Stimulus misappropriation / misallocation


lawfin

New member
Stimulus misappropriation / misallocation

0709-nat-subPROJECTS.gif



I was worried stuff like this would occur.

Enough with funding rural roads

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/09/us/09projects.html?_r=1&hp


Two-thirds of the country lives in large metropolitan areas, home to the nation’s worst traffic jams and some of its oldest roads and bridges. But cities and their surrounding regions are getting far less than two-thirds of federal transportation stimulus money.
Skip to next paragraph
Multimedia
Transportation Projects Across the NationGraphic
Transportation Projects Across the Nation

According to an analysis by The New York Times of 5,274 transportation projects approved so far — the most complete look yet at how states plan to spend their stimulus money — the 100 largest metropolitan areas are getting less than half the money from the biggest pot of transportation stimulus money. In many cases, they have lost a tug of war with state lawmakers that urban advocates say could hurt the nation’s economic engines.

The stimulus law provided $26.6 billion for highways, bridges and other transportation projects, but left the decision on how to spend most of it to the states, which have a long history of giving short shrift to major metropolitan areas when it comes to dividing federal transportation money. Now that all 50 states have beat a June 30 deadline by winning approval for projects that will use more than half of that transportation money, worth $16.4 billion, it is clear that the stimulus program will continue that pattern of spending disproportionately on rural areas.
 
I don't have a huge problem with many rural roads getting substantial amounts of stimulus funds, as these roads can be some of the worst in any given state. They're the last to get improved, the last to be repaved, the last to have bridges replaced. Out of sight, out of mind...

If rural roads get a lot of stimulus monies, it should make more state DOT funds available for the urban areas, though. Besides, infrastructure is infrastructure, jobs are jobs, rural and urban alike...

Aaron (Glowrock)
 
I don't have a huge problem with many rural roads getting substantial amounts of stimulus funds, as these roads can be some of the worst in any given state. They're the last to get improved, the last to be repaved, the last to have bridges replaced. Out of sight, out of mind...

If rural roads get a lot of stimulus monies, it should make more state DOT funds available for the urban areas, though. Besides, infrastructure is infrastructure, jobs are jobs, rural and urban alike...

Aaron (Glowrock)
I'm not sure I really agree with that, at least that's what I see in Chicago. The inner city roads are among the worst I've ever had the displeasure of riding on. Far worse than anywhere else in the state.
 
^Same here as best I can tell... Some roads in the inner city haven't been touched for decades (like 60-100yrs+), to the point where you can't drive faster than 15-20mph (if you're lucky)... I can promise you that there isn't a single paved road in other parts of the county that hasn't had work done on it for more than 30 years or so.

And let's not even start on the issue of poorly planned suburban roads which have to be torn up and widened long before their life cycle is ever over.
 
Besides, infrastructure is infrastructure, jobs are jobs, rural and urban alike...

Aaron (Glowrock)

Not really, and only from the most near-term perspective possible - infrastructure is only really infrastructure if its useful in supporting economic activity. Otherwise, why not build infinity bridges to nowhere? Useless infrastructure ties up capital into fixed improvements and structures that generate no economic benefit, are illiquid and immovable, and eventually need to be replaced (the "need" being political, not practical), meaning more wasted money down the road. Useless pork infrastructure is at best a jobs/welfare program for union construction workers, and at worst just flushing money down a figurative toilet.

Useful infrastructure, of course, fosters and supports economic activity and growth, and thus more than pays for itself in both the short run and long run.
 
Not really, and only from the most near-term perspective possible - infrastructure is only really infrastructure if its useful in supporting economic activity. Otherwise, why not build infinity bridges to nowhere? Useless infrastructure ties up capital into fixed improvements and structures that generate no economic benefit, are illiquid and immovable, and eventually need to be replaced (the "need" being political, not practical), meaning more wasted money down the road. Useless pork infrastructure is at best a jobs/welfare program for union construction workers, and at worst just flushing money down a figurative toilet.

