SMART discussions


I'm almost afraid to click on this thread anymore. It seems most new posts involve disappointing news.

Here is some more good news for you...;)

Sonoma-Marin rail agency ponders cuts

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Thursday, March 17, 2011 at 3:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Thursday, March 17, 2011 at 7:38 a.m.

The Sonoma-Marin rail agency on Tuesday reviewed a list of cost-cutting measures ranging from deferring train stations to trimming a bicycle-pedestrian path as it struggles to build a commuter line.

The list of cutbacks, totaling $106 million, are meant to close the funding gap between what the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit can afford and what it hopes to build.

“There is enough pain here for everybody,” said Charles McGlashan, a Marin County supervisor and SMART's vice chairman. “This project is still worth doing, we have to start service in 2014, we need to get people out of their cars.”

SMART predicts that it will cost $470 million to build and operate a line from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael.

However, with sales tax revenues depressed by the recession, SMART estimates it will only be able to raise $161 million by selling bonds. Together with $206 million in avilable state and federal funds, that leaves a $104 million gap, said David Heath, SMART's interim general manager.

In a worst-case scenario, if sales taxes are depressed more than expected or ridership doesn't meet expectations, the gap could be $140 million, according to consultant Sarah Hollenbeck of Public Financial Management of San Francisco.

The cost-cutting measures could save $88 million. They include reducing the pedestrian-bike path, deferring stations at Corona Road in Petaluma and Atherton Drive in Novato, building a bare-bones maintenance facility, reducing the number of train cars the agency purchases and rebuilding rather than replacing the Petaluma River bridge.

Even with those cuts, Heath said SMART would have to rely on finding $16 million in help from the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, Transit Authority of Marin or the Sonoma County Transportation Authority.

Heath also listed some cuts that he said are not under consideration, including delaying service until 2015, saving $15 million, and eliminating shuttle service, saving $7 million.

The board will meet April 6 to consider issuing bonds and review the cost-cutting measures.

During the three-hour workshop, pleas were made to forestall some of the cuts.

More than a dozen people argued that the pedestrian-bike path was significant in getting voter approval in 2008 in the two counties for a quarter-cent sales tax increase to pay for the transit plan, and will help drive ridership.

A vice president for Fireman's Fund Insurance in Novato also urged the board to keep the Atherton station because it would serve 300 of the company's Sonoma County employees who live alongside the rail line.

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110317/ARTICLES/110319582/1350?Title=SMART-rail-board-considers-cuts
 
^And in how many phases, and what gets built in which phase. I'm an avid biker and can't wait for the bike path. But if delaying that a bit means rail service gets started sooner, I'm all for it. We can fill-in the missing path segments over time.
 
^And in how many phases, and what gets built in which phase. I'm an avid biker and can't wait for the bike path. But if delaying that a bit means rail service gets started sooner, I'm all for it. We can fill-in the missing path segments over time.

According to Systemic Failure, you should be thinking the opposite:

‘SMART’ is now $350 million under-funded (shock news). As a result, the MTC has proposed to “down-size” a $70 million bike path that had also been promised to voters.

Besides the obvious inequity, shifting funds from bikes to trains is fiscally nonsensical. Bike paths require no operating subsidy, and are inexpensive to build. According to the FTA cost-per-new-rider metric, the bike path will be orders-of-magnitude more effective for reducing car trips. Trains might be more sexy than bike paths, but this scheme would cannibalize the most cost-effective portion of the project.

Although the blog of pseudonymous, I’ve generally found the author knowledgeable and I’ve heard the same from someone at CDOT as well.
 
Interesting. I get the maintenance and operating cost advantage to the bike lane, and can see how in a cost-per-rider standpoint it's more economical. But I just don't see a lot of people riding from Santa Rosa to San Rafael, while I can see lots of folks moving to the train for that trip. Cost per rider aside, the train will take a lot more cars off 101. Sure it will cost more, but it's a much longer trip than can be expected for commuting on a bike. For the shorter trips, some of the bike lane will still be built in the first phases. In fact, stretches of it have already been built between the Civic Center in San Rafael and Larkspur.

