Not to turn this into a political discussion but you sort of set yourself up with the last question. Bank bailouts by both the Bush and Obama administrations have taught large companies that there is no risk in their business. America has decided they are too large to fail, so they are expanding even though there is no money because the government won't let them go out of business even if they make bad decisions.
Or at least that's my theory. I don't see any smaller banks or credit unions on your list of those expanding seemingly senselessly.
City council members annoyed by lack of communication from developers
Phoenix Business Journal - by Mike Sunnucks and Jan Buchholz
PrintEmailReprintsRSS FeedsLinkedInShareComments
Jim Poulin/Phoenix Business Journal
The Centerpoint condo high-rise is in Chapter 7 bankruptcy and sits unfinished on Mill Avenue in Tempe.
View Larger Some Valley city council members are frustrated with the lack of updates they are getting from real estate developers regarding projects tabled by the market crash and recession.
A slew of construction projects have fallen short of expectations, and council members across the Valley are giving developers and their lawyers mixed reviews on keeping their respective cities updated.
“No, no, no, no, no,” Tempe City Councilman Ben Arredondo said when asked whether he’s been kept up to date on the status of stalled projects -- including the Tempe Centerpoint condo high-rise, which is in Chapter 7 bankruptcy and sits unfinished on Mill Avenue.
Arredondo said he’s not getting frequent or detailed enough updates on Centerpoint or other projects. He said developers -- especially those in distressed situations, such as Centerpoint -- aren’t giving Valley cities straight answers on their projects.
“I don’t think they are ever going to give us the bottom line,” Arredondo said.
Developers and their various lawyers aren’t specifically obligated to keep cities updated on their projects, but some city council members are worried about the status of delayed or abandoned developments and how they might hurt short- and long-term economic development.
Centerpoint developer Ken Losch did not respond to requests for comment.
Centerpoint is not the Valley’s only distressed real estate development. The Hotel Monroe redevelopment in downtown Phoenix sits empty and boarded up. Downtown condos such as 44 Monroe and the Summit at Copper Square are mostly empty, and a significant number of suburban subdivisions and commercial developments are unfinished or delayed because of lack of demand and financing.
“I think that everyone is cautious and holding close to the vest. This goes beyond the developers, as end-users are placing projects on hold,” said Surprise City Councilman John Williams. “That said, I believe much of the information shared is often one-sided and biased and may not reflect the exact state of our economic recovery.”
Valley cities signed off on scores of retail, condo, single-home and commercial projects during the real estate boom. Now, many of those projects are on the back burner.
“Many of (the planned projects) look foolish in hindsight, but most looked really good at the time,” said Phoenix City Councilman Tom Simplot.
Chandler spokesman David Bigos said Jeff Cline, developer of the abandoned Elevation Chandler mixed-use condo project, has not kept in touch with the city. That project, near Chandler Fashion Center, is in Chapter 11 bankruptcy. A bungled foreclosure auction has complicated the court’s disposition of the project.
“Elevation Chandler has been very difficult for our city. We’d like to see a solution to this stalled project as soon as possible,” Bigos said.
Cline could not be reached for comment. Bigos said the city has had to follow the project’s status via bankruptcy proceedings.
Still, Bigos said other builders and developers have been better about keeping Chandler city officials informed.
“Because of the current economy, everyone understands this is a down market. So being up-front and honest only makes sense because we all have a vested interest in survival as well as maintaining what we have in place,” he said.
Glendale City Councilwoman Joyce Clark said developer updates often occur behind closed doors as informal chats with affected city officials rather than during public meetings. Overall, she said West Valley developers and their lawyers keep her updated on their projects.
“They are very good about keeping us informed,” she said.
Clark said she is concerned about the economic health of Westgate City Center, but she is seeing some optimistic signs from that retail complex. She declined to share details about Westgate or other projects.
After extensive efforts to obtain updates on several of the largest mixed-use developments in the Valley, few elected officials wanted to discuss the uncertain, even dire, financial situations facing some of them. The Phoenix Business Journal asked for comments about those projects — including CityScape, CityNorth and Main Street Glendale — from the cities of Phoenix, Glendale, Tempe, Scottsdale and Chandler. The only responses from public officials are those noted above.
Mayor hits on budget cuts, tax increases in state of city address
by Dianna M. Náñez - Nov. 10, 2009 03:12 PM
The Arizona Republic .
It was not a traditional State of the City Address.
No major development announcements. An abbreviated list of city accomplishments, compared to years prior.
And instead of focusing on the city's goals for the next year, the estimated 320 people in the audience listened to Mayor Hugh Hallman spotlight the Tempe people and agencies that are working to lift the city out of a financial crisis that has left families across the nation reeling and states and cities facing massive budget cuts.
The audience at the speech, which was hosted by the Tempe Chamber of Commerce at the Buttes Marriott Resort included business owners, faith leaders, non-profit workers and city officials.
