Throwing toilet paper into trees ,“rolling”, has been a juvenile prank tradition for almost 100 years. Mostly, it’s more confined to junior high or younger high school students. But, Auburn University students have claimed “rolling” the Toomer’s Oaks after a win as a tradition for several decades, now. It’s just “their thing”. But, the trees were in trouble for repeated damage for years before Harvey Updike supposedly poisoned them in January of 2011. And, have been repeatedly damaged since.
Before, as the 2007 article atlanta68 referenced, repeated pressure washing, authorized by Auburn University, to remove toilet paper from the trees was doing major damage. But, if the toilet paper was left in the trees, it would kill the trees. Also, the trees had received fire damage on several occasions. Some examples below.
November of 1995 after a win over Alabama
https://www.thewareaglereader.com/2013/0...s-oaks-on-fire-after-the-1995-iron-bowl/
November 2010 after a win over Georgia.
https://www.thewareaglereader.com/2010/11/toomers-corner-set-on-fire/
Then, after the supposed poisoning.
November 2012 after a win over Alabama A&M. (Yes, after a win over Alabama A&M)
https://www.al.com/auburnfootball/2012/11/toilet_paper_catches_fire_on_f.html
September 2016 after a win over LSU. (video showed a man wearing an Auburn sweatshirt, set the toilet paper on fire. Auburn fans claimed he was not a real Auburn fan.)
https://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/sto...following-auburns-win-over-lsu/91075052/
In January of 2011, Harvey Updyke claimed he poisoned the Toomer’s Oaks after Auburn’s win over Oregon in a call to the “Paul Finebaum Show” and stated that the trees would die. A couple of days after the claim, Auburn University sent a Horticulture Professor out to take samples and test the ground around the trees. After testing, his results were “NEGATIVE”. Then, after a short meeting with the Administration, the Professor returned to take more samples for testing. Interestingly, the samples now tested “POSITIVE” for the strong herbicide that Harvey had claimed he used. And, subsequent tests showed more and more of the poison. Then, the drama began. The media played it up and the donations, some even coming from University of Alabama alumni and fans, began to “roll” in .
Harvey Updyke was a retired State Trooper from Texas who moved to Alabama and became a so-called Alabama fan. He was a mentally ill, deranged man who took his fandom to a ridiculous level. But, his fandom was used by Auburn University to play the victim and raise money. The University of Alabama carries no responsibility whatsoever for his actions and it was sad that, with Auburn University's nudging, the State and National media made such a big deal of it. Even today, when you hear a story about the Toomer’s Oaks, it always ends with “that were poisoned by an Alabama fan”. You never hear about all the other damage that was done, and is continuing to be done, by Auburn University itself. It is weak for Auburn University and its fans to play the victim. But, it is another example of “Auburn being Auburn”. Paul Finebaum hit the nail on the head when he described Auburn as a “cheap polyester” institution.