Reading the rest of that blog though, I totally agree that funding highway expansion at the expense of the train is crazy. But that's US transportation funding for you. Highways always get the money, while transit goes begging.
 
Interesting. I get the maintenance and operating cost advantage to the bike lane, and can see how in a cost-per-rider standpoint it's more economical. But I just don't see a lot of people riding from Santa Rosa to San Rafael, while I can see lots of folks moving to the train for that trip. Cost per rider aside, the train will take a lot more cars off 101. Sure it will cost more, but it's a much longer trip than can be expected for commuting on a bike. For the shorter trips, some of the bike lane will still be built in the first phases. In fact, stretches of it have already been built between the Civic Center in San Rafael and Larkspur.

Reading the rest of that blog though, I totally agree that funding highway expansion at the expense of the train is crazy. But that's US transportation funding for you. Highways always get the money, while transit goes begging.

totally agree. this problem is hardly unique to sonoma/marin. fact is, the freeway should've expanded decades ago - there will still be congestion on the completed sections - the train is considered sonoma county's "fourth lane" and is actually the reason the freeway isn't being expanded further.

the bike lanes will mostly be used for recreational purposes, while the train for commuting. i think serving the commuters first is the right thing to do.

and where did he get $350 million? currently smart anticipates a shortfall of 104-140 million, less than half what he states (http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110317/ARTICLES/110319582).

i'm not impressed with this guy
 
It’s a pretty old post, from December 2010—the $350 million comes from this Press-Democrat article, which was also published in december.

I’m not familiar with Sonoma-Marin’s travel patterns, so maybe peak-period congestion is the main problem and needs a piece of heavy infrastructure with lots of peak-period capacity to solve it, but I wouldn’t say that bike commuting will only be recreational. The only experience I have with bike infrastructure is in Milwaukee and Chicago, but there even if the infrastructure is recreational in character—along the lakefront or old railway corridors—you’ll still find people using it to commute, to get to school, or just to get somewhere in general, rather than just biking-for-biking’s sake.
 
It’s a pretty old post, from December 2010—the $350 million comes from this Press-Democrat article, which was also published in december.

I’m not familiar with Sonoma-Marin’s travel patterns, so maybe peak-period congestion is the main problem and needs a piece of heavy infrastructure with lots of peak-period capacity to solve it, but I wouldn’t say that bike commuting will only be recreational. The only experience I have with bike infrastructure is in Milwaukee and Chicago, but there even if the infrastructure is recreational in character—along the lakefront or old railway corridors—you’ll still find people using it to commute, to get to school, or just to get somewhere in general, rather than just biking-for-biking’s sake.

that's exactly what we need, and what the train will provide. i'm not arguing that the bike lane won't be 'useful' - just which should be the priority. i still think the bike lane should be built - but with limited dollars one or the other has to come first, and the train will take cars off 101, the bike lane probably won't.
 
:previous: Exactly. The bike lane will be great, but put it off so that the rail can be built. They say the bike lane is cheap, but it was last estimated at $42 million. That doesn't seem cheap to me. I can see people commuting from Windsor, Rohnert Park and maybe Petaluma to Santa Rosa, but nobody is going to go much further than that to commute to work.
 
:previous: Exactly. The bike lane will be great, but put it off so that the rail can be built. They say the bike lane is cheap, but it was last estimated at $42 million. That doesn't seem cheap to me. I can see people commuting from Windsor, Rohnert Park and maybe Petaluma to Santa Rosa, but nobody is going to go much further than that to commute to work.

I don't think SMART should completely abandon the adjacent trail. I do think building the entire trail isn't affordable just as the entire rail system isn't. A shorter trail is the immediate answer. The question to be answered politically is where and how much can they afford to build? An easy answer which I believe is wrong, is to build the trail where the trains aren't.

I would think pedestrians would walk further than a 1/4 mile from a train station if there were a nice wide path. I also think there's a limit based upon distance for most bike riders too. Let's assume between two to five miles. What I suggest, since there will not be two train stations in the cities initially, that they build trails completely through a city, but not between cities initially. In this way, the trail is accessible to the most users, in the more dense neighborhoods.