Useful infrastructure, of course, fosters and supports economic activity and growth, and thus more than pays for itself in both the short run and long run.
^^^Hear, Hear......well said
 
Except that rural infrastructure STILL needs improvement, guys! We're not talking about infinity Bridges to Nowhere, we're talking about improving rural roads that are not only used by citizens of the local small cities and towns, but also travelers going from one place to another, anyone who's just driving around the area...

If rural infrastructure is taken care of with the ARRA funds, it should leave states much more able to handle urban infrastructure needs. I guess I'm just saying that BOTH urban and rural infrastructure needs are important, that's all.

I know we're urbanists here, where all that matters are cities and nothing else, but you know, there are still tens of millions of people who live in rural areas, and there are tens of millions of people who used those rural roads to get from one place to another on a regular basis.

Thankfully, rebuilding rural infrastructure is cheaper than urban infrastructure in general, so the monies go further. Less time and money needed to rebuild rural infrastructure again should mean more urban infrastructure monies in the near future.

Aaron (Glowrock)
 
Thankfully, rebuilding rural infrastructure is cheaper than urban infrastructure in general, so the monies go further. Less time and money needed to rebuild rural infrastructure again should mean more urban infrastructure monies in the near future.
What standards are you basing this conclusion upon? Per capita cost? Cost to usage?? Is it based on a cost to economic benefit analysis, and if so, what parameters were used?
 
^ I brought up in another thread that indeed, some lightly-used roads in the nether regions of a road network still warrant investment for improvement, because there is value in having a complete network - this is akin to still subsidizing and operating bus routes on the reaches of a transit system because they can be an important component, when all taken together and combined with the main transit arteries to make the overall transit system attractive and useful.

But that can only go so far in justifying all the money blown on making rural roads pristine, and tearing up/widening recently-built roads in greenfield sprawl that grew beyond capacity (or at least, grew beyond capacity as defined by our national sprawl-inducing traffic engineering codes) due to poor land use planning. Investing in making the network complete would be more justifiable if our cities' heavily-used and vital intraurban arterial streets were all in great shape - but they aren't. So the funding imbalance seems driven purely by politics than anything resembling cost/benefit.
 
What do you expect when you ask the federal government to fix what they screwed up in the first place? Did we really think they would finally get something right?
 
The whole "they're spending it on the wrongs things" argument is bogus. The few of us participating right here couldn't agree on what the "right" things are. It's a foregone conclusion they won't spend it exactly as any of us or the New York Times might have wanted.

So what. They are fixing roads as well as building roads. Some of it will get to the urban transit systems we love. Some of it will keep our cops and firemen employed and our schools open.

Stop complaining. It all goes to its primary purpose--putting people to work (or keeping them at work) doing something productive.
 
The whole "they're spending it on the wrongs things" argument is bogus. The few of us participating right here couldn't agree on what the "right" things are. It's a foregone conclusion they won't spend it exactly as any of us or the New York Times might have wanted.

So what. They are fixing roads as well as building roads. Some of it will get to the urban transit systems we love. Some of it will keep our cops and firemen employed and our schools open.

Stop complaining. It all goes to its primary purpose--putting people to work (or keeping them at work) doing something productive.
I couldn't disagree more with this sentiment. Paving a road in central Illinois that creates 100 jobs for 6 months, but adds very little benefit to the overall economy is an absolute waste of money. A great example of proper use would be grade separating rail crossings in the Chicago region. It would reduce auto-traffic congestion, which leads to better productivity and improved quality of life. It would reduce transit time for freight, thus reducing costs.

Focusing on the creation of 6-12 month jobs is probably the most short sighted, irresponsible thing that could come out of this legislation.
 
