SMART discussions


yea, lagunitas does come out with good seasonals, it's hard to keep up with everything they put out! not to get too off topic but have you tried russian river brews? they can be hard to get but their pliny the elder (double ipa) is excellent. the brewmaster vinnie cilurzo is well-renowned and is now making a special beer exclusive to the french laundry restaurant in napa.

ok ok, back on topic:
really, it's the same people complaining as before (surprise surprise!), here are some recent editorials:

Editorial: SMART's leadership needs to deliver

Marin Independent Journal Editorial
Posted: 11/14/2010 07:26:00 AM PST

MARIN VOTERS deserve to be disappointed that the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit train may not start rolling as promised -- a 69-mile commuter service from Cloverdale to the Larkspur Landing ferries.

A historic economic downturn and costly planning mistakes have left that promise in a budgetary hole that is $350 million deep. The only way out is to cut back.

SMART's leaders now are talking about initial service running about 35 miles, from downtown Santa Rosa to the Marin Civic Center, by 2014.

...

The financial realities that seemed obvious then have become crystal clear and unavoidable. Many expectations, in both the private and public sectors, have had to be revamped and scaled back because of the economy. Many more likely will be.

The big question: Can SMART deliver on this plan? Can it eventually deliver on its 2008 promise to voters in two counties who backed a quarter-cent sales increase?

Marin Supervisor Steve Kinsey, who campaigned for passage of the SMART tax, is asking the right questions. He wants to doublecheck SMART's numbers. Taxpayers are already paying for the rail line; plans should be based on real numbers and realistic plans that SMART can deliver.

Voters invested their trust and money in SMART. SMART's leaders need to present a detailed short- and long-term plan in which voters can have confidence.

That confidence has been shaken.

The best way to demonstrate SMART will be a viable transit system serving both counties is to get passenger trains rolling, even on part of the system, by 2014. That includes moving forward with the parallel bike path, which we expect will wind up being used by more people than the trains.

The cost -- a quarter-cent sales tax -- is nominal when one considers the boost to the economy the project could generate in terms of construction work and jobs.

The recession has forced many enterprises, from governments to households, to reevaluate plans and budgets. It's a time that requires living within our means. SMART is not any different.

SMART officials say they only can afford to start with service that would run from downtown Santa Rosa to the Civic Center by 2014 and the promised 69-mile line could be fully completed by 2018.

We understand that times have changed since 2008.

But SMART leaders need to remember that they made a promise to voters, who responded by reaching into their wallets and purses. Now they are making another promise to voters. SMART's leadership needs to prove to voters that they can deliver.
source: http://www.mercurynews.com/opinion/ci_16598513?nclick_check=1

Marin Voice: SMART can't keep its promise to voters
By Mike Arnold

Posted: 11/18/2010 01:50:00 AM PST

THE finances of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit train are in shambles. Even in SMART's rose-colored world, staff finally admitted what has long been known: the agency is unable to construct anything close to what they promised the voters only two years ago.

A $155 million shortfall referred to in September, has suddenly more than doubled to $350 million.

The result: It is necessary to shrink the 70-mile rail line far more than anyone had imagined.

In a weekend meeting that had been promoted for months as a "workshop" at which no action would be taken, the board opted to ignore its own PR and took action to make the ever-shrinking train line official. It designated the Civic Center, not Larkspur, not even downtown San Rafael, as its southern terminus, adopting San Rafael Mayor Al Boro's statement that SMART "must build something" as official policy.

It should be obvious that terminating rail service at the Civic Center was never the plan and, had it been, would have been handily rejected by the voters.

Indeed, it would never have been on the ballot because Marin politicians would not have backed a train that would largely serve Sonoma residents commuting within Sonoma County. But that's exactly what this boondoggle has become.

As it now stands, taxpayers will be committing $600 million to a train to nowhere that will serve no more than a handful of Marin residents and far fewer Sonoma residents than originally touted. Some deal, eh?

...as indicated by a recent column by SMART board members Charles McGlashan and Debora Fudge published in Marin and Sonoma newspapers, the agency has cranked up its PR machine, promoting federal funding as its savior.

Calling the Santa Rosa-to-Marin Civic Center segment the "first" segment is nothing more than a blatant attempt to deceive voters into thinking that there is a "second" segment. In fact, they have no federal funding commitments to significantly close their ever widening funding gap. None.