Minutes into his speech, Hallman acknowledged that weak revenue collections could result in a nearly $22.5 million gap between spending and revenue by the June 30 end of the fiscal year. That scenario is predicated on Tempe making no cuts to its budget this year.
But Hallman's speech comes as city officials are discussing cuts that could result in a major operational restructuring where nearly half of the existing departments would be combined with other departments, could force Tempe to execute the first layoffs in city history and would inevitably spur scaled back neighborhood services.
Despite the gravity of the speech's tone, the message was on track, said Michael Monti, a longtime Tempe businessman and owner of Monti's La Casa Vieja, a downtown Tempe landmark built in 1871 as the home of Charles T. Hayden.
"This was much better than a glitzy Disneyland-like development presentation. There was a frank recognition of the needs right now. These are very tough times . . . most of us are fighting to get back on our feet," he said. "That wasn't being swept under the rug."
After noting the estimated 10-percent reduction in sales-tax collections Tempe has tallied for the first four months of the 2009-10 fiscal year, compared to the same period last year, Hallman discussed specific financial measures the city is considering.
Those options include increasing the city's bed tax, capping health care expenses at current levels and eliminating vacant positions.
An idea that would combine Tempe's departments would "reduce the high-end (management)...taking the city back (to levels seen) seven years (ago)," Hallman said.
While the job losses would be painstaking, Hallman said Tempe was determined to fast-track budget measures that would begin saving the city money. That commitment was lacking at the state Legislature, he said, reiterating criticism he made at last year's State of the City. Restating his frustration with legislators and Gov. Jan Brewer, Hallman called on state leaders to begin a new round of budget cuts.
"The state still faces a deficit of at least $2 billion-and some believe $3 billion-for this fiscal year and little action is being taken to address the challenge," he said. "We are still waiting to see on what terms the governor will call the Legislature into special session to deal with this fiscal crisis. We need state leaders to learn, as we have, that it is better to fix the things that cause holes in the boat than it is always to be bailing water. I call on all assembled here and those who may watch this address later to contact state leaders to take action quickly, before fewer options remain available and we have a shorter period of time in which to take necessary action."
Rather than simply listing recent city accomplishments, which despite a tough economy were resulting in what Hallman referred to as "a sustainable culture, environment and economy," the mayor profiled the work of Tempe residents, business people and other local stakeholders.
Hallman introduced a video of Christina Cenzano, who manages the newly opened and independently owned Dave's Electric Brewpub in downtown Tempe.
"We couldn't have picked a better spot (to open)," she said of the pub's location near City Hall and across from Arizona State University's Wells Fargo Arena and a light-rail station that shares a lot with the Tempe Transportation Center. "We've got a fantastic location . . . (with) the city staff right next to us, ASU, the faculty. (Tempe's) gone above and beyond . . . in getting us through the permitting process, getting our patio built, getting our bar built. The relationships are priceless. It is a grassroots connection within the community, and everybody's really helped us rise to the occasion."
Hallman noted other Tempe recognitions in the past year, including BusinessWeek magazine in March naming Tempe the best place in Arizona to open a business. He also noted awards the city won for using green-building standards in the construction of the East Valley Bus Operations and Maintenance Center and its Transportation Center.
To spotlight the city's contribution to recreating a Tempe music scene, which Hallman lamented was "allowed to disappear" in recent years, the mayor introduced longtime Valley crooner Walt Richardson.
Richardson's video monologue praised the city's creation of a weekly open-mic session at the Tempe Center for the Arts and Thursday's Music on Mill series where local musicians play on downtown's street corners.
Tempe was "creating a buzz" in the music community and "setting a stage for a new (music) scene," Richardson said.
After thanking Tempe's faith community for helping the city's struggling families through the recession, Hallman introduced Pastor Sang-Hoon Yoo. Hallman praised Yoo for his efforts with "For Our City," an interfaith group that was partnering with the city and other organizations to expand services for needy residents.
"Now is the time to be called into serving the needy instead of just serving the people in the church," Yoo said in a video. "I think the main thing is how the city government can work with the faith community to serve the community better."
Hallman's presentation also included videos highlighting Tempe's redevelopment along the light-rail line, which has grown faster compared to Phoenix and Mesa, and of a resident who lived near a recently redeveloped Tempe park.
After each video, Hallman asked the crowd to applaud the residents who were contributing to Tempe's success.
Hallman concluded his speech with a plea to the audience. Pointing to gift bags on the tables, the mayor asked everyone to consider leaving a donation for the Tempe Community Action Agency food pantry.
"With the holidays coming, our food pantries need help from all of us," he said. "All I'm asking from you today is that, if you have a spare $10.00 bill, place it in the envelope and put the envelope back in the bag."
The 2009 State of the City Address was presented by Edward Jones and sponsored by Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport, Insight, PMT Ambulance, State Farm Insurance, US Airways, McCarthy Construction, Cox Communications, Motorola, Western Refining, AlphaGraphics and the Tempe Republic.
