SMART moves down the track with cost cuts, bond preparations
By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
A major step toward construction of the Sonoma-Marin commute rail line was taken Wednesday with approval of cost-cutting measures and preparations to sell construction bonds.
At the same time, Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit directors were told the funding gap has been bridged with the promise of $21 million from local and regional transportation authorities.
Moving ahead with the first segment of the line was praised, even though it is substantially shorter than the 70-mile, Larkspur-to-Cloverdale stretch that had been planned and promised during the 2008 sales tax election.
“We are bringing Sonoma and Marin into the 21st century,” said SMART director Debora Fudge, a Windsor councilwoman. “All Bay Area cities have rail, they all have multiple freeways. We don’t. This is a far-ahead vision.”
Hard hit by a recession that has depressed revenues from the quarter-percent sales tax increase approved by voters, SMART’s initial segment will run from downtown Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael, with a planned opening in 2014.
Several objections were raised at the SMART meeting by some Sonoma and Marin residents, who said the truncated line was not what they voted for, is underfunded and should be brought before voters again.
“To press on with this flies in the face of wisdom,” said Clay Mitchell of Windsor.
“What I voted for is not what I am seeing,” said Doug Brown of Santa Rosa.
Cynthia Murray, president of the North Bay Leadership Council, a business group, defended the SMART project.
“I think the voters spoke very loudly, it passed by over 70 percent,” Murray said. “This project has not been changed, it is only being staged.”
The estimated cost to build and operate the commute line from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael over the next 13 years is estimated to be $470 million. That amount is $109 million more than SMART expects to have from sales taxes, local, state and federal funds.
To narrow that gap, directors unanimously approved measures that could save the district $88.2 million. They include postponing stations at Corona Road in Petaluma and Atherton Road in Novato, buying 12 rather than 18 trains, cutting a third of the budget for a bicycle and pedestrian path, rebuilding rather than replacing the bridge over the Petaluma River and building a smaller maintenance facility and perhaps moving it to Petaluma.
“The hope is that our financial plan is conservative enough that we can reinstate some of these cuts in the near future,” said David Heath, interim general manager.
Directors also unanimously approved the preparation of documents to sell construction bonds, which are estimated to bring in from $150 million to $160 million.
Heath said construction bids should be back by July, along with information from the bond counsel on how much the district can raise, at which time SMART directors may authorize selling bonds.
A final piece of the financial puzzle was a promise by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission to provide $10 million in funding, with a $10 million match from the Sonoma County Transportation Authority and the Transportation Authority of Marin.
http://www.sonomamarintrain.org/userfiles/file/Press Release - NWP locomotive training v_2.pdfLocomotive Training to Begin on SMART's Eastern Rail Extension
For Immediate Release: April 13, 2011
Contact: Chris Coursey, 707-521-0716
The return of freight rail service to the North Bay moved a step closer to reality this week when the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit District approved a limited plan for the Northwestern Pacific Railroad Co. (NWPCo.) to provide training to locomotive crews on SMART's rail corridor in southeastern Sonoma County.
...
NWPCo. is training its crews in anticipation of the start-up of freight rail service that will operate between American Canyon in southern Napa County and Windsor in Sonoma County. NWPCo. is a private freight railroad operator under contract with the North Coast Railroad Authority (NCRA), a public agency that owns an easement for freight service along the SMART-owned rail corridor.
Training will take place on the least-populated branch of the SMART-owned right of way, near Port Sonoma, Sears Point, Schellville and in the Carneros region of southeastern Sonoma County and southwestern Napa County. SMART's passenger trains, scheduled to begin service in 2014, will not operate on this branch, but it provides a critical link for freight trains to connect with the national rail system near American Canyon.
SMART has agreed to allow the training operations, but NCRA still needs to reach an operating agreement with SMART before freight service begins. The two agencies have been negotiating for many months on terms of the agreement, which spells out how the two rail operations will co-exist in the corridor. Most issues have been settles, but a few remain before the agreement can be signed.
While SMART's primary focus is to get commuter trains running by 2014, the agency also has been working for several years to make sure the re-establishment of freight rail in the North Bay is safe, efficient and compatible with the return of passenger rail service. This has been done in accordance with SMART's enabling legislation, Assembly Bill 2224, which requires passenger and freight trains to "operate in harmony."
....
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110422/ARTICLES/110429770/1350?p=1&tc=pg#Low bids stretch the work along Hwy. 101
![]()
CHRISTOPHER CHUNG/PRESS DEMOCRAT FILE PHOTO
Construction crews, pictured here widening Highway 101 in June in Cotati, are working from bids won after coming in under expectations.
