Quote:
Originally Posted by JACKinBeantown
In reply, my tone of voice is calm and non-confrontational. I'm only stating a fact. When you name a building after someone, you are honoring them. After 1856, American Robert E. Lee led the army that fought against the United States in an attempt to secede from the country. Treason is defined as the crime of betraying one's country. I'm not OK with honoring him. Changing the name of a building from honoring a traitor to something else is like taking down a statue honoring that person. It doesn't change history, in fact it does the opposite; it negates someone else's previous attempt to change history. I hope the mods do not take any of our posts down because we are both exemplifying how to have a calm discussion about something we disagree with. Keeping our comments here shows how people should behave online. That's all I'll say about the subject. Peace.
|
I understand the argument, and agree with parts and disagree with others:
1. There is an aspect of honor, yes, and we should guard against honoring traitors.
But is Robert E. Lee unambiguously a traitor? I think the history is more nuanced, and we should celebrate his role in eliminating slavery from our country:
2. Robert E. Lee was
opposed to secession AND to slavery—he advocated against Virginia seceding AND personally wanted to destroy the institution of slavery (the accurate historical read is that he disagreed with northerners on HOW to accomplish that goal, not WHETHER to accomplish that goal).
3. He may be a traitor insofar as yes, after Virginia seceded, he choose to defend the land he lived on. But how can we sincerely argue that he was a traitor against American values, when he clearly shared the broader values of his northern contemporaries (e.g. wanting to somehow guide slavery into its deathbed, opposition to southern secession, etc.).
4. I have NO issue removing statues of historical figures that are unabashedly pro-slavery, those who had no remorse for their actions, and those who the record shows are unidimensionally racist. Robert E. Lee should NOT be on that list, by virtue of his complex views on the issues at play during his time.