Unify different AFC System?

Penny H.

New member
AFC (automated fare collection) System is more and more normal nowadays. However, even we have machines collect our fares, sometimes it's annoy to keep 2 or 3 cards in hand since there are different systems. Especially, when traveling, it definitely will be more convenient to have just one card for all systems if they are unified.

For example, there are two systems in San Francisco- BART & Clipper Card
Unify different transportation system will be good for travelers who travel among different cities.

Is there any cities or countries doing this now?

Fare Please! 2013/07/02
Source for reference
 
For example, there are two systems in San Francisco- BART & Clipper Card
Unify different transportation system will be good for travelers who travel among different cities.
Meanwhile, in reality, San Francisco is actually a good example of the unified payment system you advocate. The Clipper Card is accepted by all major Bay Area transit agencies: Muni, BART, VTA, AC Transit, SamTrans, Caltrain, Golden Gate Transit, and the SF Bay Ferry.

You can even use Clipper to pay for car parking in many garages.
 
Meanwhile, in reality, San Francisco is actually a good example of the unified payment system you advocate. The Clipper Card is accepted by all major Bay Area transit agencies: Muni, BART, VTA, AC Transit, SamTrans, Caltrain, Golden Gate Transit, and the SF Bay Ferry.

You can even use Clipper to pay for car parking in many garages.

The information you offered is useful!
 
I know Montreal and Quebec City both use the same fare collection system based on the "Opus" card, however I believe they were designed that way from the start (i.e. from the time we converted from cash and paper tickets), so unsure whether this fits your criteria. In Montreal, one can load the (distinct) fares / passes for metro and regional transit systems on the same Opus card.

FYI Communauto (car sharing co-op in Montreal, Quebec City and other Quebec towns) is rolling out Opus card readers on their fleet. Although not "fare collection" per se, the end result is the same card lets you access public transit and car shares.
 
IIRC the (supposedly) interoperable SmarTrip/Charm Card system in DC/MD is the best example of AFC integration on the U.S. East Coast. The Charlie Card is also a good example, but mostly by dint of the fact that MBTA is the only mass transit provider in metro Boston.

SEPTA in Philadelphia is rolling out its (contactless! open-source!) New Payment Technology (NPT) system, which will either (a) redefine U.S. AFC tech, or (b) (more likely) be something of a flop. The promise is that the NPT platform would allow extensive interoperation between the Northeast's many abutting transit agencies; the problem is whether or not abutting transit agencies would actually take advantage of it...And of course there remains the question of why SEPTA didn't just go out and buy the U.S. rights for the similar French Calypso technology in the first place...
 
The direction I can see this going would make AFC systems largely a stepping stone - like how hybrid cars are theoretically a stepping stone to full electric.

When our American Credit Cards start getting contactless chips in them like they Canadians have, they will eventually be used by transit agencies around the US. This would make a system that would be universally accepted. Granted, while I've heard some transit agency's discuss it as a future plan, I have yet to see any implementation or steps towards implementation.

Also, this isn't the type of thing that happens overnight - the SF Bay Area's clipper card is the perfect example - it started a while ago(possibly the late 90s) as a BART only system called translink. The MTC then decided to invest in clipper, which for a time was being developed simultaneously alongside translink. The two technologies merged, and were rolled out across most of the main agency's over a course of a few months/years. However, some of the ferry's didn't start using clipper until this year, and some outlying agency's still don't use it.

A similar model is with the Electronic Toll Collection - we have FasTrak here in CA, which is fundamentally incompatible with EzPass. I think its far more likely(with transit at least) that beyond some local areas merging into a bigger system(If Amtrak California took TAP and Clipper... or Sacramento started accepting Clipper), we won't see a transit card that works everywhere. Clipper ran into issues implementing all the complex fare structures and collection methods of the different agencies in the bay area. I can't imagine what it would take to jive the collection systems of the T, NYC Subway, 'L, Metrorail and BART...
 
Lots of cities do this. There are at least 20 different transit agencies in the DC area that accept the Metro SmarTrip card. You can even use it in Baltimore.
 
Also, this isn't the type of thing that happens overnight - the SF Bay Area's clipper card is the perfect example - it started a while ago(possibly the late 90s) as a BART only system called translink. The MTC then decided to invest in clipper, which for a time was being developed simultaneously alongside translink. The two technologies merged, and were rolled out...
Translink started in 2002, and changed its name in 2010 to Clipper. Same project, different name.
 
I stand corrected - I remember seeing them appear very slowly while I was in highschool, which would make late 90s early 2000s - Thanks for correcting me.

I thought there was a point at which the programs were looking at diverging, but came to their senses - something about BART being worried Clipper would force things upon them. Could be completely wrong about that.
 


Back
Top