Quote:
Originally Posted by sailor734
One of the big differences between Portland and SJ is that they have residential area on a waterfront that is much less industrial and largely accessible to the public.(as per your photo) Ours is largely behind chain-link fencing. OTOH, the Portland waterfront is far more user friendly from a marine perspective. It's not wide open to the ocean, doesn't have 25 foot tides or violent currents at low water.
I do like the concept of a mixed hotel/residential tower. I think something like this should be part of Fundy Quay.
|
A lot of differences between any two cities, but there's quite a few similarities between Saint John and Portland, and Halifax for that matter... but I'd say Portland and Saint John seem more similar to one another, than either are similar to Halifax.
Saint John has at least made some leaps and bounds in terms of waterfront development, but it's been heavily concentrated on one side of the harbour, and on one very small part of the Uptown waterfront.
What needs to happen next, is a strategy to remediate and reclaim the Sugar Refinery site.
There was a huge area at the Lantic Sugar Refinery site that was filled in the early 1980's, but there remains many obstacles for development at this site, which deserve huge levels of assistance from all three levels of government to remediate and reclaim the site for development.
This area has huge potential for both residential and commercial development, but it needs a strong plan for remediation... so this site can be offered up on a silver platter for development... just like the Fundy Quay site.
I still think there exists a huge opportunity to tunnel between the West Side at Marketplace West and someplace near the lower cover loop, and use the earth extracted to fill in the former sugar refinery site. Be it a car tunnel, or a smaller active transportation tunnel, there would be a tremendous amount of earth moved in constructing such a tunnel. Moreover, the sugar refinery site is adjacent to a railway, it would be a very good location to engage in a major land reclamation/ sea wall project, as it would be very easy to transport fill material for such a project.
This site should have been on the federal, provincial, and muncipal governments radars for decades now... instead, iirc according to Sailor, its teak piling are rotting away, and the site essentially remains an urban ruin.
Irving wanted to build their HQ there, but they got shut down by the city. I honestly have to question why such a positive development was ever shut down for this site. Had Irving opened their HQ at the sugar refinery site, the area between Lower Cove Loop and the HQ would have seen substantial improvements.
This part of the central peninsula has enormous potential, but it requires some tremendous assistance from all 3 levels of government to get it to the point where it can be developed.
Once again, as Sailor has pointed out... much of Saint John's waterfront is inaccessible or off limits...
behind chain link fences...
ruinous roads...
railways ... and
technological terrors.
We need some big projects to greatly open up our waterfront for both residential and commercial developments. As Prime Minister Carney continues to say... now is the time to build.
We shouldn't accept a future where the sugar refinery site just continues rotting away...when something truly great could be built here.
It's time for newly re-elected MP Wayne Long to stand up for Saint John and get the same type of funding for the Sugar Refinery site, that he got for the Fundy Quay site.