SMART discussions


A train between Santa Rosa and San Rafael will serve the majority of SMART’s projected ridership. While many believe SMART will be used mostly by people looking to connect to San Francisco by ferry at Larkspur, the fact is that more than 90 percent of SMART riders are projected to use the system to commute within Sonoma and Marin counties.

Count me as one of those making the same assumption. I fully expected the ferry terminal to be the single largest demand driver on the line. That made me really concerned about stopping at the Civic Center, as it would suppress ridership in the initial stage and hurt the timeline for finishing the project. Glad to hear their ridership studies say otherwise. I hope they're right!

I read somewhere (probably the MIJ) that the next priority will be to build north to Healdsburg, and the last segment will be to Larkspur. A lot of work has been done between the Civic Center and Larkspur, but I guess the Puerto Suello Hill Tunnel is a major stumbling block. Turns out to be a much larger job than they first thought. At least with the Cal Park Hill Tunnel coming back online soon, the bike/ped path will get you all the way to Larkspur with just a short on-street segment around the Civic Center (which is very safe for riding) and another along Lincoln in San Rafael (which is a crappy street to ride on, but at least it's much shorter now).
 
:previous: I would expect the line from Santa Rosa to Cloverdale to be completed before the Larkspur section. The towns north of Santa Rosa are small bedroom communities (except maybe Windsor) with many people commuting South for work. I would think these people have a much greater need for SMART than the people in Southern Marin County. Plus there aren't any tunnels that need to be built up there. The railway just needs to be refurbished.
 
I hope this is not too much to ask, but can someone give me Cliff's notes on all of this SMART info? Is SMART a go, tentative, on hold, etc?

I am a newer SF resident, and I would love to travel in Marin and Sonoma without renting a car.
Thanks!
 
I hope this is not too much to ask, but can someone give me Cliff's notes on all of this SMART info? Is SMART a go, tentative, on hold, etc?

I am a newer SF resident, and I would love to travel in Marin and Sonoma without renting a car.
Thanks!

Sonoma & Marin voters approved the rail line in 2008, so it's a go. Unfortunately the revenue needed to ensure full funding of the line for completion in 2014 isn't up to where it was initially projected to be. So now they're only going to open the line in segments. For you in San Francisco, I guess you'll have a take a ferry to Larkspur and then hop on a bus to Civic Center in San Rafael where you can once again make another transfer onto the train to get further north. Or I suppose you can take a bus across the Golden Gate Bridge to San Rafael and transfer to the train there. Seems kind of disappointing that the initial train segment doesn't connect downtown San Rafael to Santa Rosa. If it's true that 90% of projected riders would be using the rail line for travel between Santa Rosa and the Civic Center, then I guess that means downtown San Rafael isn't much of a draw?
 
Last edited:
^ yea, i don't understand that either, i would've thought downtown san rafael to be a busy station. but maybe not many people work there compared to the civic center or novato business parks.
 
:previous: I would expect the line from Santa Rosa to Cloverdale to be completed before the Larkspur section. The towns north of Santa Rosa are small bedroom communities (except maybe Windsor) with many people commuting South for work. I would think these people have a much greater need for SMART than the people in Southern Marin County. Plus there aren't any tunnels that need to be built up there. The railway just needs to be refurbished.

That last part is what I was getting at above. The expense of the last southern link is probably the main reason they'll do the north segment first. But I disagree about your first statements. Those are tiny little towns up there. There are probably as many people in San Rafael (and San Rafael is a pretty small city) alone than all those small towns north of Santa Rosa combined. Plus the connection to the ferry terminal means a link to the massive job market of SF. If you took the expense out of it, I don't think there's any question you would build to Larkspur first.
 
^ yea, i don't understand that either, i would've thought downtown san rafael to be a busy station. but maybe not many people work there compared to the civic center or novato business parks.

At the Civic Center you also catch Autocad, whatever is left of Industrial Light and Magic and Lucas' two "ranches" in Lucas Valley. That's a lot of the jobs around here. But I'm still surprised because downtown San Rafael has a large business park on its southern edge and many other jobs spread throughout it. Like I said before, I just hope their projections are correct.
 
I hope they are too. I think they are really missing the ball if they aren't going to build this to Larkspur first, I guess it must be a matter of cost.

There have to be thousands of people who would rather not drive over the GG bridge everyday if they could avoid it.
 
^ yea, i don't understand that either, i would've thought downtown san rafael to be a busy station. but maybe not many people work there compared to the civic center or novato business parks.

I think they simply do not have the money to go the extra few miles. It is also a bad location for the train to reverse directions. The station is crammed into a little area downtown. The train needs to switch tracks (even though there are 2 tracks only around the stations) to load passengers going in the other direction.
 
