Quote:
Originally Posted by cdnguys
I’m betting you are going to be pleasantly surprised at how nice it will look in the end - so we can do a check in once done  For me as a bit of a history buff and architecture fan of city, I love that it’s being designed by a SJ’er, manufactured in SJ, built by SJ’ers and a SJ developer. I love the idea of a two-faced clock on corner.
|
Well, I certainly hope I am wrong and you are right.
I think there is a balance to be had between new construction blending with an area, having some design elements that pay homage to heritage etc and just being a mindless copy of what was in fashion 100+ years ago. The IOL HQ does a pretty good job of finding that balance.
To me the design shown in the 99 King renderings looks like a Disneyland copy of the Admiral Beatty Hotel (very 20's-30's). I don't think new construction of major uptown buildings should just involve mindlessly copying late 19th or early 20th century architecture. I'm all in favour of preserving heritage buildings but vibrant, living cities need to evolve and change architecturally when it comes to new builds...... not stay frozen in time.
If the renderings are accurate there is no architectural skill, innovation or creativity. Just a square faux brick/faux stone box with relentless lines of tiny windows........even the trim elements look like an afterthought that have been stuck on.