Tempe Development Thread


^ It's good to know there are people in this city who want to preserve what adds character and we're not bulldozing all in the sake of something shiny but I have myself questioning this project. Will Monti's close if this is built?? I don't it will but all these articles with flaming comments has me wondering myself.
 
^ It's good to know there are people in this city who want to preserve what adds character and we're not bulldozing all in the sake of something shiny but I have myself questioning this project. Will Monti's close if this is built?? I don't it will but all these articles with flaming comments has me wondering myself.

I've heard that it's "business as usual for now" at Monti's, but I also read between the lines an intention to close eventually. Kimpton hotels usually have good restaurants, so there may be no net loss even if Monti's does go away. To be honest, I'd miss it more for nostalgia than the actual food. If the Hayden House is thoughtfully incorporated into the new development, we can keep some of the nostalgia in place while still moving forward with the dense, walkable transit-oriented development Tempe has been smart to embrace.
 
They're preserving the original structure and not building over it like the heinous proposals from back during the boom years. I'm pretty strict with my HP thoughts, but in this case, I don't see an issue at all. This project will bring much more attention and foot traffic to the intersection where two iconic structures sit - something that is extremely difficult given the huge Palms parking lot on the other side. It makes perfect sense for visitors of the city to be boarding right next to the Mill and Hayden House.

I really hope this spurs some interest in the Mill again; love Tempe for what it did in the meantime instead of leaving it abandoned, but it deserves to become more of a draw - whether through retail, apartments, or some other mix.
 
I've heard that it's "business as usual for now" at Monti's, but I also read between the lines an intention to close eventually. Kimpton hotels usually have good restaurants, so there may be no net loss even if Monti's does go away. To be honest, I'd miss it more for nostalgia than the actual food. If the Hayden House is thoughtfully incorporated into the new development, we can keep some of the nostalgia in place while still moving forward with the dense, walkable transit-oriented development Tempe has been smart to embrace.

I believe the plan to to preserve the historic part of the building (not the add-on portion) and for Monti's to continue to occupy that space. They spent some money on a really cool patio bar in the last couple of years and I think that would thrive with the new offices and hotel.

I could be wrong, but I thought I read that Monti's is not going anywhere.
 
Correct me if I am wrong, but I though it was the Monti Family that sold the property. It would be difficult for me to keep running a steak house, albeit a great one, with that much change in my pocket.
 
Any word on the progress of The Grand (1010 Lemon)?

Drove by yesterday and it's on third to fourth floor. Hub II is coming along quickly compared to Hayden Ferry Lakeside III from when I last visited in August. I noticed 903 South Rural site finally demoed the abandoned strip mall (Dominoes Pizza). Wonder if mixed-use residential development is still in play for that.
 
/\That old Domino's Pizza strip was demolished at some time early this year or even last year.

Good to hear about The Grand. That nearly completes that neighborhood/student ghetto.
 
I believe the plan to to preserve the historic part of the building (not the add-on portion) and for Monti's to continue to occupy that space. They spent some money on a really cool patio bar in the last couple of years and I think that would thrive with the new offices and hotel.

I could be wrong, but I thought I read that Monti's is not going anywhere.

Some comments made by Michael Monti on Facebook suggest the restaurant will not endure. Unfortunately, I can't find a way to link to them from here, but here are some quotes:

"This was not a decision taken lightly, but sometimes things have to change. I love the history and tradition of our place but our model of business has been carried as far as we could take it. This transaction preserve the historic structure in the hands of a person has committed to doing right by it and gives our families security. it's still business as usual for the time being and soon we will announce some nostalgia events and our final schedule."

"When the filet steak lunch we used to sell with fries and cheese toast for $5 costs me $18 raw on the plate, it's time to go. If I raise prices enough to stay in business, it won't be Monti's anymore, anyway. Sad logic, but I can't dodge it any longer. The memories will live on in our 'alumni' and the historic building."
 
Some comments made by Michael Monti on Facebook suggest the restaurant will not endure. Unfortunately, I can't find a way to link to them from here, but here are some quotes:

"This was not a decision taken lightly, but sometimes things have to change. I love the history and tradition of our place but our model of business has been carried as far as we could take it. This transaction preserve the historic structure in the hands of a person has committed to doing right by it and gives our families security. it's still business as usual for the time being and soon we will announce some nostalgia events and our final schedule."

"When the filet steak lunch we used to sell with fries and cheese toast for $5 costs me $18 raw on the plate, it's time to go. If I raise prices enough to stay in business, it won't be Monti's anymore, anyway. Sad logic, but I can't dodge it any longer. The memories will live on in our 'alumni' and the historic building."

I would say those sound like final words to me. I've never been there myself, but I can't really say I've ever heard a glowing review of it either... I think half the attraction comes from dining in that cool old house... I've never heard particularly positive reviews of the food.
I'm glad the structure will be preserved, and I hope that a cool new restaurant takes its place!
 