The McGlashan-Fudge column fails to disclose that SMART was told unequivocally by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission in January that the MTC "cannot support the SMART project" for federal "New Starts" funding. As a consequence, a federal bail-out of this boondoggle is nothing but a pipe dream. With a Republican majority in the House a federal bailout is even less likely.

Voters beware. SMART staff is in a hurry. Their jobs and lucrative pensions are now on the line, tied to the issuance of the largest municipal bond financing in the history of the two counties that is slated for early next year.

An IJ editorial argued that "SMART's leaders need to present a detailed short- and long-term plan in which voters can have confidence." Unfortunately, SMART has shown it is incapable of producing a credible financial forecast.

Marin Supervisor Steve Kinsey has called on the MTC to perform an audit of SMART's finances in hopes of slowing down the financial train wreck. It's time for the rest of the Board of Supervisors to join him and act to protect the fiduciary interests of Marin residents.

The time to act is now. Once the bond is issued there is no turning back and taxpayers will be fleeced for 18 more years, paying for the train to nowhere.

Mike Arnold of Novato is an economist and a leader of Marin Citizens for Effective Transportation, an organization that opposed the train tax.
source: http://www.marinij.com/opinion/ci_16641709

here's the debra fudge/charles mcglashan article:

Marin Voice: SMART on track to fulfill promise
By Debora Fudge and Charles McGlashan

Posted: 11/14/2010 01:37:00 AM PST

WE can understand the disappointment expressed by North Bay residents upon hearing the news that the first segment of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit train and pathway system will be shorter than the full Cloverdale-to-Larkspur plan.

...

But we should all remember this: The project has not changed. SMART will run from Cloverdale to Larkspur. The only thing that has changed is the timeline for making that happen.

In the coming months, construction contracts will be released on what will be the biggest single public project ever undertaken in the North Bay. With a current financial capacity of $350 million, SMART will provide a train and pathway that improve mobility in the North Bay, that benefit the environment by getting people out of their cars, that stimulate the economy with thousands of good jobs, that improve our quality of life by offering alternatives to the congestion of Highway 101.

A train between Santa Rosa and San Rafael will serve the majority of SMART's projected ridership. While many believe SMART will be used mostly by people looking to connect to San Francisco by ferry at Larkspur, the fact is that more than 90 percent of SMART riders are projected to use the system to commute within Sonoma and Marin counties. The proposed initial segment will allow them to do that.

And, until we can provide full train service to the ends of the line, SMART plans to provide station-to-station bus service connecting the train to Larkspur and Cloverdale, and reduced-speed train service to northern Sonoma County.

In 2008, we produced an expenditure plan that showed how, primarily with the sales tax revenues and bonding capacity provided by Measure Q, the SMART system could be completed by Fall 2014. It was a good plan, endorsed by the Transportation Authority of Marin and deemed "reasonable and conservative" by Robert Eyler, the North Bay's leading economist.

But, shortly after 70 percent of Marin and Sonoma voters approved Measure Q, the economy collapsed. Sales tax revenues have plummeted in the last two years, reducing our short- and long-range revenues and shrinking our bonding capacity. Because of this, our plan has changed -- just like the plans of other governments, businesses and individual households have changed in this economy.

A change in our plan, however, does not mean a change in our goal. We are committed to build the complete project. We will start with an initial segment that connects the two most populous cities in our region. If construction bids are favorable -- as many predict they will be -- the initial segment may reach farther south or north. Trains will run by late 2014, as planned, on the initial segment. We estimate it will take another two to four years to complete all of the system.

We are poised to make real a dream that began more than two decades ago, when forward-thinking leaders in this community made a decision to prevent the abandonment of the Northwestern Pacific Railroad corridor and preserve it for public use as an alternative to sitting in traffic on Highway 101.

They knew then that they couldn't resume passenger rail service overnight. But they had a vision for the future, and they acted on that vision. The SMART board also acted on that vision on Nov. 6, when we voted overwhelmingly to move this project forward.

Spread the news: The SMART train is coming.

Windsor Councilwoman Debora Fudge is president of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit District board. Marin Supervisor Charles McGlashan of Mill Valley is a SMART board member and its former president.
source: http://www.mercurynews.com/opinion/ci_16598496
 
i'll have to dig up the source but someone somewhere said they're considering putting the station right into the ferry terminal - wouldn't that be somethin? :)

That's pretty much how it used to be done - look up some pictures of the old streetcar piers in the Bay Area to see how transfers can be done.
 
