Spitfiredude
New member
Looks like I finally get to say some positive things about Tempe development. Lots to be excited about! Comments and questions below.
Mill and University
The Good
4-stay hotel with great height and density is a huge score. downtown needs the permanent traffic hotels and apartments bring, especially on the south side. A more upscale customer base is also another huge plus that will help balance out the senior and student housing that has seemed to dominate.
The Bad and Questions:
Nothing but good things from my end! Only questions would be how serious this proposal is given the lot's history? The article made it sound like USA Basketball was also part of this development; is that correct? Others are posting as if it is part of the EcoDistrict. If it is part of this development, even better! That's more density, visitors and from the sounds of it, the talks seem pretty legit.
Centerpoint:
The Good
Finally, downtown is getting a mix of entertainment other than bars. Bringing in the dining model is even better, as once again, it will help attract a wealthier consumer base. This is another shot in the he arm to southern downtown- that area has taken the longest to recover, but the visitors of this theater will bring so much more foot traffic to that plaza area that I can't imagine vacancies won't fill up ASAP!
The Bad and Questions
I was really hoping the former hotel proposal would go through. This would have been a great spot for increased height and the design was beautiful and modern. Any chance the renovations will cover the exterior, or should I not get greedy?
Hanover
The Good
A pattern seems to be forming: higher-end consumer base that is desperately needed to diversify the city. Additionally, residential (along with hotel secondary) is absolutely the most important thing downtown needs. 341 units is a huge addition, especially given that they will be marketed toward graduates.
The Bad and Questions
I can't believe this project was approved in its proposed state. This should have, without doubt, been higher and included retail. Given the size of the lot, they could have gone with a combination of a tower (even just combining the garage with the residential floors for 13-stories) to the west, with town home-style units to the east (3-story units above retail). Having a parking garage with more height than the apartment building in the center of downtown is depressing, especially given the future streetcar's proximity. Finally, with the anti-urban Hayden Square to its north, the lack of retail all but eliminates the extension of downtown's core westward. Was certainly hoping Ash/Farmer would mark the transition toward midrise residential neighborhoods.
State Farm
The Good
Great heights for the lake! We were seeing heights slowly dwindling recently, so I am glad that we will be getting heights over 200 feet. Additionally, I am impressed with the amount of retail spread throughout that will help keep the cold, office campus vibe from creating a dead zone along our greatest amenity in town. I also can't imagine that this won't have major impacts on the Eco/Stadium District and SouthBank. I am most interested in SouthBank since I think there is an obvious need now for residential and hotel development in the immediate area.
The Bad and Questions
I will take other's word for it and assume there will be some tweaks to the designs, as the main structures are awfully boxy. Lakefront development should really have more of an upscale feel to it, which this certainly doesn't. I am also a bit disappointed in the orientation, as it looks like Rio Salado has once again been largely ignored. Obviously, it is challenging seeing as the lake frontage is equally important, but that is a challenge the architects should have met. The parking is also just insane. The garage at HFL is bad enough, but two more 8 story structures is unreal. I appreciate that the office and retail has been incorporated into parta but there is still a huge amount of each in the north and south elevations that is complete dead space. I really wish they had made at least one of these subterranean, and I also question the sheer amount with the streetcar coming through.
Lastly, I am a bit disappointed in the "lakefront plaza." Hopefully, I missed something, but all I see are trees and paths?
Great analyzing. Like a couple have said on here, I am keeping my fingers crossed that the design for the State Farm project is very conceptual, so I would wait to see in the coming weeks/months if anything changes.
As for Hanover, what a complete disappointment! I am excited that nearly 350 units will be added (that means HUGE chance for grocery store), but ONLY 6 stories!? How boring...10-15 would have done the job.
Not only should AMC fill up space, but it should also bring in more retail to the southern part of Mill Ave/DTT. Hopefully we see a vertical development soon on the lot on the SE corner of Mill and 7th street. 10-20 stories would be appropriate there.
Speaking of lots there aren't many left along the Mill corridor:
Mill & 3rd street
Mill & 7th street
Luckily there is still plenty of space along Farmer and Ash Avenue. I hope we see development kick up around here. If we don't see 8+ floor developments along Ash between 5th & 3rd streets, there is practically no chance to see the skyline between the lake and W6 (future University w/hotel) connect.