Septa


Wheelingman04

Pittsburgh rocks!!
What is your opinion of Philadelphia's transit network?
What about the regional rail commuter lines?
Are there any expansion plans?

I read that the Philadelphia EL and subway are getting new trains.
 
I'm jealous of regional rail that actually comes frequently and provides all day service.

MARC and VRE pale in comparison.
 
I'm jealous of regional rail that actually comes frequently and provides all day service.

MARC and VRE pale in comparison.

By many measures, WMATA is regional rail, with even more frequent service than SEPTA's regional lines. I mean the final 25% or so of almost every branch of Metrorail is undeniably through "suburban" areas. SEPTA's rapid transit by contrast is almost strictly urban; arguably the most urban-confined heavy rail rapid transit system in the country, moreso than even MBTA or CTA because of the latter twos' more recent suburban-ish extensions. SEPTA regional rail serves as the main transit artery for many areas denser than the typical suburban fringe (Fairfax....Rockville....etc.) served by WMATA.

Of course, ultimately Metrorail is a hybrid commuter/rapid transit system, not dissimilar to BART but more urban-focused.

But your point is still taken, I mean of course it'd be nice if MARC and VRE, the traditional commuter rail, had more frequent service.
 
Philly's SEPTA system suffers from a situation that almost every American transit system suffers from. And that is transit coverage in the suburbs is very very poor or not even provided. The majority of suburban Philly residents can not rely on transit as they do not live within walking distance of a bus route or regional rail station.
And those that do have to put up with buses that run every hour at best in most cases, or just a couple times a day.

If you are in the city of Philly, you can rely on SEPTA.

SEPTA does however need to work on frequency of service on the subway and L network.

And in addition they need massive work done on their management, budgets, and their image. SEPTA aside from the Regional Rail network is basically known as a last resort form of travel, due to their very bad image in the region for not being well operated.

I remember being in Philly and having to beg to ride SEPTA into Center City. Our relatives there had stopped taking it years ago due to SEPTA's service cuts, fare increases, and poor management. And I was in a neighbourhood with direct trolley service to Center City. My ride on the trolley showed mostly a captive ridership that had no other choice but to ride SEPTA.

Great bones but SEPTA needs a massive overhaul of management.
 
I have mixed feelings about SEPTA. From a Transit Fan point of view, I absolutely love the various modes available in the area, and the history of transit in Philly/Camden. I had a great time riding transit when I was out there, and couldn't get enough for the Red Arrow routes, and the Norristown line.

But from a passenger point of view, SEPTA is lacking. The Weekend service on the subway needs to be improved. The fare structure is AWFUL. I cannot emphasize this. It needs to be fixed. Paying a fare on the subway, THEN paying another fare after transfering to the Red Arrow, and Norristown lines is just stupid. And the connections between the Broad Line, and Market line?
*gag*

I have to agree with Mike here. I think SEPTA needs rebranding. It's image seems pretty bland to me.

Wheelingman" The Market-Frankford got new Trains recently. I assume you are referring to the Broad Street line?
 
I've never personally taken SEPTA, but I've run across a few tidbits on the system on a study I'm doing (commuter train from Lehigh Valley/Poconos to NYC). From what I've read, there used to be SEPTA buses and commuter trains running from the Lehigh Valley area going through the northern Philadelphia suburbs; the tracks still exist,I think, but the service has been long gone. That's really the extent of my knowledge of SEPTA.

The major problem is not lack of transportation to Philadelphia from the suburbs, but that suburban commuters don't work in Philadelphia because their jobs are elsewhere. The city just doesn't have that many white-collar jobs or large offices.

Case in point: Philadephia is about 20 or 30 miles closer to the Lehigh Valley than the next closest major city, NYC. The commuter bus service from the Lehigh Valley to Philadelphia runs only 2 buses during rush hours, each way.

Contrast this to the LV to NYC Port Authority Terminal service: during rush hours, there are about 22 scheduled buses running between the two areas each way. In addition, there are 9 rush hour buses from LV to Wall Street, and 7 rush hour buses from other Pennsylvania suburbs to NYC.

And that bus line that ran only 2 buses from LV to Philadelphia: it runs 9 rush hour buses to NYC.

It's all about commuting demand, and Philadelphia simply doesn't have it.


One more thing: I've read somewhere that Philadelphia was notorious for basically driving out startup businesses through a draconian tax structure and fees for the longest time. Ed Rendell, when he was their mayor, managed to bring in some new businesses by softening the taxes and fees, but his successor brought them back.
 
I haven't been a regular SEPTA rider since the late 80s but at that time the service from the Main Line (R5 Paoli at the time) was great. I was also close to the Norristown High Speed Line so I had two options to get into Center City. That was after they had connected the old Reading and Pennsylvania Railroad lines at Market East and started the commuter rail connection to the airport.

I understand things have slid since then.
 


Back
Top