Metro jail fiasco, ouch
By JOHN PECK Times Staff Writer
[email protected]
The cost to complete the Madison County jail is going up - way up.
Barely a year after approving a $6.6 million budget increase for the still unfinished 1,300-inmate city-county lockup, a reluctant Huntsville City Council authorized a whopping
$32 million increase Thursday night.
The adjustment brings to $70 million the total revised budget for the problem-plagued metro detention center. That's far above the initial $29.2 million budget approved in 2002 and higher still than the $25 million that was originally estimated.
Councilwoman Sandra Moon expressed similar frustrations. Moon pressed City Attorney Peter Joffrion about the prospects of recouping some of the money in court.
Joffrion said the terminated jail contractor, Dawson Construction of Gadsden, posted a performance bond of $24 million guaranteeing completion. The terminated architectural firm, 2WR Holmes Wilkins LLC of Montgomery, also had coverage for professional services.
Together, some $30 million may be recoverable but only in the event a jury awards that amount. A court victory is no guarantee, Joffrion warned.
Moon then asked what many citizens and some public officials have asked throughout the on-again, off-again jail project: "Wouldn't it be cheaper to tear the thing down and start over?"
Taylor said the project team, along with its consultants, looked into that and concluded that wouldn't be feasible when demolition and delay costs are factored in. The joint jail is expected to save city and county taxpayers $120 million over 30 years once it goes into service.
"All the consultants we've worked with have all said the building is safe and they told us the problems we found can be fixed," Taylor said.
Councilman Richard Showers admonished council members for being critical of Taylor, saying he alone could not have foreseen the problems.
The city's Public Building Authority terminated Dawson and 2WR Holmes Wilkins last year after structural problems were found while modules were being set. The dismissal followed two work stoppages and safety concerns raised by outside construction consultants.
Dawson sued PBA for breach of contract. The authority sued Dawson alleging inadequate work. Dawson's bonding company has also filed legal action to avoid paying the insurance coverage. The architectural firm is also named in lawsuits over the jail's designs and engineering calculations.
Taylor said the jail, which is about a year and a half behind schedule, could now be completed by late next year or early 2009.