Quote:
Originally Posted by BCPhil
Well, there is no single area where you can for sure buy cheaper than you can rent (if you have no down payment), but you have to look at the whole region. You can rent a 500 sqft studio in Yaletown or buy a 2br/2bath 1000+sqft condo (resale) in Surrey for pretty much the same cost per month (or even much less). It's up to you if your lifestyle is worth generating income for your landlord or if you would rather have capital assets in exchange for a commute.
|
Uhhh... isn't that like saying "If you rent in New York, it's more expensive than buying in Phoenix, so you should buy in Phoenix?"
If you're comparing renting vs. buying, isn't it better to compare mortgage rates and rents in the same area?
The comparison that one SHOULD be making is what would that 1000 sq. ft. condo in Surrey cost to rent?
Quote:
|
If it's a shot at home ownership vs a life of renting, you really have nothing to lose.
|
You always have something to lose. Whether that be your $25,000 down payment ( 2 years free rent ) or worse.
Buying is always a calculated risk. Whether it's worth it or not depends on each individual, but saying "you can't lose" is a bit specious.
Quote:
|
If you think you can't afford the rates in 5 years, then that means you will be renting in 5 years anyway.
|
Yes, renting... minus money you've lost, or the possibility of negative equity ( needing to pay for something you no longer own.
Overextending oneself beyond reasonable limits is rarely a good idea. Each person's situation is different, my friend.
Quote:
|
Under normal conditions you'll be able to put lots towards the principle, especially if you make anniversary payments, so when you do go to refinance, if there is a huge difference in rates, the inflation on the value of your home and the amount you put towards principle will balance out.
|
Under [historically] normal situations, the renters and buyers are only separated by who can afford the down payment.
Quote:
|
If the worst happens and you declare bankruptcy, and your credit is over, then you are stuck renting for the rest of your life, like you would be anyway.
|
What if you don't WANT to be stuck renting forever, with a black mark on your credit for the following 7 years? Wouldn't it be better to be patient and get in when buying makes more sense than renting?
Quote:
|
But if you think you can have good down payment saved and higher income in 5 years, then wait. But if you feel you are in a now or never situation, may as well try now.
|
Sure, all investment is risk, but it's should be calculated, and should never be "do or die!" The question people should be asking shouldn't be "Can I afford NOT to?" It should be: "How much change can I weather?"