Worthless studies

How much money has your city wasted over the decades studying new transit projects that never ended up happening?

How much tax money went into the pocket of transit consultants for no good reason?

Just curious how much money we waste studying new transportation improvements ad nauseum since such little actually gets built any more. Think how much money we could save if we didn't go through all these worthless studies and just went ahead and actually built stuff. America used to actually do things, not just endlessly talk about them, you know.

In those days building canals, bridges, reversing rivers, new rail lines--no problem. Lets get 5,000 men out there and get this thing done. Not any more. Now we have to do a $6.5 million study, followed by another one, then another one, then assess environmental impact, then oh there's a new Governor and he decided to stop the project altogether!

So how much is being wasted? Anyone want to post numbers?
 
Well, “back then” a lot of transit projects were privately-funded, so if they failed it was only the shareholders’ problems. If a project fails today, the agency’s stuck with it for 20-40 years (see Portland’s WES).

Anyway, studies aren’t the problem. Europe and Japan have pretty rigid environmental review and get plenty of stuff done. They also have strong in-house planning and engineering, which a lot of American cities don’t, so they end up hiring out consultants. They also have strong local manufacturers, which the US could take advantage of if it didn’t have Buy American (even on locally-funded projects—see Houston), which really inflates the cost of rolling stock. And most crucially there’s a broad consensus about the importance of transit (or even infrastructure in general) as a public investment, which you don’t have here, leading to ridiculous stalling, drawing-out, and ultimately a lot of unfinished studies.
 
The Detroit-Ann Arbor commuter rail plan has been studied to death. Just build it, the studies probably equate to the cost of actually building it. If it fails, I suppose you could just abandon it at no loss.
 
After some 40 years of studies. Winnipeg has considered everything from a subway to monorail to lrt. Now were getting brt on dedicated roadways. Which might turn into streetcars or light rail, before phase 2 is completed. Phase 1 should be in operation in 2012.
 
$109 million studying a new I-5 bridge over the Columbia River between Oregon & Washington.

Bridge estimated cost: $300-$400 million
Freeway reconstruction (total): $3-$4 billion

No work has been completed. They don't even have a good justification for the project, as they never studied rehabbing the crossing or adding mass transit. Which would cost even more to add to a new bridge.
 
I've heard bad things about the Columbia Crossing project but anything that major would cost a ton of money for studies, early design, aquisition of land and easements, etc.
 


Back
Top