Transportation question


Yasir

New member
Is there any possible way to transport between two and three million passengers, from a point y to a point x about 10 kilometers away, within half an hour?

If x, a point of convergence, is 1km2 in size and there are multiple points set around it in a circle at a radius of 5km, would it be possible to transport so many people?
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't that just be a recipe for disaster? And wouldn't it be too much to expect people to stand still for 15 whole minutes?

Why would they need to stand any more still on that than millions of people do on public transit at rush hours every day for 15+ minutes?
 
Wouldn't that just be a recipe for disaster? And wouldn't it be too much to expect people to stand still for 15 whole minutes?

People stand still for 30-45 minutes on the subway during the morning rush, which, incidentally, probably moves your target goal of 2-3 million 10+ K per half hour during the morning rush. On multiple lines, though. Surely a few in Tokyo move 2 million from x to y each day...
 
1 - People would just fall over and die if they attempt to step onto a 13mph (20kmph) walkway. According to wikipedia, the fastest walkway at the present is at the Montparnasse—Bienvenüe Métro station in Paris. It runs at 6mph, down from 7mph because people kept toppling over.
Wikipedia


The London underground is one of the busiest, if not the busiest, mass transit system in the world.
And according to Transportation for London site,
a.Total number of passengers carried on the Tube each year: 1014 million
b. Passengers enter the Tube system at a rate of 146,000 people an hour
c. Length of network: 408km/253 miles
d. Total number of stations served: 268
e. Cars in LU's fleet: 4070

1.014 billion passengers per year works out to about 2,816,666/day in a 360 day year. Even randomly bumping up this number for weekdays to 3.2 million/day and then assuming that passengers travel only during the morning and evening rush hours gives you only 1.6 million entering and exiting 268 stations spread along a network of 408 kilometers in 90 minutes.

I think you will agree that it is substantially less than the between two and three million passengers embarking at z number of points (Yn) and then disembarking at the one single point X, all within 30 minutes.

Still think they're comparable?
 
I can't tell if you're genuinely interested in finding a solution or just a troll, but anyways...

You're not going to find a single metro line that moves that many people in a half-hour. The highest-capacity rail lines only have operational capacity of somewhere around 70,000-80,000 passengers per hour per direction (pphpd), with most systems significantly less.
 
I imagine it would be an evacuation of some sort - but maybe that's just New Orleans influencing my thinking. 3.2 million people is close to the urban population of Houston, which right now is dealing with Hurricane Ike.

I can't think of a single event that draws 3.2 million people, except a few religious gatherings in India. Wikipedia says that several other religious gatherings, celebrity funerals, and political rallies have also drawn such crowds.
 
Very close onishenko but not quite.

The grand mosque in Makkah can at present accommodate up to 2 million people and on a couple of annual occasions during the past few years crowds have been spilling over into streets and into hotel lobbies as well.

The Mosque is being expanded substantially and a lot of stuff is being knocked down in order to make room for it. Other developments around the mosque also mean that some historical stuff is being knocked down along with hotels and whatever else was in the way. For example, the abraj al bait towers are being built on land that used to have a 200 year old Ottomon fort sitting on it until a few years ago.

Accommodation is a huge problem in Makkah, there's been a sharp decline in the number of visas issued this year because there aren't enough rooms to go around and this is with just a few hotels knocked down in order to make bigger ones. There was no spare capacity at all.

Anyway, there's a huge debate going on here with a lot of people throwing around all sorts of ideas. One was having massive developments outside Makkah and then transporting the pilgrims in. The problem? We pray five times a day and even during peak periods like the hajj or Ramadan there are no more than half a million people inside the mosque unless it's the time for prayer. People, like myself, who live in Jeddah or another nearby city and go in for just a few hours have to park on the outskirts of the city during the very heavy times and take the bus in and if you're going to have a mass transit system.... we're GOING TO use it. :-)

There are only 15 minutes between the call to prayer and the prayer, time during which people make their way from their hotels to the mosque.

That's why the question. I felt perhaps I could be mistaken in my belief that the only way to transport 2 million people a distance of around about 10 kms within half an hour is through the use of a giant catapult...
 