Bikers who might be in shape to ride the entire length of the corridor have the ability to do so on existing streets. Eventually, SMART could connect the cities together by trails as they also extend the trains.
 
Petaluma deals with SMART’s budget proposals

By PHILIP RILEY,
ARGUS-COURIER STAFF

Published: Friday, March 25, 2011 at 12:00 p.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, March 23, 2011 at 4:19 p.m.

While budget woes have raised plenty of questions about the feasibility and schedule for the Sonoma Marin Area Rail Transit line in recent months, even more controversy has emerged surrounding what proposed budget cuts could mean for Petaluma.

SMART officials last year proposed saving money by deferring station stops at Corona Road in Petaluma and another station in north Novato. While that decision is yet to be made, it is considered likely give the $106 million in cuts that SMART officials plan to make to ensure the line will open on time.

The entire SMART line, which spans 70 miles from Larkspur to Windsor, was originally set to open in 2014 and cost $590 million. Late last year, SMART’s board of directors voted to delay the Larkspur and Windsor legs of the line until 2016 or 2018, shortening the line to run between Santa Rosa and San Rafael at a cost of $470 million. But with the recession dealing sales tax revenues a blow, a $104 million budget gap still exists for the project as it stands now.

As a result, SMART officials have created a list of cost-saving measures — deferring bike trails, limiting station amenities, and more — with delaying the Corona station as a prominent opportunity to save about $11 million. That would leave one other station in Petaluma, near the Petaluma Arts Center and the Copeland street bus depot downtown.

“Our board is going to take another look at the contingency list,” said SMART spokesperson Chris Coursey, adding that while delaying the Corona station is a serious proposal, the decision won’t come for awhile.

But another cost-cutting possibility stirred even more controversy last week. At a meeting in San Rafael, Petaluma officials learned that SMART had briefly considered putting a maintenance yard on land next to the downtown station. SMART owns the plot of land on Copeland Street, bounded by East Washington Street, East D Street, and Lakeville Highway. SMART officials have been working on a transit-oriented development plan for the land with the city to build multi-story housing and shops. But many feared that a maintenance yard in central Petaluma would throw a wrench in those plans for development.

“That land in Petaluma absolutely needs to be developed to its best and full use,” said Mayor David Glass, who along with Council members Tiffany Renée, Teresa Barrett and former mayor Pam Torliatt, traveled to a SMART meeting in San Rafael last week to convey their concerns.

“It’s everything the rail is about,” Glass said about the transit-oriented development planned at the site. “You don’t simply break up the very heart of that.”

However, SMART officials say that the idea for the maintenance yard downtown “never got off the ground” and was not a serious or formal proposal.

SMART spokesman Chris Coursey said that relocation of the maintenance yard was made necessary after endangered tiger salamander were found on its original site near Todd Road in Santa Rosa. SMART considered all of the land they own for the maintenance yard, which could cost at much at $60 million, but acknowledged that building in Petaluma would do too much harm to planned development.

“This has never been suggested to our board as a solution,” said Coursey, who added that the idea was “discussed internally” before it was shot down.

“We talked to Mayor Glass. He felt the same way we did,” he said.

At the meeting last week, Torliatt suggested several other sites in Petaluma for the maintenance yard, saying it could provide local jobs.

“We are looking at other parcels we may need to buy rather than those that we own,” said Coursey. The site of the city’s former water treatment plant on Hopper Street has been suggested.

Coursey added that many decisions have yet to be made, but said that the design of the downtown station could change if the Corona station is delayed. The downtown station plan does not currently include parking, as much of the parking was planned at the more residential Corona area. That may have to change and parking may be considered at the downtown station if the Corona station is delayed, he said.

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110325/COMMUNITY/110329788
 
SMART rail officials face tough cuts
Novato, Petaluma stations, bike trail funding among list of options

By CATHY BUSSEWITZ
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Wednesday, April 6, 2011 at 3:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, April 6, 2011 at 10:36 p.m.

Elected officials are trying to save two proposed commuter stations in Petaluma and Novato that could be cut from the SMART train plan because of funding shortfalls.

