I personally love the Mill, but I agree it's not necessarily "dumb" to think otherwise.
To me, there are other reasons to attempt to preserve it besides "the street's named after it," including:
- It's the oldest reinforced concrete building in Tempe. "Old" may not always be a reason to preserve, but I think "oldest" sometimes can be.
- It's on the National Register of Historic Places at the State Level of Significance. So obviously the powers that be view it as historically significant.
- It played a significant role in Arizona's history. From this link: From the start of operations in 1874, the Hayden mill became one of the most widely known institutions in the Arizona Territory. In early territorial days the product of this mill was carried in freight wagons and by pack-trains to most of the mining camps and military posts in the Territory and its output was estimated in millions of dollars. Army and government contracts running into hundreds of thousands of dollars were filled from this mill and Hayden Flour was known in every town and mining camp in Arizona. The Salt River Pima Indians grew wheat which they brought to the mill by horseback, and Hayden established trading posts on the Gila River Indian Reservation to supply the mill. Hayden Mills flour sacks were an important source of children’s clothing for many pioneer families. The mill, along with Hayden’s store, warehouses, blacksmith shop, and ferry, became the trade center for the south side of the Salt River Valley.
- The Mill was founded and run by Charles and Carl Hayden, significant figures in Tempe and Arizona history
- I just like them--I think the silos themselves look awesome, and I don't really view them as an "eyesore." And I imagine a lot of people feel the same way.
On a related note, I just looked down there and there is a crew that appears to be preparing to bury the power lines that run on the south side of the Mill. So maybe with that, and the agreement negotiated with the developer, we may finally actually see it redeveloped? To me that's the best case regardless of whether you like the Mill or not.