SMART discussions


Santa Rosa to spend $500,000 on SMART rail station plan

By KEVIN McCALLUM
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Santa Rosa is spending $500,000 of mostly grant money to develop plans for the area around the proposed Guerneville Road train station.

The goal is to direct growth toward development and public facilities that will support use of the commuter train envisioned by the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit agency.

Like the plan already prepared by the city for the area around the proposed train station in Railroad Square, the study will identify locations for transit-oriented projects, connections to the station for bicyclists, pedestrians and bus riders, and development of attractive streets and public spaces.

Most of the money, $400,000, will come from a Metropolitan Transportation Commission grant. The city’s redevelopment agency is providing $70,000, $20,000 comes from the city’s general fund and $10,000 is provided by SMART.

Facing a $350 million shortfall in money needed to build the entire 70-mile line from Larkspur to Cloverdale, SMART’s board opted in November to build the rail line in stages. The first segment, from Railroad Square to downtown San Rafael, is estimated to cost $395 million.

If bids come in low enough, SMART planners hope they will be able to start the line in 2014 at Guerneville Road, an extension estimated to cost an additional $27 million.

http://www.watchsonomacounty.com/2011/01/transportation/santa-rosa-to-spend-500000-on-smart-rail-station-plan/
 
SMART stays on track by soliciting bids

Published: Wednesday, January 19, 2011 at 6:13 p.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, January 19, 2011 at 6:13 p.m.

The Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit board on Wednesday took its first step toward construction of a commute line, approving the preparation of construction packages and the solicitation of bids.

If all goes as planned, project manager John Lackey said that track bed reconstruction could be under way by the end of this year.

SMART estimates that it will cost $395 million to construct the line from Railroad Square to the Civic Center in San Rafael and another $39 million to extend it to downtown San Rafael.

...

Lackey said the construction packages will have options to extend to Coddingtown, $27 million, and to Windsor, $40 million, depending on how bids come in and whether other savings can be found.

The board also authorized the use of concrete ties instead of wood, which have a longer life and can cost 10 to 15 percent less than wood ties.

....

— Bob Norberg

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/articl...Title=SMART-stays-on-track-by-soliciting-bids
 
sfcityscape recently added an updated map of smart's route based on the new two phases.

here is a reminder of what the new trains will look like:

smartdesign.jpg


and here is the map, courtesy sfcityscape: http://www.sfcityscape.com/
for a large pdf of the image, click here: http://www.sfcityscape.com/maps/bay_area_transit/SMART.pdf

smartmap.jpg
 
SMART's boss steps down

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Friday, January 21, 2011 at 2:44 p.m.
Last Modified: Friday, January 21, 2011 at 2:44 p.m.

( page 1 of 3 )

Lillian Hames, the general manager of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit District since its inception a decade ago, stepped down on Friday.

Her resignation came amid deepening controversy over the length of the line, which had been promised to voters as a 70-mile commute railroad from Cloverdale to Larkspur. But it has been shortened because of dwindling sales tax revenues and a more difficult bond market.

Extra criticism came from Marin County when an initial plan failed to bring the line to the transit hub in downtown San Rafael.

As a result, some board members said Hames had lost their support and that it was time for new leadership in getting the rail line built. The board met last Wednesday in closed session to review her performance.

Hames, who previously had helped bring Portland's commute line into operation and was also a Bay Area transit consultant, informed the board of her decision Friday. She could not be reached for comment.

In a statement released by SMART, Hames said she was leaving to pursue new opportunities.

Valerie Brown, SMART's new chairwoman, stressed that it was Hames' decision to step down and that she was not forced out by the board.

“It was really her choice,” Brown said.

Brown praised Hames for leading SMART to where it is today, having purchased rail cars and positioned the agency to issue bonds and begin construction.

“In the 10 years she was here, she carried us through some incredible times, the authorization of Measure Q, the purchase of rail cars. She has put together an organization that can move forward in her absence,” Brown said.

....

source:http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110121/ARTICLES/110129872/1350?p=1&tc=pg
 
SMART may reorganize operations

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Wednesday, February 2, 2011 at 5:29 p.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, February 2, 2011 at 5:29 p.m.

( page 1 of 2 )

Directors of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit district on Wednesday began discussing how to replace the agency’s general manager, who stepped down Jan. 21.

The process may go beyond just hiring someone to replace Lillian Hames, who led SMART for a decade through the formation of the district, passage of the tax measure, selection of the trains and an initial construction plan.

Charles McGlashan, SMART vice chairman and a Marin County supervisor, said the board needs to take time to consider how to move forward and whether to reorganize it operations.