Not opening the two stations, one at Corona Road in northern Petaluma and the other at Atherton Drive in Novato, could save an estimated $16.8 million.

That unpopular option was discussed Wednesday by the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit board as it reviewed ways to cut $88 million from the rail line, which is scheduled to open in 2014 between downtown Santa Rosa and San Rafael.

Money is available for downtown stations in both Petaluma and Novato, but the cities also are pressing for construction of the second stations that were promised when Sonoma and Marin county voters approved the rail plan and a sales tax increase in 2008.

Petaluma Councilwoman Tiffany Renee said the Corona Road station would be a hub for 14,000 potential jobs and a regional link for Santa Rosa Junior College students.

“When you take out a station like Petaluma, you're actually decreasing ridership in other stations,” Renee said after the meeting. “I think Petaluma could assist SMART in helping to purchase that land. I think the council should look at it before the opportunity sunsets.”

Another appeal came from Carole Dillon-Knutson, a SMART board member who serves on the Novato City Council. “I hope that you take another look at that site,” she said. “Otherwise, Novato people will feel when the train goes by them that they were left out of the SMART process.”

The board also considered cutting one-third of the budget of the proposed bicycle path, to save $14 million...

full article: http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110406/ARTICLES/110409616/1350?Title=SMART-rail-officials-face-tough-cuts
 
I think it's a mistake to not build the park & ride stations initially in every city. It was okay to have stations serving mostly pedestrians when they were building two stations per city, but not when they will be building just one station per city.

I don't think many realize just how expensive an extra station is, especially when considering most of the cities were planning on having two, and some three. Those extra stations drive up the construction cost significantly, $10 to $20 million each. They also drive ridership up by getting the trains and its passengers closer to their final designations. It's possible to save $100 million in construction costs just by not building 5 to 10 stations along the entire corridor.

But that's the price one has to pay when the budget to build what you want isn't complete. SMART needs to build what its budget allows, then add onto that later when the budget allows more. I still think they should be seeking Federal funds, if they could get a 50% match, all their budget problems fade away.
 
i never understood why they weren't more aggressive in getting federal funding (although i think they did apply for tiger II, and didn't get any $).

as for the petaluma/novato stations, i really would hate to see them not be built in the initial phase. but if that's what has to happen so the line opens by 2014, so be it. as long as they commit to ultimately building the stations at a later date and not completely drop plans for them. it's really about priorities. i don't think anyone is arguing the value of these stations. like electricron said, there just isn't enough money in round 1 so they got save anyway they can.

grr, if only the 'complainers' read this forum!
 
There are plenty of Federal funds available that can be used. FTA "New Starts" funds are hard to qualify for, maybe the SMART train wouldn't compete well. But there are other Federal funds they could qualify for; upgrading railroad structures like bridges and building the bike trail; both of which make up a significant share of the proposed budget. Every Federal penny they can get is one less penny they have to raise locally.
 
Some more additional facts about those two potential deferred stations.
http://www.sonomamarintrain.org/userfiles/file/Special Board Meeting 4-6-11.pdf
The Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) adopted a Transit Oriented
Development (TOD) Policy on July 27, 2005. For commuter rail services (like SMART), the policy requires an average of 2,200 units within a half mile radius of stations along the operating segment. This average is calculated by adding up the units within a half mile of each station along the entire operating corridor, and dividing that total number of units by the number of stations planned for inclusion in the operating segment. The policy states that no regional funds will be programmed and allocated for construction of transit extensions until the requirements of this policy have been satisfied.

Back in 2004, the MTC included SMART in their future budget with $35 Million. To date SMART has received $13 Million for the construction of Cal Park Hill Tunnel, leaving $22 Million available for SMART. But to get that $22 Million, they have to meet the MTC TOD policy. SMART staff has analyzed the various scenarios suggested by MTC as part of their December presentation and concurs that the “Scenario 2”, “initial segment extended to Downtown San Rafael with the deferral of two stations (Petaluma – Corona Road and Novato North/Atherton) is most advantageous from the TOD policy perspective”. In other words, the downtown San Rafael to downtown Santa Rosa doesn't have enough housing units within a half mile of the tracks to meet the requirements for the remaining $22 Million, and that two stations must be eliminated. So not only will SMART save $16.8 Million not building these stations, they also qualify for the additional $22 Million. That's a total of $38.8 Million saved on SMART's bottom line.

