Transit Oriented Development Doesn’t Just Happen!


M II A II R II K

Active member
Transit Oriented Development Doesn’t Just Happen!


June 2010

Renata Simril

logo.gif


Read More: http://www.planningreport.com/tpr/?module=displaystory&story_id=1510&format=html

Transportation networks are fundamental to how we grow, develop, and prosper. We, being here today, are the converted. We are a key demographic in driving TOD development. For about 50 years, our national, state, and local funding programs have driven decentralization of settlement patterns and, ultimately, suburban sprawl. That pattern of growth is no longer sustainable. We know that congestion, long commutes, and gas prices are driving more infill, urban, and TOD development. Statistics explain the impact of the demand for TOD development. According to a Reconnecting America report from 2008, almost a quarter of all renters and buyers will want TOD housing in 2030. L.A. is expected to have a 544 percent increase in demand for TOD housing, or approximately 1.4 million households, by 2030. That compares to 261,000 households in 2000. That’s tremendous growth. The other top cities for TOD demand are major U.S. cities that are the economic engines of their regions: New York, San Francisco, Philadelphia, Boston, Miami, Dallas, and D.C.

The concept of livability and sustainability—the notion that growth and development should enhance the human and natural environments in the present and also protect them over the long term—has taken root across the United States, introducing new frameworks for local, regional, and federal partnerships, planning, and funding. We have to change the way we think; we have to look into the new frameworks for global, regional, and local partnerships. I am encouraged that we are moving toward a new direction at the state level, the federal level, and with initiative such as Measure R at the local level.

This potential for collaborative policy and planning could provide solutions from my development perspective. Forest City is a national private sector developer, but these points resonate to the non-profit sector as well. We are both facing the same challenge of trying to implement financially feasible TOD products at the local level. SB 375 is a model of cooperation between federal, state, and local policies that resonates to the demand for TOD development, but cooperation and planning must also be accompanied by real incentives for the development community. We are the ones who are ultimately going to build these kinds of projects and they tend to be more expensive and more challenging than greenfield development.

Specifically, I would like to highlight three perspectives that are important as we begin to implement these planning and policy efforts. One is providing clarity and certainty to developers. Understanding where municipalities and communities desire to grow through development, and when development should be curbed, is essential to providing that clarity. SB 375 has the potential to do just that if implemented effectively. Coupling local zone changes to support TOD/urban infill and streamlined entitlements to support TOD will go a long way to realizing implementation.

To highlight one example in Los Angeles, the Cornfield Arroyo Specific Plan (CASP) is being undertaken by the Los Angeles Planning Department adjacent to a couple of Gold Line stops. CASP is a great example of the type of collaborative effort that local planning departments can implement. In that project example, the city has taken a large geographic area, looked to rezone, looked to create high density, looked to create a mixed use district that is potentially in the wave of the next development cycle and asked what we could do to support “smart development” and encourage developers to build here. They have gone a step further by working to complete an environmental impact report based upon potential density scenarios that future developers who come into build in that particular area can then tee up and tier off of this master EIR. That will save time and money and the headache of baseless legal challenges. That provides a tremendous amount of clarity.
 
For people who don't actually read articles, this about why taking TOD for granted or expecting everything to "just happens" is wrong, and is not arguing that TOD is a bad idea or "never happens"

I thought it was good. Many cities seem to have spectacular plans but fewer have the right organization and policies for such things to actually have results.
 
In Westside Los Angeles, a Rail Line Stirs a Revival


July 6, 2010

By TERRY PRISTIN

Read More: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/07/realestate/commercial/07angeles.html?_r=1&ref=realestate

LOS ANGELES — Slowly, mass transit is taking hold in a city synonymous with the car. Now a light-rail line is finally coming to the affluent and traffic-choked Westside after years of local resistance, and at least some urban-style development is likely to follow.

- In addition to removing tens of thousands of cars from the road — 64,000 daily riders by 2030, according to transit authorities — the 15.6-mile Expo Line is expected to spawn a variety of mixed-use real estate projects, as some of the city’s previous rail lines have done. A project including more than 500 units of housing and a 300-room W hotel was recently completed at Hollywood Boulevard and Vine Street, and a rental and retail complex was built at Wilshire Boulevard and Vermont Avenue in 2007.

- The Expo route has spurred development proposals from major companies, including Hines, an international firm based in Houston, and Casden Properties, a leading Los Angeles developer of multifamily properties. In Santa Monica, Eileen P. Fogarty, the city planning director, said there was tremendous demand for any site that was located no more than a quarter-mile from a station. “People will comfortably walk a quarter of a mile,” she said.

- Much of the new line will run south of the Santa Monica Freeway, several miles from the densest population centers. But rail transit is expected eventually to have “huge economic development implications” that would bring jobs and badly needed services to people living in the Crenshaw district, a largely African-American neighborhood around the midpoint of the Expo Line, Mr. Ridley-Thomas said. Another light-rail line is planned from Exposition Boulevard south to Los Angeles International Airport along Crenshaw Boulevard.