...

The district a week ago conducted a symposium for contractors that drew 200 participants, and on Friday will ask contractors to apply to be qualified to submit bids.

“I think Lillian has put us in great position; we have operations moving in a very solid place,” said Valerie Brown, SMART chairwoman and a Sonoma County supervisor.

Brown also said that the board will take a more hands-on approach to running SMART.

The board’s executive committee met in closed session Wednesday, ostensibly to begin discussing hiring a new general manager.

Brown said later the topic qualified under state law for a closed hearing because it was a personnel issue dealing with a new general manager and the current SMART staff....
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/articl...le=SMART-board-begins-leadership-discussions-


SMART to hold workshops on station designs

By LORI A. CARTER
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Friday, February 4, 2011 at 3:28 p.m.
Last Modified: Friday, February 4, 2011 at 3:28 p.m.

The Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit district will hold another round of community workshops this month to receive public input on the design of stations along the planned passenger rail line.

SMART staff members and design consultants will present information about the progress of the project in general and the design of individual stations and station components.

The workshops will focus on stations within the planned first segment of the project, from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael. That segment is scheduled to begin passenger train service in late 2014.

...

The first community workshop will be part of the district board meeting, at 1:30 p.m. Feb. 16 in the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors chambers in Santa Rosa.

Additional meetings are:

Feb. 16: Cotati community room, Cotati and Rohnert Park stations

Feb. 17: Novato council chambers, Hamilton and Atherton stations

Feb. 22: Santa Rosa City Hall, Railroad Square station

Feb. 23: Petaluma Community Center, downtown Petaluma and Corona Road stations

Feb. 24: San Rafael City Council Chambers, Marin Civic Center and downtown San Rafael stations.

All workshops will run from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m.
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/articl...le=SMART-to-hold-workshops-on-station-designs
 
:previous: It seems like they are wasting a lot of time with the station designs. They already had initial designs and more detailed ones. These are just small rail stations with a platform and parking. They are not the Transbay Terminal.
 
:previous: It seems like they are wasting a lot of time with the station designs. They already had initial designs and more detailed ones. These are just small rail stations with a platform and parking. They are not the Transbay Terminal.

I'd rather they take the time now while it's still ink on paper to get the design set correctly than wait and modify the design after work has started. You'd be surprised how much money they can save if they don't have redesigns later. How a station fits in with its surroundings is important as well...
 
NCRA hopes to get OK for freight rail service next month

By STEVE HART
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Wednesday, February 9, 2011 at 6:18 p.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, February 9, 2011 at 6:18 p.m.

( page 1 of 2 )

Federal rail inspectors have finished their review of repairs on the Northwestern Pacific Railroad in Sonoma, Marin and Napa counties, but haven’t decided whether it’s safe to resume freight service on the route.

That decision is expected in March, said Mitch Stogner, director of the North Coast Railroad Authority, the public agency responsible for cargo trains.

The authority wants to resume freight service by the end of March, Stogner said Wednesday. But it’s uncertain whether it will meet that goal.

There are several more legal hurdles to be cleared before trains roll again, the authority’s board learned Wednesday at a meeting in Healdsburg.

Last week, the Federal Railroad Administration finished inspecting 62 miles of track between Napa County and Windsor. The federal agency closed the line in 2001 after storm damage made it too dangerous for train traffic.

Since then, the railroad authority has spent $68 million in state and federal funds to put the line back in operating condition.

NCRA said cargo trains will provide a low-cost alternative for North Bay shippers and take trucks off Highway 101. It plans three round-trip trains per week between Windsor and a rail junction south of Napa where the Northwestern Pacific connects to the national rail network.

On Wednesday, Sonoma County shippers said they’re anxious for cargo service to return.

“Freight is a very important part of our future,” said Dick Caletti of Standard Structures, a Windsor company that makes industrial wood beams.

One rail car can carry three truckloads of freight, said Bill Owens of Korbel Champagne Cellars in Guerneville....
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/articl...-OK-for-freight-rail-service-next-month&tc=ar
 
SMART appoints Heath interim chief
February 18th, 2011

davidheath.jpg

David Heath

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

The Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit agency expects to take up to six months to hire a new general manager, relying for now on its financial officer to keep it on track as it completes a financial plan, starts buying material and begins construction.

David Heath, who left the city of Santa Rosa to become SMART’s chief financial officer a year ago, on Wednesday was named interim general manager to replace Lillian Hames, who resigned unexpectedly Jan. 21.

