Meanwhile, a "Downtown Master Plan" seems to be getting pushed back further and further as great projects like Crescent are canceled or linger (7S, Rio+Mill). Papago Grand is at least on the light rail, even though its design is completely suburban, but really -- do we need rendering of anything east of McClintock? Low-rise, brick or stone veneer, and stucco. It isn't going to vary much from that.
So, 1/2 of the block on 1st Street between Farmer and Hardy will be luxury residential, while the rest will be blighted industrial leftovers? Lakefront real estate is all but gone, and with ASU encroaching upon downtown more and more - like turning College Ave into a student housing corridor - these lots are probably the last ones with any draw for non-student housing. Letting a well-known developer with a great product slip over a handful of units is really effing stupid, but not surprising.
Just looking at the project list shows that Tempe will always be ASU + Mill Ave + the Lake. The lakefront properties and ASU talent will allow it to be the hottest suburban submarket, but there just isn't the proper planning in place (or the land) for creating a true downtown vs. a typical suburban main street with some surrounding urban-ish buildings. With downtown Phoenix finally diversifying and being home to a mix of restaurants, bars, boutiques, etc. with tons of room for growth, it's really the only choice for a business or developer wanting a true live/work/play lifestyle rather than just a faux urban environment from 9-5, after which they can get in their SUV and head back to Buckeye.