Additionally, to build those two stations and still meet the MTC TOD requirements, all SMART would have to do is extend the corridor north to the north Santa Rosa station. But that means finding the money to build three new stations, which of course at $45.8 Million is more than the $22 Million coming from the MTC.

Statistics from http://www.sonomamarintrain.org/userfiles/file/Board 2011-04-06 Presentation (KS)CC.pdf

To Santa Rosa North/Guerneville Station (Total Cost Estimate $29m)
•ROW - $8.4 million
•Station - $2.6 million
•Track - $11 million
•MUP - $1 million
•Additional Trainset - $6 million

Defer Corona Road Station $11.5 million
Defer Atherton Station $5.3 million
Defer Fare Collection Ticket Vending Machine $4.3 million
Defer Fiber Optic Communication System $4.5 million
Defer Closed Circuit Television on Platforms $3.4 million
Defer replacement of Novato Creek Bridge $5 million
Defer replacement and rehabilitate Haystack Bridge $15 million
Reduced Land Acquisition at O&M Facility (OMF) $7 million
Maximum Reduction in O&M Facilities $15 million
Multi Use Path (MUP) – build 1/3rd - $14 million
Multi Use Path (MUP) – cut all - $42 million

Getting that $22 Million grant from the MTC could save lots of other cuts.
 
SMART ready to finalize cuts, approve bond sale

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Monday, April 18, 2011 at 12:32 p.m.
Last Modified: Monday, April 18, 2011 at 12:54 p.m.

Postponing construction of stations in Petaluma and Novato is among the $88 million in cost saving measures the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit is expected to approve Wednesday as it moves forward with an initial line to open in 2014.

The SMART board also is expected to approve the sale of construction bonds, which are estimated to raise $161 million.

Even with the cuts, however, there is potentially a gap of $21 million between SMART funds and the cost of building and operating the line over the next two decades.

“There are discussions going on with other transit agencies, with the Metropolitan Transportation Agency, Transportation Authority of Marin and Sonoma County Transit Authority,” said SMART spokesman Chris Coursey of the search for additional funding.

“And all of this is projection and estimate, there are those who believe that if we can get these construction contracts out right away, the construction market will give us savings also,” Coursey said.

Hard hit by a recession that has depressed sales tax revenue from the 2008 quarter-cent sales tax election, SMART is planning an initial line running from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael.

SMART could save $16.8 million by deferring the construction of stations at Corona Road in Petaluma and Atherton in Novato.

At the same time, because there is little existing or planned housing surrounding those two stations, SMART's line would meet MTC's housing density guideline and qualify for $22 million in regional funding.

Other cost-cutting items include cutting the funding for the pedestrian-bicycle path by a third, building a smaller operations and maintenance facility and possibly moving it from Santa Rosa to Petaluma, rebuilding rather than replacing the bridge over the Petaluma River and buying 12 trains instead of 18.

The meeting is at 1:30 p.m. Wednesday at the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors chambers.

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110418/ARTICLES/110419474/1350?Title=SMART-ready-to-finalize-cuts
 
Just wanted to add this observation to this discussion.

That SMART wasn't aware of the MTC's (TOD) provisions as much as they should have been. It seems to have caught both the SMART board and their consultants by surprise. A surprise that shouldn't have happen.

If they had been aware of it sooner, maybe they would have limited the proposed station locations to locales acceptable for the MTC's (TOD) provisions so they wouldn't have to make these late station cuts to qualify for the last $22 Million promised.

The SMART Board was placed in an unnecessary un-winnable position no board should ever be placed. They have lots of hard political decisions to make, giving them additional ones probably did not go well with the Board. I wouldn't be surprised if the SMART Board hire new consultants at the very next opportunity.
 


Back
Top