^ i can understand them wanting to go north before going south (cost is definitely a big factor here). yes it will be a greater inconvenience to sf riders, but frankly, sf isn't paying for this, also sonoma voters had almost 10 percent more yes votes than marin county. and while the towns north of santa rosa are (barely) smaller than san rafael (san rafael: 56000 versus 45000: windsor: 27000 + healdsburg: 11000 + cloverdale: 7000) many of the people who live there commute to santa rosa due to a low amount of jobs being there. not to mention the huge tourist draw these towns provide.
they also have brought up the possibility of re-evaluating the larkspur station, perhaps moving it closer to the ferry terminal. i really hope they do that!
 
yes it will be a greater inconvenience to sf riders, but frankly, sf isn't paying for this

It has nothing to do with people from SF. It has to do with residents of the North Bay getting to their jobs in SF.

they also have brought up the possibility of re-evaluating the larkspur station, perhaps moving it closer to the ferry terminal. i really hope they do that!

Amen to that! I'm really excited about this possibility.
 
I think they simply do not have the money to go the extra few miles. It is also a bad location for the train to reverse directions. The station is crammed into a little area downtown. The train needs to switch tracks (even though there are 2 tracks only around the stations) to load passengers going in the other direction.

If they could get to downtown San Rafael, they would just go all the way to Larkspur where turning around won't be an issue. That stretch is mostly ready to go. They just have to redo a couple of grade crossings. Oh, and build a station in Larkspur. :) The big expense is repairing the Puerto Suello Hill Tunnel, which sits between the Civic Center and downtown.
 
It has nothing to do with people from SF. It has to do with residents of the North Bay getting to their jobs in SF.

my point exactly! (my comment was a response to cybereric's complaint, though i meant it both ways). i've always felt that golden gate transit (or the mtc, or somebody) should contribute since this will undoubtedly increase ferry passengers. yea i know, wishful thinking since they're all broke too.
and i know the situation is slightly different in marin, but hardly anybody in sonoma works in san francisco anymore - the commute is just too hard and expensive ($6 toll?!). i think people looking for cheap housing live in solano now ;)

Amen to that! I'm really excited about this possibility.

i'll have to dig up the source but someone somewhere said they're considering putting the station right into the ferry terminal - wouldn't that be somethin? :)
 
I saw a quote to that effect from Marin Supervisor and SMART board member Charles McGlashan in the MIJ: "The challenges of getting south of the Civic Center are significant. Getting to Larkspur later maybe allows us to re-envision the Larkspur station. Maybe we could go over Sir Francis Drake and get into the ferry terminal."

Too many "maybes" in that statement, but I'll take it! Thinking rationally though, bridging the Frankie D (as I like to call it) is going to be expensive. If they can't afford to rehab a tunnel, I don't know how they're going to build a new bridge from scratch. Plus, I can't see where they'd route it, to be honest. But I'll hold out hope.

I can see why we disagree on the need to get to the terminal if Sonoma residents don't work down there. But Marin is pretty much a bedroom community for the Financial District, and we're paying for this too. It's all moot though since the expense is the key thing. That article I linked to above highlights other expenses beyond the tunnel I must have glossed over the first time I read it.

Another thing I've been thinking about: In terms of fairness, I think it makes sense to finish off the north first. That's a large percentage of the total Sonoma mileage up there. CC to Larkspur is a much shorter stretch. So in terms of what each county was promised compared to what they're getting in the first phase, I think it's much more fair to go north first.
 
Last edited:
Reading that quote above and quotes from officials in Healdsburg and Cloverdale, I must say I'm extremely impressed with the approach everyone is taking. Once they were forced to phase the project, you would think there would be tons of public sniping back and forth between cities arguing for their town to be included first. But there has been none of that. Everyone seems to be thinking of the greater good and I love seeing that in our elected officials.

Hey northbay, when this thing is done we're meeting for a beer in downtown Petaluma!
 
beer/wine + transportation talk = heaven :D

petaluma has some good spots downtown. there's also lagunitas brewing company (they make a great ipa) but they're on the other side of the freeway

btw. there certainly has been a lot of complaining about smart not following thru on their promises blah blah... but all things considered i think people realize it's not a matter of IF, but WHEN. waiting a couple more years is no biggie since we've been waiting for how many decades now?
 
Sounds good, Eric!

I love Lagunitas! They make a great everything and I've been there many times. I especially love their many varieties of stout and that they are always trying new things. Mendocino Brewing Co and Lagunitas are probably my two favorite brewers. I think the Corona Rd station will be close enough to walk over to the beer sanctuary. We can do a whole beer and wine tour of the North Bay! Then someday we can hit up the Hamburger Ranch in Cloverdale.

I guess I've missed the complaining officials. Everything I've read from politicians has been very objective and rational. Even those in towns who are getting cut out of the first phase. I avoid the comments sections of newspaper websites, so probably missing most of the bitching because of that.
 


Back
Top