Tempe streetscape rift leads to shorter medians
By Dianna M. Náñez
The Republic | azcentral.com
Tue Mar 12, 2013 9:46 AM
A backlash from business owners has spurred Tempe to refine a $1.1million street project intended to make walking and biking safer on a busy strip of University Drive near downtown.
The city’s University Drive Streetscape project proposal includes a mix of median islands, landscaping, signalized crosswalks, improved bicycle lanes and sidewalk upgrades. The changes are targeted along University from Ash Avenue to Priest Drive.
Although the medians drew support from Tempe’s bicycling community, the city plans to reduce their length. The change is in response to merchants on University who said medians would inhibit vehicles driven by potential customers from making left turns into their businesses.
About a dozen bicyclists and business owners at odds over the proposed medians attended a City Council meeting last month to offer their thoughts.
Bicycling advocate Ryan Guzy is among the Tempe residents who expressed support for the center medians, saying it would increase safety for pedestrians and bicyclists who share the street with vehicles.
Several Arizona State University students, who travel the street on their way to campus, told the council that they fear for their safety when competing with speeding cars in heavy traffic.
Merchants who spoke at the meeting agreed that the safety measures, including signalized crosswalks and landscaping, are much needed.
But business owners expressed concern over the median islands, describing them as a barrier to their businesses.
“I have not found a single (business) owner who wants medians on University Drive,” said Arthur Markman, who operates Tempe Feed & Tack on University.
But bicyclists say that the medians may increase the businesses’ customer base.
One ASU student told the council that “going down University on a bike is so stressful, I intentionally avoid it, and by doing so, I also avoid the businesses there.”
The exchange grew heated after the public comments when Mayor Mark Mitchell left the council dais to discuss merchants’ concerns. One business owner said Mitchell had ignored him while he was offering his thoughts to the council.
“You made a mockery of my time,” Markman said.
Mitchell apologized and said it was his intention to listen to the business community.
On Thursday, Greg Eccles, who owns Tops Liquors Plaza near Farmer Avenue and University, said Mitchell followed up with business owners after the council meeting, inviting them to a sit-down this month.
“I think it was impressive that he wanted to listen,” Eccles said. “There were about 20 business owners there.”
Eccles said many business owners back the project.
“We want the traffic safety,” he said, adding that the signalized crosswalks will “unite the neighborhoods” on the north and south sides of University.
However, Eccles said the medians aren’t just a barrier to traffic but could also create safety concerns.
“It would force them to make U-turns, which are very unsafe,” he said.
With an increase in residents riding bicycles as their primary mode of transportation, cities are forced to balance the needs of everyone using streets.
Miah Spring, who biked Thursday to Tempe Farmers Market on University and Farmer, said she opts for public transportation, bicycling and walking over driving a car.
Spring said that people do not realize how unsafe University and other Tempe streets near ASU are until they have biked or walked on them.
Spring said she was hospitalized last year after a car hit her while she was bicycling near Rio Salado and Packard Drive.
“I got smacked on my bike,” she said. “And that’s not anywhere near as busy as this part of University.”
Eric Iwersen, Tempe’s interim transportation planning manager, said the city is considering the needs of the community. He characterized the revisions to reduce the medians as minor adjustments.
“Our first priority is to make sure things are operating safely,” he said. “This refined median concept with less medians, it will improve the safety of the street while still recognizing the importance of business.”
Iwersen said the proposal includes adding two signalized crosswalks, at Farmer and at Roosevelt Street, to the approximately milelong project. That would make for a total of six signalized crosswalks, including the current ones at Priest Drive, Ash Avenue, Hardy Drive and Beck Avenue.
“For a mile section in Tempe that would be one of your highest number of signalized crosswalks,” he said.
Other amenities proposed for University would increase landscaping, a buffer that would texture portions of the street between the bike lanes and vehicle lanes as well texture areas bordering the crosswalks. Iwersen said the texture changes alert drivers to be more vigilant of pedestrians and bicyclists with whom they share the street.
Although drivers may make U-turns at the medians to enter a business, adding islands increases safety because it concentrates areas where drivers may make left turns, Iwersen said.
The city plans to complete the proposal this month. The project would be presented to the public at a meeting or through other notices. The city’s transportation commission and the council will review the changes.
Construction is expected to start after January 2014 and be completed before the end of that year.
Michelle Francis, who owns Rare Lion Antiques and Jewelry on University, said given the project’s importance to the community, the city owes it to residents and businesses to keep them aware of changes.
“Keep us informed, and do whatever they can to keep the street open during construction,” she said. “The economy is terrible. We need all the courtesy they can extend to us.”
Iwersen said that the city would keep the public informed and that the wealth of feedback is making for a better project.
“I think in the end we’re going to have a positive project that is supported by the business community and neighbors alike,” he said.