I would say those sound like final words to me. I've never been there myself, but I can't really say I've ever heard a glowing review of it either... I think half the attraction comes from dining in that cool old house... I've never heard particularly positive reviews of the food.
I'm glad the structure will be preserved, and I hope that a cool new restaurant takes its place!

I hope so, too. Here's another quote I found that seems to confirm that might be happening:

"The historic Hayden House will remain--11,000 s.f of adobe building--and be rehabbed by the developer for, most likely, another F&B tenant. It was not an easy decision, but the right and necessary thing to do."
 
I hope so, too. Here's another quote I found that seems to confirm that might be happening:

"The historic Hayden House will remain--11,000 s.f of adobe building--and be rehabbed by the developer for, most likely, another F&B tenant. It was not an easy decision, but the right and necessary thing to do."

Thanks for that, I was mistaken, or maybe just was wishful thinking. At least the structure stays
 
B0-h7E9CMAETJrw.jpg


Marina Heights on October 27 (source)
 
Blah don't care for Monti's... I've been there twice and it was not anything special. For me below average. The building is staying and that is what is important.

I think we are starting to see consistency for downtown building height. I know some people don't like that much height is occurring closer to Mill, but I think that its fine. It keeps a small town feel for the neighborhood. I was in downtown Bellevue (Seattle) last weekend and it made me think of Tempe for some reason - on a slightly larger scale. There was a mixture of high rise/mid rise development. Some development did not have ground floor retail, but majority did. This is what I notice is trending with height:

The outskirts have the taller buildings (Univ, College, Ash, Lake)..

Going toward the core (Mill/5th) you see a trend toward mid rise development (Hanover, Orchidhouse/Brickyard, Gateway building, mid rise directly south of Gateway, Residence Inn, possible future development)...

Mill is mostly low rise which is expected.

On the outside of the high rise sections you have mid rise to low rise (Farmer Avenue-west of Farmer Avenue; Apartments south of Omni).

The lake is pretty much all mid rise and up. I'm not sure what to think about "SALT" (that name sounds lame..HFL lofts were better).

I want everyone's opinion on the consideration of high rise, mid rise, low rise for Tempe standards? Obviously high rise in Tempe vs Phoenix vs Chicago will be different. IMO, I think below 50' is low rise, 50-200' is mid rise, and 200'+ is high rise.
 
Blah don't care for Monti's... I've been there twice and it was not anything special. For me below average. The building is staying and that is what is important.

I think we are starting to see consistency for downtown building height. I know some people don't like that much height is occurring closer to Mill, but I think that its fine. It keeps a small town feel for the neighborhood. I was in downtown Bellevue (Seattle) last weekend and it made me think of Tempe for some reason - on a slightly larger scale. There was a mixture of high rise/mid rise development. Some development did not have ground floor retail, but majority did. This is what I notice is trending with height:

The outskirts have the taller buildings (Univ, College, Ash, Lake)..

Going toward the core (Mill/5th) you see a trend toward mid rise development (Hanover, Orchidhouse/Brickyard, Gateway building, mid rise directly south of Gateway, Residence Inn, possible future development)...

Mill is mostly low rise which is expected.

On the outside of the high rise sections you have mid rise to low rise (Farmer Avenue-west of Farmer Avenue; Apartments south of Omni).

The lake is pretty much all mid rise and up. I'm not sure what to think about "SALT" (that name sounds lame..HFL lofts were better).

I want everyone's opinion on the consideration of high rise, mid rise, low rise for Tempe standards? Obviously high rise in Tempe vs Phoenix vs Chicago will be different. IMO, I think below 50' is low rise, 50-200' is mid rise, and 200'+ is high rise.

Bellevue is on a much larger scale as you noted; while Tempe is experiencing a boom and is the most dense, urban place in the valley, it still is lacking when you consider similar cities. It's still growing up from a small-town college-focused area to a more metropolitan city with a well-rounded economy.

Not only is Tempe landlocked, but its downtown is essentially defined by natural (Salt River, Tempe Butte) and mand-made borders (ASU, Loop 202), meaning that all development really needs to be smartly planned. I think your breakdown of where highrise, midrise and lowrise development needs to occur is spot on, but the problem is that current development trends aren't following that pattern. Mill between Rio Salado and University is fine with < 5 stories, but that should expand to ~20 along the lake, 10-20 along Ash and College, and 5-10 along Farmer and Apache.

Lakefront development should all be in the 200'-300' range, and yet SALT is 4 stories and the Jefferson is 6. Ash should have staggering heights between 10-20 stories to balance off the precedent set by W6, yet Hanover is 5 stories and Ash/University right now is only slated for 82' on a lot that should be 20+ stories. Etc, etc. I won't hate on USA Place because at least its model is very sustainable and dense if built out according to plan, but even that is rather sprawled out with nothing more than 8 stories aside from a 14-story hotel over a very significant portion of land.