07angelesMap-popup.jpg
 
Practicing Architecture


By Zach Mortice

Read More: http://www.aia.org/practicing/AIAB084440

Post-WWII prosperity brought to America coast-to-coast interstate freeways and sprawling green suburbs that become the quintessential image of the American dream, but during today’s economic recession, a different set of development patterns are being rediscovered: dense, urban neighborhoods facilitated by public transit infrastructure. Cities across the country are re-investing in light rail, street cars, and bus lines.

The potential causality between previous automobile-centric development patterns and the economic crash will be a topic of discussion for scholars, politicians, and interest groups for decades to come, but the connection between the economy and public infrastructure development is clear in one way: Just in time for a global economic meltdown that created a call for massive investments of public capital, including public transit spending, a growing consensus has settled in among civic leaders, developers, and designers that cities and towns are more sustainable and stronger economically with mass transit.

US Census data reveals that city growth accelerated between 2006 and 2008, and the entire decade saw an increase in the use of mass transit. At least half a dozen cities (like Phoenix, Houston, and Charlotte) have invested in new light rail lines over the past 10 years. Last year, the Obama Administration unveiled an ambitious $8 billion plan for a nationwide high-speed rail network. Los Angeles, a city that has tied its fortune to the automobile in brazenly iconic fashion, is now investing $40 billion into mass transit as part of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s 30/10 plan.

“When you start to see Los Angeles really ramping up their transit expansion, then maybe there’s a groundswell that’s really starting to change how people think about public transit,” says Sam Zimbabwe, director of the Center for Transit Oriented Development in Washington, DC.




Dubuque, Iowa’s Historic Millwork District received $5.6 million for multimodal streetscape improvements. The Minneapolis-based Cuningham Group Architecture drafted a masterplan for the area. Image courtesy of the Cuningham Group.

105468-5.gif





The Twin Cities Metro Transit light rail system will stop at St. Paul’s Union Depot. Image courtesy of HGA.

105468-2.gif
 
State of Washington Uses Transit to Generate Development


Jul 20th, 2010

Yonah Freemark

rev_logo.png


Read More: http://americancity.org/columns/entry/2464/

For decades, many urban planners have argued that the link between transportation and land use is unbreakable; the kind of communities we live in directly affect the way we get around, and vice-versa. Yet that line of reasoning, no matter its self-evidence, has frequently been ignored by government policy-makers over the years, most notably in the decision of the Johnson Administration during the mid-1960s to form separate cabinet-level departments for the two issues. Yet the Obama Administration has followed a different tact, promoting links between agencies that once operated completely independently. This policy was solidified with the announcement last year of the smart growth partnership between the Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Transportation (DOT), and the Department of Housing and Urban Development. The administrations plan to work together to address their common goals.

But this intense new focus may be getting in the way of the mobility-oriented principals formerly prioritized in the DOT’s grant distribution. In the past, when it came to public transportation projects, the federal government encouraged cities to build train and bus corridors that shuttled people over long distances as quickly as possible. That’s just about the opposite of the goals of this new program, which emphasizes the creation of dense neighborhoods where people perform most of their daily tasks within a tight radius.

In that vein earlier this month the DOT announced that it would allocate almost $300 million in small grants to cities across the country for urban transit improvement projects in the form of streetcar lines in cities like Charlotte and Cincinnati and bus rapid transit in New York City and Chicago. These investments would promote not simply the transport of people around town (as most DOT grants do), but also alterations in the physical environment, lining up with the housing and environmental efforts of others in the federal government. In fact, writing for the Dallas News, journalist Michael Lindenberger explained that when it comes to these grants, federal policy is now explicitly aimed towards changing land use and developing “livable” communities. Peter Rogoff, head of the Federal Transit Administration, told Lindenberger that “When we look at these grants we are going to look not just at ridership but at the economic development successes.” The agency has reduced its emphasis on the “cost-effectiveness” principle grounded in high ridership that used to guide its investments.

At first glance, this is an excellent policy change. Big housing and commercial projects are too often built without a second thought for transportation issues, even in big cities; meanwhile, transit systems are sometimes implemented with only minor consideration for associated construction. The two issues should be thought of as one. But is the DOT putting too much thought into land use effects and not enough into transportation itself? None of the streetcar systems that were awarded funding earlier this month are likely to carry more than 5,000 daily riders, a pittance in huge metropolitan areas, and certainly fewer than cheaper improvements in buses might allow. Is each worth the $25 million Washington is planning to allocate to it, just because of the expected economic improvements that will follow? The federal government must ask itself a fundamental question: Is the role of the DOT to fund improvements in the urban environment of cities, or is it supposed to merely invest in getting as many people around as possible?




A streetcar in Portland. Credit: Flickr user Jason Rodriguez

8dca6200b157fc35403c98fac843081d779c2d68.jpg
 
It’s easy to see why the Red or Purple Lines would bring development and why the Purple should be a “Subway to the Sea”. These are the areas of the Westside that have long had high demand, plus Hollywood and Ktown which started booming in the last 15-20 years. I don’t discount the value of the MTA lines; good transportation is critical for growth, and they certainly provide focuses for development. But these areas are also developing well away from mass transit (Beverly Hills, Beverly Center, the Grove, Melrose, WeHo).