By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
Published: Friday, April 22, 2011 at 2:06 p.m.
Last Modified: Friday, April 22, 2011 at 2:21 p.m.
( page 1 of 3 )
The low bid for the latest Highway 101 widening project is more than a third under engineers' estimates, a recession-era trend that will save Sonoma County $56 million in anticipated costs for work from Windsor to Petaluma.
“You have a lot of contractors who are trying to get the limited amount of work there is out there, and they are sharpening their pencils to a degree that we have not seen before,” said Suzanne Smith, executive director of the Sonoma County Transportation Authority.
It is a bidding environment that is being closely watched by the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit District, which is about to go out to bid on $314 million of work for an initial commute line from Santa Rosa to San Rafael.
“I am speculating that there are people who want the work, are knowledgeable of what we want and what our budget is,” said Sonoma County Supervisor Valerie Brown, chairwoman of the SMART board. “I assume the bidding will be very competitive and it would not surprise me a bit if it came in under.”
The latest bids for freeway work were opened Tuesday, with Ghilotti Construction of Santa Rosa the low bidder at $10.6 million to widen Highway 101 from Pepper Road to Old Redwood Highway in Petaluma, about 36 percent below the engineer's estimate of $17 million.
Ghilotti was also the low bidder on work now under way on an adjacent project to widen the freeway from Rohnert Park Expressway to Pepper Road, at $48.8 million, which was $28.8 million below estimates.
Two previous projects to widen the freeway from Santa Rosa to Windsor and from Santa Rosa to the Rohnert Park Expressway were also under budget. The work was estimated to cost $139.7 million, but came in at $105.7 million.
...
SMART hopes to see savings when it goes out to bid within the next few weeks, but given the specialized nature of rail work, the question is how much.
The rail project includes reconstruction of 37 miles of track from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael and building seven stations, a maintenance facility and a pedestrian-bike path. The work is budgeted for $314 million.
Nine contractors, with assembled groups of consultants and subcontractors, have been pre-qualified by SMART for the work.
“It really is a crap shoot,” said consultant Dave Anderson of American Rail, who has overseen rail work on the line for the North Coast Railroad Authority and is also involved in companies that may be bidding on the SMART work.
“I know a couple of the design-build teams are very hungry, which is good, it may help SMART, but this is specialized work.”
In Sacramento, a $41 million contract was awarded two weeks ago to move rail lines and build platforms and three tunnels at The Railyards, a housing, retail and museum project. It was $3 million under budget, but only after the project was redesigned when bids came in $12 million over budget.
“Rail is absolutely different,” said Fran Halbakken, Sacramento's transportation operations manager.
http://www.watchsonomacounty.com/2011/04/cities/rohnert-park-considers-new-site-for-smart-station/Rohnert Park considers new site for SMART station
April 24th, 2011
By JEREMY HAY
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
Rohnert Park officials want the City Council to approve a new location for a planned train station projected to be built in 2014.
The change, said Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit officials, also might benefit the overall commuter train project by allowing it to plan for construction of a Novato station delayed by budget constraints.
The new proposed site of the SMART station would be off Rohnert Park Expressway at State Farm Drive. Currently, the site is planned for Roberts Lake Road at Highway 101.
There are distinct differences between the two, but the proposed alternative probably would not attract more train passengers, said SMART spokesman Chris Coursey.
Still, city Development Services Director Darrin Jenkins said, a recent SMART study outlined advantages to the Rohnert Park Expressway site.
Chiefly, the SMART study, which the city requested, found the location was nearer to more housing and would offer easier pedestrian access.
The study examined two variations of the Rohnert Park Expressway site. Both are more expensive than the Roberts Lake Road site, which is projected to cost $2.2 million.
The first variation would offer vehicle access only from State Farm Drive. That would cost at least $2.7 million, the study said. The second would require the construction of an additional access route from Seed Farm Drive. It would cost $3.1 million.
It’s unclear who would pay the extra costs. SMART does not have the money, Coursey said.
“We’re hoping that the city would … contribute to the additional costs that this brings up,” he said.
But Rohnert Park, after slashing costs for three years, still faces a $1 million deficit that officials are trying to trim.
Vice Mayor Jake Mackenzie said the new proposal is better for SMART and the city because it is next to property that State Farm Insurance plans to vacate by July.
That location, Mackenzie said, affords the opportunity “for public-private (funding) partnerships” because it could spur the development of mixed use projects on the 33-acre site.
That would have added benefits for a city that has no real center, he said.
“Hopefully the development of that property would result in finally establishing where downtown Rohnert Park really is,” said Mackenzie, who is on the SMART Board of Directors.
