Quote:
Originally Posted by Wooster
^ I'd like to know what is "unrealistic" about Carra's idealism? Any specific examples? There are lots that dismiss progressive urban views such as Druh Farrell's as unrealistic too. In my mind, we could use a lot more idealism, rather than the half-heartedness and mediocrity that often pervades when it comes to urban issues in Calgary.
|
Mainly that (as he does consulting work) he's a dreamer whose concepts never actually get implemented on the ground. Any half-decent planner can come up with designs for plazas and grand boulevards, but taking it to the next level and making it work on the ground is the real challenge. Maybe you're right and idealism will serve him more effectively as an Alderman than as a planner, but we'll have to see, assuming he wins/is acclaimed. Aside from that I've heard stuff in planning circles that don't inspire me with confidence, as well as regarding his work on the Community Association - I don't want to give credence to heresay, but in my experience where there's smoke there is at least some fire. Regardless, I'm not keen on losing one of the best guys on Council regardless of who is replacing him. If Carra were to replace, say, Hodges or Chabot, I'd be fine with that.