The Expo Line discussed in the article is a more interesting case. There was minimal growth here until recently but USC, Culver City, WLA and South Santa Monica were logical next places to build since the areas to the north (Santa Monica, Westwood, DT) were developing and quite expensive. TOD at these locations is not surprising. But the sheer volume along the whole line and in particular within 1 or 2 blocks of stations seems like much more than a coincidence. This is especially true in Crenshaw and adjacent (say, Western to La Cienega), which are largely black and Hispanic and, while not particularly poor, were not particularly growing either. I think the growth in these areas can at least in part be attributed to the Expo Line itself and not general development of the area.

Other lines are more mixed. In Pasadena there has been some development along the Gold line, but Pasadena has been making a strong economic comeback for 20 years plus; and similarly, Glendale has no rail transit but has redeveloped its DT shopping and commercial area amazingly over the last decade or two. The rest of the Blue, Green and Gold lines have been mixed, in spite of heavy ridership on the Blue Line.

My conclusion is that rail is part of the solution (an important part) but is not the driver of growth or development. The driver still remains the other factors that make a place desirable to be (good schools, low crime, good maintenance, urban amenities, etc.).
 
Linking Transit-Oriented Development, Families, and Schools in the San Francisco Bay Area


PDF Report: http://citiesandschools.berkeley.edu/reports/Putting Schools on the Map_Final_Jul10_noappendices.pdf

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

In the nine-county San Francisco Bay Area region, municipal and regional leaders are grappling with how to plan for the expected growth of the coming decades. Because of the projected increases in residents under 18 years of age, access to high quality schools – defined by both the educational quality of school programs and a school’s role as a local, place-based community asset – will continue to play a strong part in where families choose to live in the region. Interest in Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) has grown across the country in the last decade and is increasingly employed as a strategy to achieve environmentally sustainable infill development and auto use reduction. The Great Communities Collaborative (GCC) in the San Francisco Bay Area has developed an aspirational vision for guiding new development that aims to increase equity, support families, and create mixed income communities.

Given the GCC’s “aspirational” TOD strategy, this paper looks at what must happen to realize these goals. In particular, we examine the connections between TOD and families, which, by extension, includes making the link among TOD, schools, and expanding educational opportunities for all children. This paper is the first of its kind; there is very little research on TOD and families and virtually no research on the relationship between TOD and schools. Therefore, we take an exploratory approach to understanding and framing these interconnections, and provide a rationale for the linkages at this nexus. The findings in this paper are the result of extensive case study research, interviews, and focus groups conducted throughout the Bay Area. Specifically, we ask:

• What issues, concerns, and/or questions about families and schools have emerged among stakeholders in current TOD planning processes throughout the Bay Area?

• How do these issues, concerns, and/or questions differ by the local context of the various TOD planning processes?

• What policy and planning opportunities exist to address these issues and both support and ensure successful TOD, complete communities, and high quality educational opportunities for families?

The report begins by describing “Ten Core Connections” among TOD, families, and schools relevant to creating complete communities and ensuring ensure high quality educational opportunities for all children. We then describe the unique demographic and policy context in which schools and school districts operate in California. From there, we present and analyze the experiences from five Bay Area TOD planning processes. These case studies illustrate a range of issues and represent different points in a planning and development time frame. Combined with our years of research in the region, these exploratory case studies guided our development of the “Ten Core Connections” between TOD and education, and informed the findings that conclude the paper.
 
Needed: a better way of keeping infrastructure working well


2010-08-31

By Philip Langdon

logo.png


Read More: http://newurbannetwork.com/article/needed-better-way-keeping-infrastructure-working-well-12945

The old way of maintaining America's subways and other transportation components should be replaced, says a tech expert who has pondered the problems of Washington's MetroRail system. If the US is to make a pronounced shift toward compact, less resource-consuming patterns of development, Americans will have to rely increasingly on mass transit. And to accomplish that, we'll have to find better ways of keeping the transit infrastructure working well, at a cost that doesn't bleed public agencies dry.

- A major problem, says Archer, is the inadequate process by which much of the transportation infrastructure is kept running. Just look at MetroRail, he suggests. Until recently, MetroRail was "considered by many to be the best subway system in the country," Archer writes in a blog called "Greater Greater Washington," available here. Much of the MetroRail system serving metropolitan Washington was built between 1970 and 1990, Archer points out. "Everything just worked because it was new."

- But in recent years, there have been difficulties: broken escalators and elevators, doors that won't close, tracks that malfunction. The solution proposed by the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority, is to replace all the aging infrastructure that is "at the end of its useful life," Archer says. Unfortunately, that may cost a fortune.

- What might be done instead? Archer proposes shifting to "reliability-centered maintenance." This model "initiates maintenance activities when monitors or tests indicate that an asset's condition is likely to lead to breakdown." For example, remote sensors can easily monitor vibration or temperature, two of the most common leading indicators of breakdowns. With reliability-centered maintenance, the aim is to "initiate the right maintenance at the right time. The result," says Archer, "is that maintenance is less costly and more effective."
 


Back
Top