College is essentially filled up unless some redevelopment occurs and, unfortunately, the only building more than a few stories is student housing. Hopefully, the last phase of College Commons/Block 12 includes a market rate tower and retail so that at least there's a nice variety instead of being essentially a more public campus mall.

Lastly, Apache is filling up with low-rises, student housing, and 1-house structures, when it should be a mix of market rate and affordable housing almost ALL mixed use in order to promote a true, transit-friendly neighborhood along that corridor. Gracie's Village was a great development, but those folks still need a car in order to buy their daily necessities because no developments have gone up/or will be going up that intend to bring groceries, hardware stores, dry cleaners, fast food, ethnic markets, etc.

I think with the Stadium District, we might need to start looking at Rural a and University as the next attractive roads that can handle mid-high rise development. Rural is a solid midpoint between the 101 and McClintock and Priest and some high, urban development on both would really help connect the dots. Otherwise, development is going to sprawl beyond the current LRT, BRT is still years away, and the streetcar does nothing to help alleviate this because it's essentially redundant with the light rail. That route should've been kept to Rio Salado and gone down further East, or attempted to connect the other areas where development might/will occur: Broadway/10, Papago Park and Southern/Rural (like, say a line that ran from Broadway/Priest up Priest to McDowell/Rural).
 
Last edited:
Well, it looks like Monti's is going out of business....

http://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/tempe/2014/11/03/tempes-iconic-montis-la-casa-vieja-closing-nov/18436845/

Amy Edelen, The Republic | azcentral.com 5:30 p.m. MST November 3, 2014

Tempe's iconic Monti's La Casa Vieja, the oldest restaurant in the city that is housed in the historic Hayden House on Mill Avenue, is closing on Nov. 17 after nearly 60 years in business, restaurant owner Michael Monti confirmed Monday, Nov. 3.

Monti said that for some time he's been interested in arranging developments around the Hayden House and due to growing operating costs of the restaurant he decided to sell.

Sad to see the business go, but it was bound to happen eventually.
 
Just happened to go there a couple of weeks ago during the Oktoberfest - had no idea it would be the last time.

As said - decent - but nothing special when a late lunch for 4 with only a couple of drinks was 100+ bucks....
 
Well, damn - there goes one of the few draws to that northern edge of between the lake and heart of downtown. I hope HFIII ends up including some visible retail, but I don't think it will.

Hopefully, this development actually happens. Would hate to see TWO landmarks abandoned at that gateway intersection.
 
PD-Jefferson-Lake-600x313.jpg


New articcle and Rendering for the PLaya del Norte condo:

http://azbex.com/tdi-developing-50m-jefferson-town-lake-multi-family-complex/

The luxury multi-family complex, which is being called Jefferson Town Lake, is targeted for a 1.62-acre site that is bordered on the north by Playa del Norte Drive. Jefferson Town Lake Holdings GP LLC paid $4.2M to purchase the 1.5-acre site from PDN Group LLC.

Jefferson Town Lake will have 418KSF of total building area in a six-story, 85-foot structure. The project includes 432 parking spaces with an underground podium garage.

Design plans from ORB Architects in Phoenix shows a mix of studio, one- and two-bedroom units ranging from 552 sq. ft. to roughly 1,300 sq. ft. Construction should be underway by fourth quarter 2015 with an opening anticipated mid-2017. Build out expected to take 29 months.

I know this got a lot of flack but Id rather see developments of this density valley wide than a few flashy towers seperated by miles of sprawl.
 
PD-Jefferson-Lake-600x313.jpg


New articcle and Rendering for the PLaya del Norte condo:

http://azbex.com/tdi-developing-50m-jefferson-town-lake-multi-family-complex/



I know this got a lot of flack but Id rather see developments of this density valley wide than a few flashy towers seperated by miles of sprawl.

There's no reason that there can't be "flashy towers" AND dense development. Nobody here would advocate for miles of sprawl; but, Tempe is a landlocked city with an even more defined downtown core, with finite land available for development along the lake in particular. Wasting prime lots on 6 story buildings hurts the long-term potential for the city to have dense enough nodes of downtown that can support walkable, urban hubs. Towers in general tend to be slightly anti-urban and Playa del Norte is in a rather unwalkable part of town... it was a pretty perfect location for a large tower that could've provided a nice end-cap to what is mostly a low-midrise development. Visually, the development also will look rather flat and medioce with buildings all at the same level.

This would've been a perfect development on Farmer or Apache. But, instead we're seeing 3-4 stories on those blocks and 5 stories along the lake and Ash where higher, 10+ story buildings should be going.

I think everyone wants a dense, walkable downtown. But, certain areas need to be denser/taller than others for the city to work.
 


Back
Top