“He has a great skill set for what we need right now. I am totally confident with him handling it in the interim while we do a search,” said Debora Fudge, a Windsor councilwoman and SMART director. “It is a lot of work and we are lucky he is willing to take it on.”

The appointment of Heath was made after the SMART board met in a closed session.

Fudge said the board still has to identify the qualities it wants in a new general manager.

“What I would be looking for is someone who doesn’t necessarily have to be a technical transit planner, but be able to manage an evolving public agency, how to manage a large board and understand about creating strong relationships with the agencies that will help us with funding needs,” Fudge said.

Heath is paid $165,000 as chief financial officer, but said the board has indicated it might increase his pay to $175,000, which was Hames’ annual salary, while he is the interim general manager.

On Friday, Heath said he has not decided whether he will seek the general manager position. He has not previously worked in rail transportation, but said that he has worked with engineers on facility construction and running bus and paratransit operations.

SMART also will be hiring Erin McGrath, who was briefly SMART’s finance officer before Heath, as a part-time finance officer.

...

The SMART board will hold a workshop at its March 16 meeting in San Rafael to receive the final financial and construction projections. A decision whether to authorize a bond sale and construction bids is scheduled for a special April 6 board meeting.

Directors Wednesday received updated ridership figures, which estimate that trains would carry 5,050 passengers in 2035 along the entire line, which is envisioned as running 71 miles from Cloverdale to Larkspur.

The figures have not changed from estimates SMART made in its 2005 environmental impact report.

The initial rail segment from Santa Rosa to San Rafael is estimated to carry 2,860 passengers a day in 2015. It is scheduled to begin service in the fall of 2014.

....
http://www.watchsonomacounty.com/2011/02/transportation/smart-appoints-heath-interim-chief/
 
not about smart directly, but related:

Metrolinx orders DMUs to work airport rail link
01 March 2011

CANADA: The Metrolinx board of directors has approved the purchase of 12 two-car diesel multiple units for Toronto’s future airport rail link from Sumitomo Corp and its partner Nippon Sharyo Inc for C$53m.

The DMUs will be similar to the 18 cars ordered by Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit Authority to work its commuter service between Cloverdale and Larkspur to the north of San Francisco. They will be powered by clean diesel engines meeting the latest EPA Tier 4 emission standards.

The cars will be built at a new Nippon Sharyo plant in Rochelle, Illinois, and will have the capability to be converted to electric traction, at a cost of about C$12m, if the province decides to proceed with plans to electrify the corridor; a feasibility study for this is currently underway....
http://www.railwaygazette.com/index.php?id=44&no_cache=1&tx_ttnews[tt_news]=12892&cHash=8edad53ca2

toronto following in sonoma/marin's footsteps...
 
Better link
http://www.railwaygazette.com/nc/ne...nx-orders-dmus-to-work-airport-rail-link.html

12 2-car DMU trains adds up to 24 cars, larger than SMART's original order of 9 2-car trains. Metrolinx has an option for 6 more 2-car trains. I supposed those could be ordered as EMUs later, or as additional middle cars....

The news article didn't state if Metrolinx was ordering the streamline or blunt nose versions, just similar. Nippon Sharyo is capable of building either...
 
sorry about the bad link guys...

only smart's first phase will be done by 2014. the rest of the line has no estimated completion date as of now.

it will be interesting to compare the livery
 
getting tired of them crying wolf...

just restart freight service already!

Santa Rosa prepares for return of freight trains

By KEVIN McCALLUM
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Tuesday, March 1, 2011 at 3:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Tuesday, March 1, 2011 at 10:52 p.m.

After being derailed for 12 years, freight trains could begin rumbling through Santa Rosa by next month, and city officials want to make sure residents are ready.

The long lapse in service means many people aren’t used to locomotives lumbering along the tracks, and officials don’t want any surprises.

...

There hasn’t been freight service on the former Northwestern Pacific Railroad since 1998, when federal regulators shut the lines. The North Coast Railroad Authority has spent $68 million in state and federal funds repairing 62 miles of track between Windsor and Napa. If they get the OK from federal inspectors, trains could return by mid-April, said Mitch Stogner, executive director of the North Coast Railroad Authority.

In the first year, trains of 15 to 20 cars are expected to run three round-trips a week. They are expected to carry grain, aggregate, timber or other bulk material, said John Williams, president of Northwestern Pacific Co., the company ready to run freight service on the line. Trains will run at about 25 mph, he said. As business grows, trains could grow to up to 60 cars in length, Williams said.

Various city departments are poised to reach out to the community to make sure that homeless people, pedestrians and motorists are aware the trains are returning and to take precautions.

