Quote:
Originally Posted by Steely Dan
are you kidding me?
only the spoiled brats of chicago could whine and moan about an 89 story building being proposed for their city. for god sakes, this is an awesome announcement! we're finally hearing solid information about a plan to rid our famed river front of that eye sore surface parking lot, oh happy joyous day.
let the good times roll!
|
Agreed, this is great news!! Hines has a reputation of getting things done, and this scheme seems to break their fear of doing truly bold things in Chicago and taking advantage of mixed use.
What bugs me a bit about the scheme is that, at first glance and from the nice map you posted earlier, three towers would probably consume a lot of this site, leaving little open space.
I would prefer one major, tall tower, with a ton of public features at the base and a good deal of setback from the river. On the other hand, phasing the development seems to be the way to get things done these days, rather than mega-projects like Block 37, where one phase is dependent on the one before it. Also, if Pelli manages to create a great urban ensemble like Marina City, where the three buildings play off one another and are greater than the sum of their parts, I could certainly see the value in a scheme like this.
The Pelli commission overall has me a bit disappointed, though. I was hoping for a new talent and someone who wasn't represented here yet. And, don't forget Pelli's last idea for Chicago: The Tweezer calamity. That was the only supertall structure I've ever seen that managed to scream out, "I'd rather be playing golf than designing this damn thing."