And for SMART, he said, putting a station in an area where there is a higher housing density could qualify the rail agency for more regional transportation funds.
That might benefit the whole rail project, he said, allowing it to proceed with the Novato station, which along with a Petaluma station, SMART decided last week to postpone as a cost-cutting measure.
....
You can reach Staff Writer Jeremy Hay at 521-5212 or [email protected].
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110508/ARTICLES/110509514/1350?p=1&tc=pgSonoma wants Marin to dig deeper for SMART
By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
Published: Sunday, May 8, 2011 at 8:07 p.m.
Last Modified: Sunday, May 8, 2011 at 8:07 p.m.
( page 1 of 2 )
Sonoma County transportation officials want Marin County to dig deeper in a regional effort to help the Sonoma-Marin commute rail project bridge a $21 million funding gap.
“We do feel that we have participated and have not seen a full equity arrangement ... Marin has got to do some fair-share stuff,” said Sonoma County Supervisor Valerie Brown, who also chairs the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit district.
After taking $88 million in cost-cutting measures, SMART estimates there is still a $21 million gap between its budget for first-phase construction and projected revenues from the sale of construction bonds and local, state and federal funds.
The Sonoma County Transportation Authority and the Transportation Authority of Marin are working with the Metropolitan Transportation Commission to help fill the hole.
However, Sonoma County’s transportation authority already gives SMART $11 million from proceeds of the Measure M quarter-cent sales tax measure and Sonoma County is taking the brunt of SMART’s cutbacks.
“We don’t have money to give. We have given all the Measure M (funds) we could,” said Suzanne Smith, the transportation authority’s executive director.
Jake Mackenzie, a Rohnert Park councilman and chairman of the Sonoma County Transportation Authority, said he wants to form a committee to explore using authority funds for SMART.
Steve Kinsey, a Marin County supervisor and chairman of the Transportation Authority of Marin, said the Marin authority discussed the issue Thursday.
....
SMART isn't going to help traffic congestion as much as you suggest.
...
Sort of makes that 390 passengers per hour per direction capacity look very small.
If you're going to do the math, 390/2000 is 19.5%. Removing almost 20% of the traffic is definitely going to help, especially since SMART is planning to add more trains and service as they grow.
If you're going to do the math, 390/2000 is 19.5%. Removing almost 20% of the traffic is definitely going to help, especially since SMART is planning to add more trains and service as they grow.
That was 2,000 vehicles per lane. That 19.5% becomes 9.75% on a freeway with 2 lanes in each direction and 6.5% on a freeway with 3 lanes in each direction. Those percentages fall further if you consider that there might be two, three, or four passengers in each vehicle.
when the freight line opens that will be taking a lot of trucks off the freeway. one rail car = four trucks. the rail line may not carry as much as a freeway lane but nearly every person that takes the train will be one less car - taking thousands of cars off the 101 WILL REDUCE CONGESTION.
Amen. That's what I really hope will happen for the SMART train as a whole. It will be very helpful to see the trains running once more because it will give residents and businesses a new alternative to driving solo to work, school, or anywhere else.
http://www.watchsonomacounty.com/20...-novato-strike-deal-to-resume-freight-trains/NCRA, Novato strike deal to resume freight trains
May 19th, 2011
By STEVE HART
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
North Coast Railroad Authority and the city of Novato have reached a tentative deal on the return of freight service in Sonoma, Marin and Napa counties.
...
Novato sued the rail authority in 2007 to halt the project, charging it failed to consider environmental impacts of train traffic in the city.
The two sides reached a settlement the following year. The $1.5 million deal called for “quiet zones” at rail crossings in the city, use of low-emission locomotives and other provisions. NCRA also agreed to pay Novato’s legal costs.
But NCRA last year asked for some changes in the agreement, and the two sides have been negotiating ever since.
“It appears to be a done deal,” said Mitch Stogner, NCRA’s executive director.
Novato attorney Jeff Walter didn’t return a call seeking comment. But in a May 17 email to the authority, he said Novato has tentatively agreed to the changes.
They still must be approved by NCRA’s board, the Novato City Council and a Marin County judge.
On Monday, NCRA notified Novato that it plans to start freight service “on or about June 16, 2011.”
....
[northbay] Ooh so that means I'll see the railroad crossing arms go up and down again throughout Novato soon? That will be great since it will mean the line will almost be ready for passenger rail. But, here's the kicker: how many train cars will pass by the city, especially near Hamilton where the junction for Sonoma and Napa Counties is close by in Ignacio? Plus, how longer will those freight cars affect traffic at many roads in the city, especially close to business centers?