I couldn't disagree more with this sentiment. Paving a road in central Illinois that creates 100 jobs for 6 months, but adds very little benefit to the overall economy is an absolute waste of money. A great example of proper use would be grade separating rail crossings in the Chicago region. It would reduce auto-traffic congestion, which leads to better productivity and improved quality of life. It would reduce transit time for freight, thus reducing costs.

Focusing on the creation of 6-12 month jobs is probably the most short sighted, irresponsible thing that could come out of this legislation.

Bingo. That money should be going into CREATE vs a repave of a rural road that will do nothing for the global economy other than six months of paying local labor to buy cheap Chinese crap from Walmart from those previously unemployed workers.
 
... It's a foregone conclusion they won't spend it exactly as any of us or the New York Times might have wanted.

So what. They are fixing roads as well as building roads. Some of it will get to the urban transit systems we love. Some of it will keep our cops and firemen employed and our schools open.

Stop complaining. It all goes to its primary purpose--putting people to work (or keeping them at work) doing something productive.

BT this reminded me of the 50 Herbert Hovers that this country is dealing with in this GOP depression. Almost every state is laying off workers, furloughing them... Basically fighting the stimulus tooth and nail all the way for most all states have to by their own constitution balance their budget. Illinois is in a tough spot no doubt because of the decrease in all tax revenues and rasing taxes in this environment only makes things worse. California being the largest state in population has the largest budget deficit of all. That will take a lot of slashing and burning to even come close to closing their deficit.

What Nobel Laureate Krugman is saying is that the states are doing the exact opposite of what the FED needs to get us out of this Bush disaster.

This is just not a state issue, cities are also doing the slash and burn at the worst time.



http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/29/opinion/29krugman.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print


December 29, 2008

Op-Ed Columnist

Fifty Herbert Hoovers

By PAUL KRUGMAN

No modern American president would repeat the fiscal mistake of 1932, in which the federal government tried to balance its budget in the face of a severe recession. The Obama administration will put deficit concerns on hold while it fights the economic crisis.

But even as Washington tries to rescue the economy, the nation will be reeling from the actions of 50 Herbert Hoovers — state governors who are slashing spending in a time of recession, often at the expense both of their most vulnerable constituents and of the nation’s economic future.

These state-level cutbacks range from small acts of cruelty to giant acts of panic — from cuts in South Carolina’s juvenile justice program, which will force young offenders out of group homes and into prison, to the decision by a committee that manages California state spending to halt all construction outlays for six months.

Now, state governors aren’t stupid (not all of them, anyway). They’re cutting back because they have to — because they’re caught in a fiscal trap.

But let’s step back for a moment and contemplate just how crazy it is, from a national point of view, to be cutting public services and public investment right now.

...

So why are we doing this to ourselves?

The answer, of course, is that state and local government revenues are plunging along with the economy — and unlike the federal government, lower-level governments can’t borrow their way through the crisis. Partly that’s because these governments, unlike the feds, are subject to balanced-budget rules. But even if they weren’t, running temporary deficits would be difficult. Investors, driven by fear, are refusing to buy anything except federal debt, and those states that can borrow at all are being forced to pay punitive interest rates.


...

And why should investments in infrastructure, which will serve the nation for decades, be at the mercy of short-run fluctuations in local budgets?

That’s for later.

The priority right now is to fight off the attack of the 50 Herbert Hoovers, and make sure that the fiscal problems of the states don’t make the economic crisis even worse.
 
typical. A great analogy would be Michigan and Detroit. the country will become like Michigan; sucked everything dry from the city to the point where there is nothing left to suck out and the city then becomes a burden but still the other money grabbing areas will not be able to swing it themselves. There is nothing left.
 
What do you expect when you ask the federal government to fix what they screwed up in the first place? Did we really think they would finally get something right?
The toxic notion that government can never ever do anything right is one of the most pervasive and pernicious shibboleths of groverites everwhere....


In America's history there are many, many instances of government intervention that have yielded very postive results.


The funny thing is that after 30 years of groverite ascendency....and the hallowing out tendencies of supply-side market fundamentalism...they (the groverites) have the temerity to say "see government screws everything up......."