State Sen. Meg Burton Cahill announced Tuesday that she won't seek re-election in 2010.
It's a move that sets in motion a series of political dominoes as Democrats try to maintain control of legislative District 17, a swing district that includes Tempe and south Scottsdale.
Next year marks Burton Cahill's 10th at the Legislature, which she joined with her election to the House in 2000. But the Tempe Democrat has battled chronic pain in her ankle and back, and said she has been advised to seek a less pressure-packed occupation.
"I have a couple doctors who believe my health would be better if I was working in a non-hostile work environment," said Burton Cahill, who isn't term-limited from the seat until 2014.
With her expected departure, state Rep. David Schapira took the first steps to campaign for what will be an open Senate seat by announcing the formation of an exploratory committee. Because of the state's resign-to-run law, the Tempe Democrat can't formally launch his campaign until January.
Schapira's campaign for the Senate would open his House seat, and Tempe City Councilman Ben Arredondo wasted no time launching his campaign. A longtime Republican, Arredondo registered as a Democrat a little over a month ago - explaining that the party was "where I'm most comfortable."
Arredondo is currently serving his fourth city council term, which expires in July. Burton Cahill said she feels comfortable having Arredondo join the Democratic slate of candidates in District 17, explaining, "he has been voting Democratic (on the City Council) for a long, long time."
Urban garden to be planted in downtown Tempe
8 commentsNov. 17, 2009 10:37 AM
.
The Downtown Tempe Community in partnership with the Phoenix Permaculture Guild and Caffe Boa's Chef Payton Curry
, will be announcing the launch of Arizona's first urban garden.
The announcement will take place at Caffe Boa at 4 p.m. Thursday during a special reception featuring food items that represent products that may be grown in the garden.
The urban garden will be planted at Fifth Street north of the City Hall garage.
The garden will give Valley chefs and the community at large access to locally grown, organic produce and ingredients to use in their culinary creations.
Curry is leading the charge for Valley chefs to get involved and use locally-grown ingredients on their menus.
Goldwater Institute sues over aquarium kickbacks
By Linda Bentley | November 25, 2009
Hypocrisy at the Tempe taxpayer trough
PHOENIX – On Monday, the Goldwater Institute filed a complaint on behalf of a group of Tempe business owners and taxpayers against the city of Tempe, mayor and council, seeking a preliminary injunction to halt taxpayer-funded subsidies from being provided to Merlin Entertainments Group to build a 26,000 square-foot Sea Life Aquarium at Arizona Mills Mall.
Merlin, which owns Legoland, Madame Tussaud’s wax museums as well as other amusement parks around the world, is a United Kingdom-based company that is second to Disney as the largest operator of attractions worldwide.
In August, Tempe City Council entered into a development agreement to provide for taxes and fees in excess of $148,000 to be paid to the developer as follows: a) rebate all construction sales taxes to the developer up to $900,000; b) rebate all transaction privilege taxes to the developer up to $78,000; and c) rebate all planning, engineering and building safety processing fees (excluding water and sewer development fees and residential development taxes) paid by the developer after Jan. 1, 2009, and waive all future fees up to $70,000.
With the project already underway, the aquarium’s developer has already received rebates and/or waived fees in excess of $25,000.
According to the Goldwater Institute, the development agreement violates the Arizona Constitution’s gift clause, which provides that neither the state nor any city “shall ever give or loan its credit in the aid of, or make any donation or grant, by subsidy or otherwise, to any individual, association or corporation …”
The case is not dissimilar to Turken v. Gordon in which Phoenix business owners sued the city of Phoenix, mayor and city council for issuing tax rebates to the developer of CityNorth.
In Turken, the Arizona Court of Appeals stated, “Promoting economic development, retail uses, employment, an urban core, an increased tax base, and related benefits – even if laudable goals that the city may pursue – are not a valid public purpose for which the city may expend public funds under the gift clause.”
Plaintiffs claim Tempe’s actions discriminate among businesses, depriving plaintiffs’ privileges or immunities made exclusively to Merlin, stating the discriminatory treatment is not rationally related to a legitimate governmental purpose.
In May 2005, Tempe Mayor Hugh Hallman joined Phoenix Mayor Phil Gordon and Chandler Mayor Boyd Dunn in signing an agreement not to offer tax subsidies to retail developers along their common borders.
Then, on Sept. 25, 2009, Hallman joined Scottsdale Mayor Jim Lane and Paradise Valley Mayor Vernon Parker in an opinion published in the Arizona Republic stating a subsidy gift of tax rebates for a Phoenix mall developer was wrong and in violation of the Arizona Constitution, stating, “The needless waste of taxpayer resources, the shift in tax burden to others, government’s selective favoring of some and government’s arbitrary creation of an unfair competitive advantage are all problems created by illegal gifts of public money to favored businesses.”