That's pretty much how it used to be done - look up some pictures of the old streetcar piers in the Bay Area to see how transfers can be done.

yea - i've seen pix of the ferry building in its glory days. they just can't do it like they used to can they?
 
I know some are disappointed, but few rail projects are built entirely at once. The corridors are split into sections for bidding and construction purposes, just like highway projects. SMART is not doing anything far different than what other transit agencies have done in the past.
Of course, not funding all of the corridor at once can bring up disputes in the future. Look at DART's I-3 Orange line disputes today as an example of what can happen. There's always that risk of what is not funded today will never be funded. Promises can't be legally enforced if they aren't written down on paper. The SMART sections not being funded today should get legally enforceable protections that their sections will be built before any new sections or services are initiated (towards Napa Valley).
 
more negativity (notice how so much of it is coming from marin, no offense pg):

Published Sunday, November 21, 2010, by the Marin Independent Journal

Does SMART's 34-mile plan make sense?

By Dick Spotswood
Special to the IJ

The idea behind the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit train plan is solid. A train,
running between Larkspur Ferry and Cloverdale in Northern Sonoma linked with
convenient feeder buses, should serve as the core of 21st-century North Bay
transit.

While the concept is good, its execution has been disappointing.

Rail supporters thought they saw a green light when in 2008 70-percent of
Marin-Sonoma voters backed a half cent sales tax to fund the line.

Right after the "Crash of 2008" events started to go very wrong.

With the recent decision to cut the proposed 69-mile line to a virtually useless
34-mile segment between Santa Rosa's Railroad Square and Marin's Civic Center,
the question is whether SMART can ever deliver its bright promise.

Marin supervisors are prudently reviewing options. SMART has a small time window
before the public gives up and demands a vote terminating the tax. While
two-thirds super-majorities are needed to pass taxes, a simple majority can axe
them.

Problem one was that SMART's staff, headed by general manager Lillian Hames,
underestimated the cost of placing the train and its parallel bikeway in
service. Voters were told that construction and equipment costs would total $540
million.

After post-election engineering, those estimates soared to $700 million.

Problem two was the Great Recession. Tough economic times decreased sales tax
receipts, the agency's prime source of funds.

Over the next 20 years, SMART will receive $140 million less in sales tax
revenue than initially projected.

To finish the job as promised will cost an additional $290 million SMART doesn't
have.

This shortfall can't be filled by California's deficit-plagued state government.
With the Republican landslide, the cash is unlikely to come from Washington.

In politicized national politics, transit and passenger rail are considered
Democratic-urban-suburban issues which prompt immediate Republican opposition.

With no funding for the Larkspur Ferry-to-Civic Center and Santa
Rosa-to-Cloverdale sections, for the foreseeable future the promised 69-mile
program will exist only in SMART backers' most optimistic dreams.

Skipping the ferry terminal is bad enough, but stopping short of Central San
Rafael is a blunder. It's mostly due to failure to foresee the $10 million cost
to seismically rehabilitate the Puerto Suello Hill tunnel.

Amazingly, the San Rafael City Council meekly accepted the cutback without a
whimper. This, even though the rail-bus hub was intended to be the green
centerpiece of transforming downtown San Rafael into a vibrant commercial
center.

...

An abbreviated 34-mile railroad stopping short of central San Rafael and
northern Sonoma makes little fiscal or transportation sense. Those cutbacks
eliminate 43 percent of projected train riders.

What to do? SMART needs a fresh approach. Its staff initially developed the
ideal commuter train and then asked how much it cost. It got it backwards. SMART
now needs to ask what's the best Downtown San Rafael-Northern Sonoma rail system
that the available $350 million can buy.

...

If SMART can't turn this budding fiasco around pronto, then it's time to
acknowledge that sometimes it is better to do nothing than to do it badly.
source and full article: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/BATN/message/47194

this guy is too much... :whip:
 
Might as well throw in there those retarded oversized tanks on wheels they call their rolling stock of choice that will end up costing twice as much as standard proven off the shelf equipment. This and the Caltrain CBOSS blunder - the misguided ignorant desire to reinvent the wheel is astonishing.
 
