Vancouver's Density


Lindberg

New member
Hi there,

I am new to Vancouver (moved here from Montreal 10 days ago). Someone told me recently that the lack of land around Vancouver explains the high price of land, thus the need for high rises, apart from other factors of course.

Is urban sprawl truly affected by a lack of available land around Van?
 
have you seen the mountains outside? or the US border to teh south and the water to the west?

lol
sorry

but yes there is a lack of land here - a lot is set aside and not allowed to be touched by many levels of government - provincial, federal, municipal etc.

BC is something like 8% liveable land wise? the rest is mountains and just not able to be used - and the majority of farmable land is in the fraser valley so we lose that farmland we lose a lot because there is no other place to farm
 
The region is something like 1,400 sq. kms in size, much smaller than othe regions. On top of that, about half of that is non-developable land (agricultural reserve, forests, water sheds, parks, etc.). And then, there's the fact that we're bounded by water in the west, mountains in the north and east, and the American border in the south.
 
There are obvious limits to the growth of the region, but that doesn't mean it justifies the current RE prices.
 
for the region, there are obviously some pretty important sources of pressure on prices - natural limits to growth, political limits to grown (things like zoning, the alr, the neighborhood council), employment distribution, transportation infrastructure.

but there's loads of sprawl in vancouver and out in the hinterlands. something like 80% of the vancouver region is covered in ultra low rise development characteristic of montreal's west island. so while the core of the city of vancouver is nice and dense, the single family homes that occupy the very vast majority of the city's square miles (and almost all of the suburbs) have a much, much lower relative density. all this to say that when you're talking about the high price of land in the core, this is just as much about zoning and the long term planning decisions, as it is about the market side of it. after that, toss in the highly irrational tendency that british columbians have to speculate on property...
 
It's the residential land that's worth the money in Vancouver. In most cases, the actual value of the house on top of it is negligible, and in many cases with older busted up houses on the land, they're a liability and bring down the price of the lot.
 
The region is something like 1,400 sq. kms in size, much smaller than othe regions. On top of that, about half of that is non-developable land (agricultural reserve, forests, water sheds, parks, etc.). And then, there's the fact that we're bounded by water in the west, mountains in the north and east, and the American border in the south.

yes, if excluding farmland, wasteland, rivers and mountains, there r roughly 2.0-2.3 million ppl living in an area of 750-850 km2. however, if you would compare this to the largest cities in the world, then we are nothing. i would imagine by 2020 the whole scene of vancouver would not be much different since the development areas are highly concentrated, but there will be a lot of suburban downtowns.
 
yes, if excluding farmland, wasteland, rivers and mountains, there r roughly 2.0-2.3 million ppl living in an area of 750-850 km2. however, if you would compare this to the largest cities in the world, then we are nothing. i would imagine by 2020 the whole scene of vancouver would not be much different since the development areas are highly concentrated, but there will be a lot of suburban downtowns.

Ok all, then, let me ask you this,

What is the NUMBER ONE factor which dictates high land price in the great region of Vancouver?
 
Ok all, then, let me ask you this,

What is the NUMBER ONE factor which dictates high land price in the great region of Vancouver?


um... because this is vancouver.... duh. this is lotusland. we have money to burn and yoga poses to pose. somehow we have been convinced that 650 sqft condo for 1/2 million is a good value.

alas, people pay what they want to pay. free market forces in play here. somehow, people have decided that an average metrovancouver home is worth more than a average home somewhere else. it does not mean this is smart, just true
 
um... because this is vancouver.... duh. this is lotusland. we have money to burn and yoga poses to pose.


Well djmk, feel free to send some money here, I'm ready to start a nice big camp fire ! :banana:


Anyone else here has money to burn, feel free to PM me.
 
Ok all, then, let me ask you this,

What is the NUMBER ONE factor which dictates high land price in the great region of Vancouver?

Two things, really:

1) Since about the late 1970s, people have historically been willing to pay a premium to live in Canada's most temperate climate.

2) More recently--psychology, and (even more recently) a speculation binge. We have had speculation binges in the past but nothing quite like this. We are currently the 4th most overvalued real estate in the world, (based on income/price ratios), and we will head down. Many specuvestors are currentlyl holding (even with carrying costs) in the hopes that the Olympics will make them rich.

It's all psychology now, since real estate is now not a good investment, with extremely low cap rates.

I have to admit that this market has been more resilient than I had anticipated. Right now there is very high demand, which really doesn't make sense from an economic standpoint (i.e., when you compare rent-equivalents in other cities around Canada and US.).
 
not everyone wants to live in highrises though hence why houses are so much more $$$

I wish people would snap out of their want for a single family dwelling and embrace better living like more density

where else is there to live in BC? theres not much choice so everyone chooses to live here for the most part
 
Theres one thing that shocked me quite a lot when I visited Vancouver, I didn't saw many medium density development (small appartments, row houses...) around the downtown core, it seemed to me that it changed drastically from very dense to low, in many parts.
 
A list of countries about the same size as the usable space of BC. (Based on 8% usable land)

Code:
Country  	2008 Pop	Area	Density
S. Korea 	49,233,000	98480	499.9
Sri Lanka	21,129,000	65610	322
Portugal	10,677,000	92391	115.6
Czech Rep.	10,221,000	78866	129.6
Hungary  	9,931,000	93030	106.8
Austria  	8,206,000	83858	97.9
Azerbaijan	8,178,000	86600	94.4
Sierra Leone	6,295,000	71740	87.7
Jordan  	6,199,000	92300	67.2
Georgia   	4,631,000	69700	66.4
** BC ** 	4,419,674	75760*	58.3
Ireland   	4,156,000	70280	59.1
U.A.E   	4,621,000	82880	55.8
Lithuania	3,565,000	65200	54.7
Panama   	3,293,000	78200	42.1
* Only Usable Space listed

Given that there are lots of countries with MUCH higher densities ( this list lists their land mass INCLUDING UNUSABLE SPACE ) BC has lots of room.
 
A list of countries about the same size as the usable space of BC. (Based on 8% usable land)

Code:
Country  	2008 Pop	Area	Density
S. Korea 	49,233,000	98480	499.9
Sri Lanka	21,129,000	65610	322
Portugal	10,677,000	92391	115.6
Czech Rep.	10,221,000	78866	129.6
Hungary  	9,931,000	93030	106.8
Austria  	8,206,000	83858	97.9
Azerbaijan	8,178,000	86600	94.4
Sierra Leone	6,295,000	71740	87.7
Jordan  	6,199,000	92300	67.2
Georgia   	4,631,000	69700	66.4
** BC ** 	4,419,674	75760*	58.3
Ireland   	4,156,000	70280	59.1
U.A.E   	4,621,000	82880	55.8
Lithuania	3,565,000	65200	54.7
Panama   	3,293,000	78200	42.1
* Only Usable Space listed

Given that there are lots of countries with MUCH higher densities ( this list lists their land mass INCLUDING UNUSABLE SPACE ) BC has lots of room.

Thank you twoneurons for this interesting table, so what is the MAIN FACTOR that makes Vancouver's land prices so high?
 


Back
Top