Sports delusions aside, we could do so much better at LeBreton Flats
This latest deal is reportedly worth somewhere between $30 and $35 million. Is this really what this expanse of prime real estate is worth?
By Brigitte Pellerin, Ottawa Citizen
Published Aug 15, 2025 | Last updated 4 days ago
QUEBEC CITY — It’s official. In Ottawa, we cannot think about community outside the ice rink.
You could say I’m a little irritated by the land deal just announced between the National Capital Commission and the National Hockey League to build a sports facility at LeBreton Flats. We could do so much better than that, for instance by taking inspiration from my favourite Quebec City project.
I don’t wish to be more of a killjoy than usual and deny the people of Ottawa their bread and circuses. But golly. Do we really need to devote that much public space to professional sports, related loud restaurants and louder bars? Are there no other pursuits worthy of our collective approval?
But Brigitte, you insufferable snob, people love their pucksports!
Don’t I know it. But you know what else I’m aware of? Sports fans are — and I say this as gently as I can — slightly delusional.
For instance, they keep hoping and believing that their team will win a trophy despite all evidence to the contrary. And I don’t just mean the Leafs.
In itself, belief in a team’s efforts and potential success could almost be cute, much like puppy love. And about as harmless. You go ahead and paint your face and wear jerseys and cheer on your couch. If you find value in these activities, who am I to judge?
It’s when the delusion extends to assuming that building a new spectator sports facility will necessarily benefit the larger community that I have a problem. Especially when coupled with the blind and mistaken assumption that it won’t cost the public a thing.
Politicians and franchise owners trip over themselves trying to reassure everyone that very wealthy business people employing very wealthy athletes to play a sport enjoyed by fans who have enough disposable income to drop thousands of dollars on season tickets plus roughly the same on beer and hotdogs (I am barely exaggerating) aren’t after subsidies.
I’m ready to believe there won’t be direct monetary contributions to building the arena, but I know full well league owners only invest when there’s significant government support thrown their way. Mayor Mark Sutcliffe, for one, says “yes, absolutely, there is a role for us to play” in this arena project.
That’s assuming the project actually does come to fruition, mind you. I hate being that person who twists the knife in the wound, but it’s necessary to remind local hockey enthusiasts that they’ve had their hearts broken before.
Also, why must arenas take over valuable public spaces like that? This latest deal is reportedly worth somewhere between $30 and $35 million. Is this really what this expanse of prime real estate is worth? How does anyone know what the true market value is when there’s only one buyer considered?
What if, instead, we had decided to use this beautiful space for complete communities with lots of various housing options, including the affordable kind, arts venues, places for people, flexible office space, playgrounds, sponge parks, or whatever else people think we should have, determined by a real and thorough public consultation, in a space that ought to remain fully accessible to the public for historical and community reasons?
I am in Quebec City this week, and I checked in on construction at the Place Fleur-de-Lys site I told you about a year and a half ago. The site of an old and decrepit mall is being turned into a complete community by civic-minded private developers. Residential buildings are coming up nice and fast and while there’s a lot of dust and disruption, there is also plenty of progress. The website (in French) shows the kinds of residential rental units already available and the various amenities available to residents.
We could do something inspired by that at LeBreton Flats. But we’re not, because in Ottawa, if it doesn’t involve an ice rink, we don’t even think about it. Colour me deeply disappointed.
Brigitte Pellerin (they/them) is an Ottawa writer.
https://ottawacitizen.com/opinion/pellerin-lebreton-flats