Tempe Development Thread


Did we already know about this? Looks new to me? I couldn't find any pictures of it though...

http://azbex.com/developer-architect-bring-flair-to-tempe-townhome-project/

Developer, Architect Bring Flair to Tempe Townhome Project
Posted by Matthew Roy on Dec 18th, 2014 // No Comment
facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinmail
By Gremlyn Bradley-Waddell for The Arizona Republic
4 TwentyOneWest is expected to provide a neighbor- and pedestrian-friendly vibe that fits well with events such as the Tempe Festival for the Arts along Mill Avenue. Photo credit: Jessie Wardarski/The Republic
4 TwentyOneWest is expected to provide a neighbor- and pedestrian-friendly vibe that fits well with events such as the Tempe Festival for the Arts along Mill Avenue. Photo credit: Jessie Wardarski/The Republic
For the 24 upscale townhomes they’ve created on an acre near downtown Tempe, developer Irene Clary and architect Bing Hu turned to their equally vibrant hometowns for inspiration.
She recalled the classical brownstone dwellings of her native Toronto, and he harkened back to the similarly styled, urban-and-vertical living spaces of Beijing. Together, the Scottsdale-based professionals have crafted the community of 4 TwentyOneWest using what might best be described as an updated brownstone: an attached, three- or four-story urban dwelling that has “all the elements required for a single-family home,” said Clary, owner of Catclar Investments.
Located at 421 W. Sixth St., this is the third of four projects the duo have worked on. Even though they only recently broke ground in Tempe, they’ve already sold four of the homes, which range in size from just over 1,550 square feet to just over 2,200 square feet and boast private balconies.
Hu, owner of H&S International, said that unlike most other brownstones found elsewhere that typically offer parking in an alleyway, homes at 4 TwentyOneWest offer an attached two-car garage plus additional space where one can leave a car on the driveway or use for guest parking, something of a real luxury for townhome dwellers.
 
I believe we discussed this a few months ago, but I hadn't realized they'd already broken ground. Here's some renderings and floor plans:

http://amacslp.idxbroker.com/idx/photogallery/a012/5194510

It will be less than a block from Encore.

Personally not a fan of 6 new driveways in such a small space, and the rendered landscaping would seem to make it very difficult to see when backing out of one of the garages. But I love that they utilized the alley for the other half of the units, and I imagine that inner courtyard will be a nice place for kids to play under their parents' watchful eyes from the balconies.

Did we already know about this? Looks new to me? I couldn't find any pictures of it though...

http://azbex.com/developer-architect-bring-flair-to-tempe-townhome-project/

Developer, Architect Bring Flair to Tempe Townhome Project
Posted by Matthew Roy on Dec 18th, 2014 // No Comment
facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinmail
By Gremlyn Bradley-Waddell for The Arizona Republic
4 TwentyOneWest is expected to provide a neighbor- and pedestrian-friendly vibe that fits well with events such as the Tempe Festival for the Arts along Mill Avenue. Photo credit: Jessie Wardarski/The Republic
4 TwentyOneWest is expected to provide a neighbor- and pedestrian-friendly vibe that fits well with events such as the Tempe Festival for the Arts along Mill Avenue. Photo credit: Jessie Wardarski/The Republic
For the 24 upscale townhomes they’ve created on an acre near downtown Tempe, developer Irene Clary and architect Bing Hu turned to their equally vibrant hometowns for inspiration.
She recalled the classical brownstone dwellings of her native Toronto, and he harkened back to the similarly styled, urban-and-vertical living spaces of Beijing. Together, the Scottsdale-based professionals have crafted the community of 4 TwentyOneWest using what might best be described as an updated brownstone: an attached, three- or four-story urban dwelling that has “all the elements required for a single-family home,” said Clary, owner of Catclar Investments.
Located at 421 W. Sixth St., this is the third of four projects the duo have worked on. Even though they only recently broke ground in Tempe, they’ve already sold four of the homes, which range in size from just over 1,550 square feet to just over 2,200 square feet and boast private balconies.
Hu, owner of H&S International, said that unlike most other brownstones found elsewhere that typically offer parking in an alleyway, homes at 4 TwentyOneWest offer an attached two-car garage plus additional space where one can leave a car on the driveway or use for guest parking, something of a real luxury for townhome dwellers.
 
WOW those are ugly. I like this type of development in that neighborhood west of the tracks (Riverside?), but any of the other existing brownstone-type developments look much better than this (the modern ones and the faux-historic ones).

And I can't tell, but no way there are all those driveways along 6th street, right? One of the renderings (where there doesn't seem to be any driveways) doesn't match the site plan (where it looks like both sides of the development has driveways).
 