Whatever. Someone, somewhere is always going to complain. The folks actually in charge at the city and county level up and down the line have been very mature and cooperative in their approach to the funding issue. There wasn't a huge public battle between supervisors fighting for their respective stations. That's all that matters. Groups that were against it from the beginning are taking advantage of this setback to make some noise. They'll continue to do so 20 years from know when we've all been using the system for a decade. I don't pay them any attention.
 
Marin officials want new studies on viability of SMART

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Monday, November 29, 2010 at 6:08 p.m.
Last Modified: Monday, November 29, 2010 at 6:08 p.m.

In a move that is reopening old political wounds with Sonoma County, some Marin County officials are pushing Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit to defer its start-up plans until the plan and sales tax projections are subjected to an outside review.

Judy Arnold, chairwoman of the Marin County Board of Supervisors, said additional scrutiny is needed because SMART has decided to build the commuter rail line in segments in response to a $350 million funding shortfall.

The system, which was originally designed to carry passengers from Cloverdale to Larkspur, will initially stretch from Santa Rosa to the Marin Civic Center in northern San Rafael. The agency plans to extend service to Cloverdale and Larkspur two to four years after the rail line opens in 2014.

“I am looking out for Marin County,” said Arnold, who is also a SMART director. “For a train to go from Novato to northern San Rafael will do precious little. It should go to the San Rafael Transit Center, where there is connectivity with buses.”............

source and full article: http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20101129/ARTICLES/101129508/1350?Title=Marin-officials-want-new-studies-on-viability-of-SMART
 
SMART planners select Guerneville Road site

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Commute rail planners settled on a new site for a northern Santa Rosa station that is closer to housing, government, schools and shopping and cheaper by $3 million than one in a previous plan.

The location on Guerneville Road east of the railroad tracks is about half a mile from Coddingtown Mall.

It will cost the rail agency $12.2 million to build the station and acquire needed property on Guerneville Road where two stores are located, Sonoma Kitchen & Bath and Kelly-Moore paints.

The location is a half mile north of the initial site near Jennings Avenue, which was a former railroad junction called a “wye” and was heavily contaminated. That site would have cost $3 million more, not counting possible environmental cleanup.

“This is the best site for the station,” said Debora Fudge, Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit chairwoman, on Wednesday. “It is better for buses and it gets us away from the contamination of the wye site.”


A map showing the two proposed locations of a SMART station in northern Santa Rosa

SMART planning manager John Nemeth said SMART could scale back the Guerneville station by more than half, saving $6.7 million, by acquiring just the Kitchen & Bath store and providing less parking in a first phase.

The savings could help SMART build a longer line for a first phase of construction, scheduled to be open in 2014.

SMART’s board on Nov. 6 adopted a controversial plan to begin service from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to the Civic Center in San Rafael, instead of the 70-mile line from Cloverdale to Larkspur that had been envisioned.

The truncated line is necessitated by a $350 million gap in what district’s sales tax, depressed by the economy, can raise and what the 70-mile line is estimated to cost.

However, SMART officials hope to go out to bid early next year to take advantage of the economic downturn’s affect on construction, which has caused bids on highway and other public works projects to come in 20 to 30 percent below estimates.

The hope is lower bids could allow SMART to open an initial line that goes to Guerneville Road or Windsor to the north and downtown San Rafael to the south.

“In the near term, we would continue to do station design work, but not buy property until a formal decision to extend the line,” Nemeth said.

The cost of extending the line 2.5 miles from Railroad Square to the Guerneville Road site is estimated to cost $24 million, half of which is for the station.

The Guerneville Road site is preferable because it is closer to the Sonoma County Administration Center, Santa Rosa Junior College, Coddingtown Mall, bus service, businesses and homes than the Jennings site, according to Nemeth’s report.

Codding Enterprises, which co-owns Coddingtown Mall with Simon Properties, paid $40,000 for the study.

The study does not take into account proximity to a bicycle and pedestrian bridge Santa Rosa was planning to build over Highway 101 from near Coddingtown to the Santa Rosa Junior College.

The new station site is slightly farther away from the proposed bridge, which is now mired in controversy at the Santa Rosa City Council.

