Quote:
Originally Posted by yaletown_fella
By some metrics , such as quantity of high rises in both the city and inner suburbs , Toronto already has a much more vast and extensive skyline than Chicago, especially when you account for seperate nodes such as Yonge Eglinton, Don Mills, Fairview Mall, Six Points, NYCC
But I dont see how we will ever compete with Chicago when it comes to build quality. We don't have the beaux arts and art deco stock and downtown river that gives Chicago its dramatic beauty. Chicago's skyline is much more neat, orderly and visually appealing, while ours is cluttered with bad trends and "premium" semi-gloss window wall and also the soviet style social housing of the late 60s and early 70s.
|
I agree about natural features like the river which will mean Chicago will likely remain more beautiful. But I consider that more of a city beauty thing than a skyline specific thing. While a skyline can play a role in a city's beauty, I find that things like natural setting/geography, non-skyline impacting buildings, parks, trees, street layout etc. combine to play a bigger role.
I'm also not sure about the issue of quality. It seems to me that Chicago's advantage in that area is almost entirely down to it having a much higher proportion of office buildings which tend to be more prestigious with more premium designs than residential. Metro Chicago is still larger and can support more office but that may not be the case forever. Toronto is catching up in pure numbers since highrise living has always been more common here but Toronto's office projects aren't really inferior on average. For quality, I'd put buildings like Scotia Plaza, the CIBC Squares, RBC plaza, CCW etc. on the same tier as most large Chicago office towers. Chicago just has a lot more with fewer residential buildings cluttering things up.
It's true that Chicago has more variety in architectural styles, but that's mainly just due to Chicago building for longer. We can see the same issue affect many other cities that matured more recently than Chicago since if you look through the SSP global diagrams the overwhelming majority of large towers built in the last 20 years are blue glass.But that's something that tends to fix itself over time as style trends evolve.