Yeah, this one is UGLY looking. But very appropriate density/development type for this neighborhood.

Indeed there are all those driveways on 6th (and the same amount in the alley). The rendering without driveways is of the interior courtyard.

WOW those are ugly. I like this type of development in that neighborhood west of the tracks (Riverside?), but any of the other existing brownstone-type developments look much better than this (the modern ones and the faux-historic ones).

And I can't tell, but no way there are all those driveways along 6th street, right? One of the renderings (where there doesn't seem to be any driveways) doesn't match the site plan (where it looks like both sides of the development has driveways).
 
Yeah, this one is UGLY looking. But very appropriate density/development type for this neighborhood.

Indeed there are all those driveways on 6th (and the same amount in the alley). The rendering without driveways is of the interior courtyard.

I just spent some time driving the Google mobile around to all of the other brownstone developments in that neighborhood... none of them had individual driveways (and garages) fronting the main street. Even though 6th street isn't a major thoroughfare as it dead ends at the tracks, it still seems like a pretty bad design and a miss for the City to let that through.
 
The existing ones generally tend to have all units share a single driveway (or two, one on each street they front). All the vehicle parking is accessed through an inner courtyard area. That's what I would have preferred to see here, instead of the "zen garden" in the middle. Or they could have done a partial drive space behind the units fronting 6th (moving them directly against the sidewalk), keeping the other units' parking in the alley, and leaving a courtyard green space almost the same size.

Definitely missed opportunity.

I just spent some time driving the Google mobile around to all of the other brownstone developments in that neighborhood... none of them had individual driveways (and garages) fronting the main street. Even though 6th street isn't a major thoroughfare as it dead ends at the tracks, it still seems like a pretty bad design and a miss for the City to let that through.
 
Dear lord, take that thing back to Atlanta where it belongs! So many things wrong with this thing. Unfortunately the uneducated condo buying public will thing they look different and quaint and they will get snapped up quickly.
 
Really glad to see that the apartments are moving forward on the north side of the lake. While they're fairly short, I admire the unique design applied to deal with the overhead utilities and get as many units in as possible. I also love the ground floor retail orientated toward the Marina that the developers hope attracts boat-related businesses. Hopefully, this sparks some additional north-bank development.

As for the 6th street townhomes, it's pretty hard to make dense townhomes anti-urban and they've done a decent job at it. UGH. The floorplans are also terrible if anyone has bothered to get that far.
 
Right?? And people are paying $400k for these???

Really glad to see that the apartments are moving forward on the north side of the lake. While they're fairly short, I admire the unique design applied to deal with the overhead utilities and get as many units in as possible. I also love the ground floor retail orientated toward the Marina that the developers hope attracts boat-related businesses. Hopefully, this sparks some additional north-bank development.

As for the 6th street townhomes, it's pretty hard to make dense townhomes anti-urban and they've done a decent job at it. UGH. The floorplans are also terrible if anyone has bothered to get that far.
 
I definitely don't think these are terrible.
- As for the design - it may not be your taste, but that doesn't make it wrong. I prefer the look of these condos over the faux southwestern beige stucco crap everywhere else. However, I would prefer brick exteriors over this design.
- Anti urban? How? Because it has a garage? That doesn't make it anti-urban. Keep in mind, there is still a front door and walk-out patio facing the street. It's not like these are snout-houses. This is Phoenix, not a fantasy world-these would NOT sell without garages (I wouldn't buy one without a garage).
- $400k doesn't sound unreasonable assuming the materials and finish are nice. You're paying for the location. If these were in Gilbert, they'd be $250k.
 
I definitely don't think these are terrible.
- As for the design - it may not be your taste, but that doesn't make it wrong. I prefer the look of these condos over the faux southwestern beige stucco crap everywhere else. However, I would prefer brick exteriors over this design.
- Anti urban? How? Because it has a garage? That doesn't make it anti-urban. Keep in mind, there is still a front door and walk-out patio facing the street. It's not like these are snout-houses. This is Phoenix, not a fantasy world-these would NOT sell without garages (I wouldn't buy one without a garage).
- $400k doesn't sound unreasonable assuming the materials and finish are nice. You're paying for the location. If these were in Gilbert, they'd be $250k.

Anti-urban in the sense that they've abandoned the traditional model of townhomes in the neighborhood which share a common driveway; 6 driveways off 6th street is pretty ridiculous. Anti-urban might be pushing it, but it's certainly not transit- or pedestrian-oriented design.

Have you seen the floorplans? The options are bizarre, IMO, like adding a bathroom into the ground level which is just a garage... and the master suite is no larger than the additional bedrooms, etc. I don't find anything appealing about these except for the fact that they're infill in an area that could use it.
 
