will be very interesting in determining the future of pro football in the Maritimes. I think everyone knows where my own personal allegiance lies but it is certainly too soon to count Halifax out of the equation. For the time being Moncton (rightfully and deservedly) remains the frontrunner. The tortoise however may still win the race......