I'm not a huge fan of the renderings. I despise Irving, but their new home office looks really nice and I think something like it would look great on this site. They clearly put a lot of effort into making sure it looked nice and fit in well with Saint John, unlike what we've seen with this development so far.
The new renderings don't look great, mainly the upper portion. The weird fake ornamentation mixed in with the mostly empty walls clashes in a very unpleasant way, especially with where the balconies are placed. The roof is the worst..

What is going on? Those things on the corner remind me more of a budget freeway exit hotel than a major building in the downtown in Canada's first city. Also, what is that weird, very wide boxy glass window in the middle?
Overall, I feel the developer has a lot of ideas, but put them together in a way where none of them are fully realised and end up clashing.

I'm hoping a better design is chosen. I love Saint John, and I feel it deserves better.