Yep; that's for the SALT development. I took a (very poor quality) picture over the weekend, posted above. I can't imagine all 5 cranes at Marina Heights will stay up for TOO much longer, so we'll probably be back to 6 on the lake in a little while. In the meantime, I'm going to enjoy seeing all 7 up each weekend on my bike rides and grocery runs!

I just saw yesterday that there's a (small) tower crane up at the lot to the west of Marina Heights.
 
Have you seen the floorplans? The options are bizarre, IMO, like adding a bathroom into the ground level which is just a garage... and the master suite is no larger than the additional bedrooms, etc. I don't find anything appealing about these except for the fact that they're infill in an area that could use it.

I agree with that, the floor plans have some "unique" elements.
 
I agree with that, the floor plans have some "unique" elements.

Yeah it looks like the Garage bathroom is the "main level Bathroom" because the living floor has no bathroom. which would be annoying.

As somone with elderly realatives that would be a disaster.

And the Masters have slightly bigger bathrooms and a standing shower.

Definately wouldnt pay extra for that. I split a three bedroom place now and pay more for about twice the square footage and my own bathroom, thats worth it to me!

edit I was just thinking, these look like projects you see on the foreign boards like townhomes for Baku or Tashknet or some other ex soviet central asian city.
 
Last edited:
I definitely don't think these are terrible.
- As for the design - it may not be your taste, but that doesn't make it wrong. I prefer the look of these condos over the faux southwestern beige stucco crap everywhere else. However, I would prefer brick exteriors over this design.
- Anti urban? How? Because it has a garage? That doesn't make it anti-urban. Keep in mind, there is still a front door and walk-out patio facing the street. It's not like these are snout-houses. This is Phoenix, not a fantasy world-these would NOT sell without garages (I wouldn't buy one without a garage).
- $400k doesn't sound unreasonable assuming the materials and finish are nice. You're paying for the location. If these were in Gilbert, they'd be $250k.

I agree with all of this.

I'm just happy they had the guts to build upscale condo's on this lot - and that they're selling. I assumed someone would have to purchase the entire block before this lot got developed. The houses immediately surrounding this development are rundown, single and multifamily homes with trash and pitbull's in their backyard. It took major balls to build these - hopefully this gets the ball rolling on someone buying out the surrounding trash neighbors.
 
Ugly elevation, but exactly what exists in other very urban places like Brooklyn for example. This style of driveway walkups is present in thousands, yes thousands of buildings all over NYC, so is it urban? Yes, Amercian urban. Are they Tashkent or Baku (hilarious comparison, I love it)? No. I'd say more like Atlanta. Brick would have been better for sure.
 
For the most part, I don't agree with people who say there are too many restaurants and bars on Mill. However, at this point, I do agree that it would be nice to see some more retail enter the market.

To me, it's more of a call for variety of dining as there are joints with the same concept at the moment i.e. sandwiches and pizza. I wouldn't be surprised to see few closings last couple years ala what happened with hot dog and froyo. At least change it up with sandwich place with a banh mi shop. Nice to finally see breakfast spots and places like Hot N Juicy Crawfish.
 
Really glad to see that the apartments are moving forward on the north side of the lake. While they're fairly short, I admire the unique design applied to deal with the overhead utilities and get as many units in as possible. I also love the ground floor retail orientated toward the Marina that the developers hope attracts boat-related businesses. Hopefully, this sparks some additional north-bank development.

I drove by today and indeed saw dirt moving and the property fenced off.

Also, Marina Heights is starting to look massive! And one of the taller towers (on the east send) still isn't above ground!

Tempe is going to look absolutely awesome from the North, looking south across the lake if the Monti's project comes through!

Hoping for some good news in the New Year on USAplace and Marriot AC!
 
I agree with all of this.

I'm just happy they had the guts to build upscale condo's on this lot - and that they're selling. I assumed someone would have to purchase the entire block before this lot got developed. The houses immediately surrounding this development are rundown, single and multifamily homes with trash and pitbull's in their backyard. It took major balls to build these - hopefully this gets the ball rolling on someone buying out the surrounding trash neighbors.

Agreed that it's good to see a dense infill development on this lot.

I wonder what the best solution is for those rundown single-family homes along Farmer is. The area is rapidly modernizing and densifying, and I would hope they don't last much longer in their current state. OTOH, with so much empty land for development along that strip, it might be neat to save the buildings and apply Tempe's new adaptive reuse guidelines to these buildings and have a row of unique boutiques/bars/restaurants in the houses, rather than razing them and plopping down another townhome development for example.
 


Back
Top