SMART’s real estate committee Wednesday approved amending the environmental impact report for the Guerneville Road site. It will go to the full board Dec. 15.

source: http://www.watchsonomacounty.com/2010/12/featured-articles/smart-planners-select-guerneville-road-site/
 
Has this ever been posted? It's a PDF showing all the schematics and background info on the DMU bidders. It concludes with a write up and rendering of the chosen but ugly and inefficient Sumintomo tank on rails FRA compliant DMU: http://www.sonomamarintrain.org/userfiles/file/Vehicle%20recommendation%202010-10-25.pdf

The Sumitomo design isn't that bad, and it looks a lot less clumsy than many of their Japanese models.

They were also the lowest bidder, so as I understand it, if SMART had chosen another manufacturer, it would have forced the planners to cut back even more on the track length and station amenities.

The logo of SMART is a piece of retro-railroad schlock, and the paint scheme looks very British. The carbody is pretty decent, though.
 
great find busy bee! i'll have to say though that the nippon sharyo - sumitomo train design is the best by far. stadler would have required a power unit and the caf and seimens trains look weird.

plus the paint job is perfect - classy but not corny:

smartdesign.jpg

source: http://www.sonomamarintrain.org/userfiles/file/Vehicle recommendation 2010-10-25.pdf

EDIT: i'm so glad they're going with this design. knowing this is what the sonoma/marin train is going to look like has made my day! also, good call on the guerneville rd site - makes more sense. good for smart. :)
 
Last edited:
San Rafael tunnel opens along SMART rail line



A tunnel through Cal Park Hill in San Rafael for Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit trains and for bicyclists and pedestrian is now open.

The gates were opened to the bike and pedestrian tunnel Friday, which is essentially a mini-tunnel inside the main tunnel that will eventually serve the trains.

For SMART, it was one of its first major projects to be completed, even though it is not clear when commute trains will be running as far south as Larkspur.

For Marin County, it removes a key obstacle in the county's North-South Greenway that runs from the Golden Gate Bridge to Novato, said Andy Peri of the Marin County Bicycle Coalition.

“The Cal Park hill tunnel is very, very important link. It was a barrier to bike and pedestrian movement between north and south,” Peri said. “Bike riders would have to cross a freeway on-ramp and off-ramp and it is an extremely dangerous intersection.”

The rebuilding of the railroad tunnel, which had partially collapsed after a fire in the 1990s, cost $27.7 million.

The major portion of the cost was paid for by $13 million in Bay Area Toll Bridge money that went to SMART and $7 million to Marin County. Other funds include $3 million in federal funds, $1.5 million from the Bay Area Regional Air Quality Management District, $1.4 million from the state, and $300,000 from Marin County.

source: http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20101213/SPORTS101/101219840/1350?Title=San-Rafael-tunnel-opens-along-SMART-rail-line
 
the cal park hill tunnel looks good - i like how the trail is a completely separate tunnel-within-a-tunnel. seems like it will be much safer that way. you'll notice in the picture there's even a fire hydrant by the opening. of course fire is a tunnels worst enemy but it makes the trail look like an actual road.

also seeing that picture again of the (potential) new smart railcars just gets me so excited. :) i never imagined the same company that made shinkansens could be making the smart cars here. we'll hopefully find out wednesday:

SMART to consider buying train cars at Wednesday meeting

THE PRESS DEMCORAT

Published: Sunday, December 12, 2010 at 6:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Sunday, December 12, 2010 at 8:19 a.m.

The Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit board is meeting Wednesday to consider buying trains, at a total cost of $56.8 million, and to move toward issuing construction bonds next spring.

The board also will discuss a request by the Marin County Board of Supervisors to delay entering into any contracts or selling bonds until there is an independent review of SMART's sales tax projections. Regional transportation planners are currently undertaking just such a study....
http://www.pressdemocrat.com/articl...nsider-buying-train-cars-at-Wednesday-meeting

boo marin supervisors.
 
Last edited:
I also think Marin politicians are over-stepping their authority. Whether the train authority has enough financial resources or not isn't their job, it's the job of the SMART board. All along, the SMART board has been updating the public as tax revenues have fallen from previous expectations. The SMART board has been responding to the drop in tax revenues as it is being reported to them as well. The SMART board has already asked the Regional Council to audit their projections.
Of course they are smarting from the SMART's board apparent choice to build a shorter rail line initially. But it is wrong for them to suggest that the SMART board has been fiddling around doing nothing during this financial slump. The SMART board has actually been trying to build train services that they can afford to build and run.
 