1 - People would just fall over and die if they attempt to step onto a 13mph (20kmph) walkway. According to wikipedia, the fastest walkway at the present is at the Montparnasse—Bienvenüe Métro station in Paris. It runs at 6mph, down from 7mph because people kept toppling over.
Wikipedia


The London underground is one of the busiest, if not the busiest, mass transit system in the world.
And according to Transportation for London site,
a.Total number of passengers carried on the Tube each year: 1014 million
b. Passengers enter the Tube system at a rate of 146,000 people an hour
c. Length of network: 408km/253 miles
d. Total number of stations served: 268
e. Cars in LU's fleet: 4070

1.014 billion passengers per year works out to about 2,816,666/day in a 360 day year. Even randomly bumping up this number for weekdays to 3.2 million/day and then assuming that passengers travel only during the morning and evening rush hours gives you only 1.6 million entering and exiting 268 stations spread along a network of 408 kilometers in 90 minutes.

I think you will agree that it is substantially less than the between two and three million passengers embarking at z number of points (Yn) and then disembarking at the one single point X, all within 30 minutes.

Still think they're comparable?

my great aunt broke her leg on a moving sidewalk thingy at heathrow airport i don't know how or what happenned but she fell somehow :(
 
Very close onishenko but not quite........

.....That's why the question. I felt perhaps I could be mistaken in my belief that the only way to transport 2 million people a distance of around about 10 kms within half an hour is through the use of a giant catapult...

Very interesting. But would your timeframe not be 15 min then? From the call to prayer, to prayer? If indeed it is 15 min, and you factor in people getting out of their hotel rooms, down to the lobby, etc., you only have 10 min remaining.

Unfortunately it seems there is a problem here. Mass expansion of accommodation, room for the mosque expansion, etc. yet no demolition of historic structures...

I think the most realistic option is selective reconstruction and integration of historic structures as part of new buildings. There is are a couple great examples of this in Jordan.

Unless you have dozens of high-speed trains that could boarded, and converge on a central axis in a couple min. max, (not factoring the time it takes people to walk to and from a station) it doesn't seen that realistic.


(I'll ponder your question some more. I have a planning design class I am assisting to teach in an hour here. I'll pass off the question and pull up google maps for perspective and see what we can muster.)
 
Thanks Onishenko! People start leaving early in order to get a place at the front of the mosque, hence the 30 minutes. And I would really appreciate any further information you could give. :-)
 
1 - People would just fall over and die if they attempt to step onto a 13mph (20kmph) walkway. According to wikipedia, the fastest walkway at the present is at the Montparnasse—Bienvenüe Métro station in Paris. It runs at 6mph, down from 7mph because people kept toppling over.
Wikipedia


The London underground is one of the busiest, if not the busiest, mass transit system in the world.
And according to Transportation for London site,
a.Total number of passengers carried on the Tube each year: 1014 million
b. Passengers enter the Tube system at a rate of 146,000 people an hour
c. Length of network: 408km/253 miles
d. Total number of stations served: 268
e. Cars in LU's fleet: 4070

1.014 billion passengers per year works out to about 2,816,666/day in a 360 day year. Even randomly bumping up this number for weekdays to 3.2 million/day and then assuming that passengers travel only during the morning and evening rush hours gives you only 1.6 million entering and exiting 268 stations spread along a network of 408 kilometers in 90 minutes.

I think you will agree that it is substantially less than the between two and three million passengers embarking at z number of points (Yn) and then disembarking at the one single point X, all within 30 minutes.

Still think they're comparable?

these London stats are not very useful for your estmates

If you consider a subway type transit, the ballpark numbers are:

1. about 250 people per car
2. 8 cars per train
3. 2 minute interval between trains
4. 40 km/hour average travel speed including stop time

Now, the last one, considering your requirement of only two stops (beginning and final) can be increased to 60 km/hour, assuming top speed between stations of about 90-100 km/hour, resulting in travel time of about 10 minutes.

With these rough numbers you can have a train carrying 250x8=2000 people arriving at the final stop every two minutes. Thus, in 30 minutes you can deliver 30,000 people from point A to point B using a subway line.

Add not a small problem of having 2000 people clear the destination platform in time before next train arrives.

Assuming you could solve these problems, and perphaps somewhat increase number of people per car (to about 300) and number of cars (from eight to ten ), you could transport about 50K people with one subway line. To move one million people you would need 20 lines running in parallel, 2 mln - 40 lines, 3 mln - 60 lines.

But the biggest problem IMO will be avoiding stampede at the boarding and destination.
 
roller-coaster technology.

How about a few pedways connected to each other. Starts at 5mph, then the next one is 10mph and then 15mph.
 


Back
Top