NO....bad government screws things up...
 
What standards are you basing this conclusion upon? Per capita cost? Cost to usage?? Is it based on a cost to economic benefit analysis, and if so, what parameters were used?

It's cheaper in terms of ROW acquisition if needed, it's cheaper because there are less restrictions as to hours available to do the construction (ie: no peak traffic times to worry about), and it's cheaper because the overall scope of improvements is just not as great as for urban areas.

Cost-benefit analysis? Jasonhouse, you know damn well that ALL non-urban projects would fail that, save for some huge trucking corridors! :) What I'm saying, in simple terms, is that improving 10 miles of rural road is generally going to cost less than 10 miles of urban road. Less total asphalt, less pavement of any sort, less red tape due to overlapping governmental jurisdictions (in many cases, obviously not true in all cases)...

Jeez, you'd act like I was spouting some absolute vile words out of my keyboard here! All I'm saying is that rural areas shouldn't be overlooked, pure and simple.

From my 12 or so years in Colorado, the rural roads WERE completely neglected for many years, until the last couple of years, at least.

Unfortunately, there will never, ever be enough monies to fund all worthwhile road AND transit projects, both urban AND rural. While it's tempting to put all the funding for improvements where the most people live, that's not fair to those who don't live in the major urban corridors.

Aaron (Glowrock)
 
I couldn't disagree more with this sentiment. Paving a road in central Illinois that creates 100 jobs for 6 months, but adds very little benefit to the overall economy is an absolute waste of money. A great example of proper use would be grade separating rail crossings in the Chicago region. It would reduce auto-traffic congestion, which leads to better productivity and improved quality of life. It would reduce transit time for freight, thus reducing costs.

Focusing on the creation of 6-12 month jobs is probably the most short sighted, irresponsible thing that could come out of this legislation.

So, what if that road being repaved in Central Illinois is a major trucking route? :)

Of course there's politics involved in funding decisions, but it's not always as cut and dry as you seem to think, ChicagoChicago.

Aaron (Glowrock)
 
It's cheaper in terms of ROW acquisition if needed, it's cheaper because there are less restrictions as to hours available to do the construction (ie: no peak traffic times to worry about), and it's cheaper because the overall scope of improvements is just not as great as for urban areas.

Cost-benefit analysis? Jasonhouse, you know damn well that ALL non-urban projects would fail that, save for some huge trucking corridors! :) What I'm saying, in simple terms, is that improving 10 miles of rural road is generally going to cost less than 10 miles of urban road. Less total asphalt, less pavement of any sort, less red tape due to overlapping governmental jurisdictions (in many cases, obviously not true in all cases)...

Jeez, you'd act like I was spouting some absolute vile words out of my keyboard here! All I'm saying is that rural areas shouldn't be overlooked, pure and simple.

From my 12 or so years in Colorado, the rural roads WERE completely neglected for many years, until the last couple of years, at least.

Unfortunately, there will never, ever be enough monies to fund all worthwhile road AND transit projects, both urban AND rural. While it's tempting to put all the funding for improvements where the most people live, that's not fair to those who don't live in the major urban corridors.

Aaron (Glowrock)

look at this his way. I'm going to use chicago/illinois as i know the place.

Illinois loses out to many other states to the tune of 12 billion a year in federal taxes on average. Illinois only gets back 72 cents on the dollar. The major funding for the State of Illinois comes from metro Chicago. Metro Chicago loses out on funding the rest of the state. Now with the economic stimulus stuff metro chicago yet again loses out.

So Metro Chicago loses out on federal funds on average, loses out to fund the rest of the state, loses out on stimulus money, loses out on Medicare funding, most states get back 80% we get back like 50% and loses out on infrastructure bills passed by the federal governent.

Are we allowed to keep any of our money we make? What are we left with? Like half or third from the money we generate?
 


Back
Top