“One of the safety concerns that we all share is that because trains haven’t been around for a while, there are a lot of people that use train tracks as a right of way,” Gossner said.

Crossings are a key concern. There are 11 places in the city where roads cross the tracks. Motorists will have to get used to waiting between one minute and three minutes for trains to pass, Williams said.

Overall, the restoration of service could provide an economic boost for the city, said Mayor Ernesto Olivares.

“I can’t help but think that this is going to be overall a good economic thing for our community as far as moving goods and services,” he said.

...

The wine industry currently ships thousands of cases of wine by truck to American Canyon, where it is transferred to rail cars, said Doug Bosco, a Santa Rosa attorney and former congressman who was responsible for securing the federal funding that helped repair the line.

Standard Structures in Windsor is another type of company that could benefit. It has the ability to construct 120-foot high towers for electrical transmission lines. Those structures are too large to be moved on trucks, but can be moved by rail, Bosco said. “It’ll really open up that sort of opportunity for local people,” said Bosco said.
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110301/ARTICLES/110309920/1350?p=1&tc=pg
 
I know that the bike/pedestrian path is part of the deal and people do not want it delayed, but $42 million dollars for construction? I think it's far more important to get the tracks and stations built.

Worst case: SMART shortfall could grow by $36 million

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

The Sonoma-Marin rail agency today will review a worst-case financial scenario of a funding gap that could widen by $36 million if sales tax revenues remain depressed and ridership falls short.

The shortfall increase from $104 million to $140 million is the latest attempt by the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit agency to assess how much money it will have to build a commute line during a struggling economy.

SMART is using an annual estimate of 3 percent growth in sales tax, which is 1 percent less than its consultant, Beacon Economics, recommends.

With that sales tax revenue, the agency foresees a $104 million difference in what it can raise and what it will cost to build the line, which is scheduled to start up in 2014.

If sales taxes grow at 2 percent and ridership is 10 percent less than forecast, the gap could grow to $140 million.

“If you take a very pessimistic scenario, if things are very bad, and that is not what we are expecting, it could be a $140 million gap and we would have to look at other things to cut,” Coursey said.

SMART estimates that it will cost $470 million to build the initial segment of the line from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to downtown San Rafael.

It includes $142.6 million to reconstruct the track, $53.7 million for the trains, $44.9 million for a maintenance facility, $42 million for systems, $42 million for a bike and pedestrian path, $40.7 million for stations and $34 million to rebuild the bridge over the Petaluma River.

The ability of SMART to purchase construction bonds depends on sales tax revenues from the quarter-cent sales tax voters approved in 2008.

The new financial estimates also eliminate any expectation of receiving $10 million over 20 years in lease payments from the North Coast Railroad Authority, which has been struggling to resume freight service over the line for the past decade.

SMART staff also will present a list of cost savings that total $106 million. They include delaying stations at Corona Road in Petaluma and in Novato, reducing the pedestrian-bike path by two-thirds, refurbishing instead of replacing the Petaluma River bridge and building a smaller maintenance facility.

The SMART board meeting is at 1:30 p.m. at San Rafael City Hall.

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20110315/ARTICLES/110319679/1350?Title=Worst-case-SMART-shortfall-could-grow-by-36-million-
 
This is a typical happens every time "what if" scenario mess up.

SMART should use whatever formula the State of California recommends for issuing bonds. Then sell the bonds accordingly, and use that cash to build their railroad.

It's tough to find sufficient funding when you must raise all of it locally. It wouldn't hurt to ask the Feds for some funds too, whether it'll be FTA "New Starts" or "Small Starts" funding. "New Starts" providing up to 50% of the capital costs is much harder to qualify for, but qualifying becomes easier as the asking % share drops. "Small Starts" funding is easier because there's less funds involved. But if your project doesn't qualify for "New Starts", getting a little funding from "Small Starts" is better than nothing. Maybe enough funding to finish a project....

SMART should have asked for half cent sales tax, not the quarter cent that passed. I don't know of a single transit agency using as little as a quarter cent sales tax to fund a major rail project. Just about all have asked for at least a half cent sales tax. But SMART has already passed that bridge.

If they can successfully find ways to cut $100 Million from a $470 Million project (more than 20%), the project must have been too luxurious to start with.
 
Last edited:
The economy was much better off when the quarter cent sales tax passed, and it looked like it would be enough to fund the project. However, we now know that is not the case. A half cent sales tax would never have passed. The quarter cent took several tries to pass, and even when it did it was by a small margin.
 


Back
Top