Quote:
Originally Posted by colemonkee
I couldn't agree with you more. Pershing Square definitely has potential, but I don't think it will ever reach the status that Union Square has within San Francisco. It does, however, have the potential to be a great urban square surrounded by retail and restaurants, which is slowly happening already with the opening of the salon and the upcoming restaurant at the corner of 6th and Olive, and the opening earlier this year (or was it last year?) of Arda's Cafe on 6th.
|
Perfectly stated. Pershing Square has a long way to go before it can be compared to Union Square (and may never be to LA what Union Square is to SF), though that tends to be the development model since it's the main comparison we have to use.
Setting aside the obvious design flaws of Pershing itself, the surround buildings/neighborhood have some differences and a few similarities:
Retail - SF has high-end retail, while we have a few sandwich shops, a cafe (Arda's has been open for 4 1/2 years, btw), many jewelry and jewelry supply stores, and empty storefronts. The Biltmore has some higher-end dining options, and the Heron Building has a high-end salon, fast-cas dining. Pacific Center is getting a nice steakhouse.
So in order for the square to have a constant stream of people to visit it, we need to fill in the retail gaps. The Title Guarantee Building still hasn't gotten any retail; the Pershing Building has a Subway and a pizza place; the jewelry stores aren't going anywhere barring a collapse in the local jewelry market (a distant possibility, considering the talks I've had with some jewelry owners lately).
Next, there are seven vacant lots within spitting distance of the park. Park Fifth, but there's nothing planned for the others from what I know.
Some positive steps: The Clark Hotel is coming back, the Metropolitan Building is inching its way toward residential occupancy (though I haven't seen much lately), Pacific Center and Heron buildings on 6th are improving their retail and dining, Title Guarantee is now open *?* and Park Fifth... well, who knows.
Another positive is the cleanup of 7th Street and the Historic Core, which has increased pedestrian flow to/from Pershing.
Then there's the cleanup of Pershing Square itself, which is worlds away from even how it was a couple years ago. The built environment of the park is still —, but at least it's not dangerous or filthy.
My pet fix for Pershing Square would be to redo the parking ramps, which impede access to the park from basically all but the four corners of the park and decreases sight lines (perception of safety).
Whereas Union Square's parking ramps meet the streets at 90-degree angles, Pershing's take up 3/4 of the sidewalk space. Union Square has steps leading up from the sidewalk; Pershing has parking ramps and walls. Fix the parking ramps!