Interesting watching opening morning unfold over the Twitterverse . . . there’s been lots and lots of social media traffic from passengers.
For the most part, it looks like opening day is going really, really well. A great day!
Interesting to see what the hiccups are on opening day . . . there seem to be four happening:
Call to Gate: It’s clearly confusing people. Numerous tweets complaining about the lack of seating at the gates.
And a few photos have even been tweeted showing people (and quite a few of them!) sitting on the floor around the gates as they wait for their flights – ouch. Seeing users of a space do that would indicate a design flaw.
https://twitter.com/thetylerrichard/status/793087274254757888
CATSA Plus: Some negative comments, i.e. “really bad idea” to have my bins – with my valuables – all go through the xray without the owner, and without all of an individual’s bins traveling together. (But also a positive comment giving kudos to the automated delivery system bringing empty bins to the front of the line.)
Water bottle refilling: Yes, a few comments about it. It’s 2016. Liquids haven’t been able to go through security since just post 9/11 … 15 years ago. Yet there’s nowhere evident to fill a reusable bottle.
US departures backlogs: It looks like there are some hiccups there – not sure if it’s an opening morning breakdown, or a bigger systems or design issue . . . but there are some complaints of long lines to get through to U.S. departures. (From the posts, it’s unclear if the issue is CATSA Security or U.S. Customs.) One photo of the line up to get to E departures, and it looks somewhat similar (sadly) to the nasty CATSA lines at concourse A.
https://twitter.com/dannierob/status/793139195162206208
The big ongoing question will be Call To Gate. In my mind, it was the biggest design gamble here – and I think it’s going to be a tough go for YYC. If people keep heading straight to gates, and keep sitting on floors there, it's going to be a poor experience for a lot of YYC's customers.
- Most of the world doesn’t use it, and few travelers have ever even experienced it. Therefore, it just won't be intuitive for travelers . . . meaning it will confuse people, and people will instinctively look for workarounds. (And please, YYC, don't try to fix it by putting up a bunch of explanatory signs.)
- A CTG system makes sense when designing for the pre-board waiting experience. Have folks congregate in a central plaza, and that plaza can offer more amenities and a great experience, but . . .
- CTG was designed before pay-for-checked-baggage, and before HD-seating on planes. Those lead to anxiety for most travelers (even in premium cabins) over bin space for carry-on items. So unlike when CTG was created, there’s now substantial anxiety about getting on the plane quickly. I don’t think your average North American traveler will feel comfortable not being at the gate ahead of time.
They’ll need to make CTG work, as it’s embedded in the building’s design. But I’m not sure how they’re going to take what seems to be a confusing system and make it easy/intuitive for every passenger!?