Here is the historic preservation commission agenda which has a link to some renderings for the proposal:
https://www.tempe.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/102969/638241726377598863
It's okay, still not sure how I feel about it. As some here predicted they're proposing to maintain the main sanctuary/chapel of the first congregational church and demo the classroom and office space. They are also proposing to build on the House of Tricks lot. I had not realized that House of Tricks was on the national register of historic places. Interestingly, they are apparently trying to weigh whether it is feasible to move the House of Tricks house to another location in Tempe. If that is not feasible or acceptable to the powers that be, I suppose they will have to go back to the drawing board on that portion.