Well here is some pretty sweet news :cheers:

San Rafael to get SMART
Board OKs train order for $56.8 million

By BOB NORBERG
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Published: Wednesday, December 15, 2010 at 7:56 p.m.
Last Modified: Wednesday, December 15, 2010 at 7:56 p.m.

The North Bay commute line will still be built in stages, but commute planners on Wednesday vowed to extend the Marin County terminus from the Civic Center to downtown San Rafael.

“It will add $38 million to the initial segment cost, but it is the right thing to do,” said Debora Fudge, chairwoman of the Sonoma-Marin Area Rail Transit district.

That new strategy and the presentation of two independent analyses of SMART's sales tax projections demanded by Marin board members appeared to heal a rift that had developed between the two counties over the past month.

“I think we are back on track,” said Judy Arnold, a SMART director and chairwoman of the Marin County Board of Supervisors.

Another major action in the four-hour meeting was the unanimous decision by the SMART board to purchase trains from Sumitomo Corp. of America, a $56.8 million order for nine two-car trains.

“It's a big day,” said Fudge, who signed the purchase contract after the meeting. “You look forward to a day like this, you work toward it for five years, when you take the vote, it was almost surreal, it is a positive step forward.”

Sumitomo Corp., the financial partner of Nippon Sharyo, a Japanese rail car builder, was the low bidder to provide the cars. Called Diesel Multiple Units, the individually powered cars have the weight and design to withstand crashes and will meet 2015 federal emission regulations.

The aluminum shells of the cars will be built in Nippon Sharyo's plant in Japan and shipped to a new plant being constructed in Rochelle, Ill., for final assembly, satisfying federal Buy America standards.

In what has been a contentious issue that divided Marin and Sonoma directors, the SMART board deferred taking final action on issuing $250 million in bonds for construction and operating expenses until January.

Instead, it ordered it staff to work with SMART's financial advisers to come up with new estimates after reviews by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission and by Sonoma State University economist Robert Eyler on the initial estimates.

Those reviews were done at the insistence of the Marin County Board of Supervisors and Marin's members on the SMART board, creating a controversy that threatened to derail the line.

“They provided a realistic assessment,” said Arnold. Marin's board of supervisors had asked SMART to delay its plans until outside reviews were done.

SMART's consultant had estimated that over the 20-year life of the quarter-cent sales tax, which was approved by voters in November 2008, there would be enough money to raise $193 million to $213 million in a bond sale, depending on the interest rate.

Eyler, a principal of Economic Forensics and Analytics, said the Beacon report was theoretically sound, but he felt it should be more conservative, specifically in its projections of population growth.

“You have to be careful of how conservative you become, you could miss the boat,” Eyler said.

The MTC report, however, projected that the bond sales would more likely result in funding of $151 million to $210 million, widening the gap between what SMART wants to build and what it can afford.

The regional transportation agency recommended that SMART staff and advisors review and revise their figures.

MTC also reviewed the cost of constructing the initial line approved by the SMART board on Nov. 6. The line would run from Railroad Square in Santa Rosa to the Civic Center in San Rafael and was estimated to cost $395 million.

One of MTC's consultants, the National Constructors Group, estimated it would be $49 million less, while a second, Parsons Brinckerhoff, estimated it would cost $20 million more.

However, MTC strongly recommended that SMART run the line to downtown San Rafael, connecting the two largest cities in Sonoma and Marin counties and serving the most riders.

“The initial segment may be the only operable segment that you have for some time, and we think that you should connect the two downtowns,” said Alix Bockelman, MTC director of programming and allocations.

Bockelman said that if necessary, SMART could eliminate the stations at Corona Road in Petaluma and in northern Marin County to make up the difference, which could be $42 million to $50 million.

MTC staff said there is $22 million in Bay Area Toll Bridge funds that could be directed toward the San Rafael extension.

MTC said it will work with SMART to find more money, recommending that local and regional funds that are unallocated or have been earmarked for projects that are stalled could be redirected to SMART.

“We believe the shortfall to be $62 million to $125 million to build to downtown San Rafael,” Bockelman said. “We view this gap as manageable.”

http://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/20101215/ARTICLES/101219671/1349?p=3&tc=pg
 
:tup: great news. finally (almost) everyone is happy.

“We view this gap as manageable.” :jester:

now does anybody got an extra 125 million just lying around anywhere?
 


Back
Top